Live data from Hacker News

YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

bloomberg.com

71–80 of 295 posts

Re: YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Uniformization" sounds like a better fit, if we are searching for a more conventional word.

Or “Homogenization”

I think this is the more established term.

Re: YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

#72
post #13
post #10

I'm not sure I understand. Are these sites paying with cryptocurrencies or is the content delivery based on blockchains? The article is a bit vague about this.

The article is shit, that's for sure. Only the payment is via cryptocurrency. The content delivery is as centralized as ever, so this does not change anything wrt to "privacy concerns, censorship".

It uses IPFS for hosting, IPFS stores hashes on a blockchain. IPFS is according to wikipedia a distributed file system.

Re: YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

#74
post #52
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Such a big problem with people hoping to be rewarded with political influence. Even Paul McCartney has been diluting Youtube with extremist videos[1] about veganism. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnNFryHonQo

I think I just triggered a Vegan :) I have respect for Vegans despite being a huge meat lover. What I mean by extremism is that Vegans are extreme and controversial form certain philosophies and eating habits and those serious about Veganism more often than not claiming that people who eat meat are murderers and should be treated as such, framing this as "Us the spotless goodies vs them unredeemable baddies". In my b…

I think you may be conflating vegans in general with extremist vegans. Perhaps most normal vegans simply don't create YouTube content.

Re: YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

#75
post #52
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Such a big problem with people hoping to be rewarded with political influence. Even Paul McCartney has been diluting Youtube with extremist videos[1] about veganism. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnNFryHonQo

I think I just triggered a Vegan :) I have respect for Vegans despite being a huge meat lover. What I mean by extremism is that Vegans are extreme and controversial form certain philosophies and eating habits and those serious about Veganism more often than not claiming that people who eat meat are murderers and should be treated as such, framing this as "Us the spotless goodies vs them unredeemable baddies". In my b…

We already have Quorn burgers and they're great. The problem with going vegan isn't burgers; it's decent cheese, and milk to put in my tea. And something to replace eggs in cake. And something to make boots out of if veganism is to go beyond food. I hope these problems will be solved one day.

We can't stop animals from getting harmed. They harm each other in the wild in terrible ways. All we can do is keep our own hands and mouths clean and avoid trashing the environment with livestock farming on an industrial scale.

Re: YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You certainly don't need blockchains and distributed databases to reward creators, centralized solutions like Patreon work perfectly fine. If you want Netflix style monetization, that is not a technical problem but a social one, Netflix relies on the concept of copyright. Any community that does not respect copyright will switch to the free alternative, leaving voluntary donations as the only monetization option. May…

I don't agree with your Netflix story. Most people don't prefer free, they prefer convenience. Spotify almost works properly as a centralized platform because almost all music is on there. But I know a few albums that aren't, and it's too bad. For Netflix, I have a subscription. But guess what I do when I want to watch the latest Walking Dead or Game of Thrones. I want it convenient, preferably legal, but most of all…

How is subscribing to HBO inconvenient?

It's a combination of price and convenience. There's some upper limit to the monthly price you (and everyone else) is willing to pay for content.

Re: YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

#77

The blockchain-based alternative to Twitter, peepeth.com is worth mentioning too I've been using it since 10 days, it's really well made

There is also the holochain-based Twitter alternative, Clutter:

https://github.com/holochain/clutter

Holochain is a blockchain alternative designed to avoid blockchain’s scalability and energy consumption issues.

Re: YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

#78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You certainly don't need blockchains and distributed databases to reward creators, centralized solutions like Patreon work perfectly fine. If you want Netflix style monetization, that is not a technical problem but a social one, Netflix relies on the concept of copyright. Any community that does not respect copyright will switch to the free alternative, leaving voluntary donations as the only monetization option. May…

I don't agree with your Netflix story. Most people don't prefer free, they prefer convenience. Spotify almost works properly as a centralized platform because almost all music is on there. But I know a few albums that aren't, and it's too bad. For Netflix, I have a subscription. But guess what I do when I want to watch the latest Walking Dead or Game of Thrones. I want it convenient, preferably legal, but most of all…

For Game of Thrones it's not such an issue, but I do feel bad if there's e.g. an old BBC film I want to watch, but there's no way to get it legally, sometimes at all. Other times it's £20 for a DVD. No way I'm paying three months of Netflix subscription (or a large fraction of a license fee) for that.

The BBC has such an extensive and amazing back catalogue of content they wholly own. Why they don't chuck it on iPlayer is beyond me. I know they have it all on a digital platform internally already, format is not an issue.

Re: YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

#79

Yours.org is is my favorite example of this. Writers of articles receive Bitcoin Cash from the community. Interestingly, it costs Bitcoin Cash to upvote content and comment on things. Presumably this helps combat upvote bots and spammers. Edit: forgot to mention that if you upvote content, later upvotes of the same content earn you money. This incentivizes people to discover and promote new content they think will be…

I find it an interesting concept, but as with so many of these solutions I don't really see why you have to have Bitcoin Cash to make it work. They could charge your credit card for upvotes and pay you in fiat like Patreon does, and the functionality will be exactly the same from the end user's perspective.

Re: YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Powered Rivals

#80
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't agree with your Netflix story. Most people don't prefer free, they prefer convenience. Spotify almost works properly as a centralized platform because almost all music is on there. But I know a few albums that aren't, and it's too bad. For Netflix, I have a subscription. But guess what I do when I want to watch the latest Walking Dead or Game of Thrones. I want it convenient, preferably legal, but most of all…

How is subscribing to HBO inconvenient? It's a combination of price and convenience. There's some upper limit to the monthly price you (and everyone else) is willing to pay for content.

Well for me, in my jurisdiction HBO just simply isn't available. That's hands down about as inconvenient as you can get.

In jurisdictions where it is available it's often only available as a part of a larger cable package. If you're signed up with another provider that's pretty inconvenient also.

There is a well worn cartoon on this topic that sums up the position of many quite well [0]

[0] http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones

Post reply on HN