Live data from Hacker News

Why Alcohol Is Good for You

wired.com

1–10 of 46 posts

Re: Why Alcohol Is Good for You

#2
Summary: the author of the article speculates that moderate alcohol consumption leads people to socialize and not be lonely. People who are lonely are more likely to die from "just about everything." There's no actual study done here -- the author only references other studies. This article is about the author's hypothesis.

Re: Why Alcohol Is Good for You

#3
These studies that whet the appetite for 'sin secrets' are entertaining, but that's about it. I favor reductionism. Maybe it's not forced brain evolution or African-plain-life recreation. Maybe it's because when you drink you tend to eat less, which is, good.

Re: Why Alcohol Is Good for You

#4
post #2

Summary: the author of the article speculates that moderate alcohol consumption leads people to socialize and not be lonely. People who are lonely are more likely to die from "just about everything." There's no actual study done here -- the author only references other studies. This article is about the author's hypothesis.

thanks for the tldr.

btw tldr

Re: Why Alcohol Is Good for You

#6

These studies that whet the appetite for 'sin secrets' are entertaining, but that's about it. I favor reductionism. Maybe it's not forced brain evolution or African-plain-life recreation. Maybe it's because when you drink you tend to eat less, which is, good.

The only inherent advantage in eating less is getting fewer calories; alcohol has a substantial number of calories itself, so no benefit there.

Re: Why Alcohol Is Good for You

#7
Correlation does not strictly mean causation. Our statistics professor brought this example once, he explained it that people who don't drink (in a western society) have often problems with their health or are taking medication. Statistics could be often misleading.

Another example was that people with bigger feet were more likely to be earn more money. Guess why?

Re: Why Alcohol Is Good for You

#8
post #2

Summary: the author of the article speculates that moderate alcohol consumption leads people to socialize and not be lonely. People who are lonely are more likely to die from "just about everything." There's no actual study done here -- the author only references other studies. This article is about the author's hypothesis.

This article, similar to "The Web Is Dead", is about nothing more than link baiting. Wired has been going down hill as of late.

Re: Why Alcohol Is Good for You

#9
Since I've taken up light drinking almost entirely for the health benefits, and since I don't drink socially, I hope this hypothesis isn't really the answer. The other day when a co-worker was trying to get me to go to a scotch tasting, he said, "What, do you only drink at home, alone, in the dark?!" I replied that it wasn't usually dark... :)

Re: Why Alcohol Is Good for You

#10
Complete abstinence from alcohol is also correlated with lower education level and poverty. People with less certainty and control over their lives are more likely to distrust alcohol, justifiably -- the risk that comes with it is more serious for them.
Post reply on HN