Live data from Hacker News

Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

friendi.ca

111–120 of 146 posts

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And yet if you said "Or you can pay me directly to use this service," how do you think people would respond? And you literally just described the profession of marketing. So if you replaced the inflammatory phrase "manipulate your thinking" with "market toward you", I think they'd be totally fine with it. I mean, why else do you "Like" something on Facebook anyway unless you want other people to know that you like it…

Well, your whole argument seems to be based on what ill-informed people will tolerate, not was is ethical. I agree marketing is intended to manipulate your thinking... or "market towards you". I suspect I have a different attitude about marketing than you do. I don't use facebook, I used for a week in 2007, and thought "this is just a marketing data machine, no thanks". Further, the innocuous sounding "Connecting the…

I'm very well informed and I'm 100% ok with Facebook using whatever data I put on it.

The fact that some people choose to remain uninformed about what Facebook is doing with the data that these people willfully give them is on those people.

What is ethical in this situation is personal to you, so you can't make a blanket statement that marketing is or not ethical.

Again, to me, it's perfectly ethical, but I'm a big believer in personal responsibility.

As you said, you signed up, saw what Facebook was about and bailed.

That's called personal choice, and it's a wonderful thing.

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

More people believe the world is flat than know what a "decentralized social network" is.

Changing goalposts. chrstphrknwtn was responding to your comment on privacy and now you changed to talking about decentralized social networks. Quote: > I would say 90% or more of Facebook users couldn't care less if their data is sold to advertisers. So, changing goalposts.

How am I changing goalposts?

I'm making the point that "a lot" is a throwaway term.

It's like saying a car is "very fast."

Well, compared to a jet, a car is not fast at all.

Also, "a lot" means something different to me than it does to you.

So saying "a lot" of people do or believe anything is meaningless.

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Tell me why I should care. I don't care if you care. That's your decision. > The same thing happens with loyalty cards at Walgreens. It's not the same thing at all. With loyalty cards I get the OPTION of being rewarded for allowing a company to track me. So I weigh getting rewarded (positive) against sharing my data (negative), and I make a decision. With Facebook there is no option, they track everyone regardless.…

Tell me why anyone should care. You have the option of using Facebook or not. If you don't have a Facebook account, they don't have your data. If you don't have a Walgreens loyalty card, they don't have your data. People are faux outraged. They're not really outraged at all. Check this comment in two months and tell me how "outraged" people are at Facebook for selling their data. It would depend on what kind of "demo…

> If you don't have a Facebook account, they don't have your data.

Not quite true, all the like buttons and other FB integration code for websites and apps still collect your data

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#114

PHP and MySQL...

...successfully runs a vast majority of web services on the internet.

I always love the argument that PHP runs 70% of the web.

Water covers 70% of earth surface, therefore I should build my house on water.

http://i.imgur.com/Fp5pw9o.png

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#115

I think many people that are moving away from Facebook move away from social networks in general. Personally, I am not interested at all in a Facebook replacement. I gave a couple a try, but quickly realized that spending time on these social networks is even more boring than Facebook, especially if none of your friends are on there.. and therefor a total waste of my time. If I need to communicate with friends I do t…

> I think many people that are moving away from Facebook move away from social networks in general [...] If I need to communicate with friends I do this "directly" via WhatsApp or email. I'd like to see the line disappear and I'd like to see WhatsApp or email be considered social networking. I think a well built app can have both of those features in addition to the feed+post+comment style of Facebook. From the user…

Seriously, if Snapchat is considered a social network, IRC/email/WhatsApp/iMessage/Hangouts/SMS is a social network too.

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am pretty sure if Google disappeared we were going to see a huge drop in the email traffic. How would I get to know the new email address of my friend who we only talked using Gmail for example?

> How would I get to know the new email address of my friend who we only talked using Gmail for example? Call him up on the phone or message him on whatsapp or... whatever... email IS decentralised. Even if we had ONLY gmail, a startup could implement a better email frontend and be successful.

How do you call someone on the phone if you only ever talked via Gmail and suddenly don't have any of those messages anymore?

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#117
post #26
post #21

All communities have leaders, whales, whatever you want to call them. Even Bitcoin is now controlled by a small group of mostly Chinese people. Decentralization does nothing other than put control in the hands of an unpredictable and potentially unaccountable group of people, whereas centralized systems have people you can point to and hold accountable (or so we hope). There is a reason it's never worked throughout h…

Like e-mail or the web, perhaps?

It's funny because those are perfect examples of what they are talking about.

Gmail and Cloudflare.

For example, the web makes it cheap and trivial to DoS someone. And you often don't want your origin exposed. Hence everyone using Cloudflare and the collapse of the decentralized dream.

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#118

I think many people that are moving away from Facebook move away from social networks in general. Personally, I am not interested at all in a Facebook replacement. I gave a couple a try, but quickly realized that spending time on these social networks is even more boring than Facebook, especially if none of your friends are on there.. and therefor a total waste of my time. If I need to communicate with friends I do t…

> I think many people that are moving away from Facebook move away from social networks in general [...] If I need to communicate with friends I do this "directly" via WhatsApp or email. I'd like to see the line disappear and I'd like to see WhatsApp or email be considered social networking. I think a well built app can have both of those features in addition to the feed+post+comment style of Facebook. From the user…

Yeah, I'm sure Facebook could build WhatsApp into a trustworthy social networking platform.

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#119
post #78

Sounds interesting, but I don't think PHP & MySQL are a good stack. While it's possible to write secure software in PHP (I'd probably trust the Paragon IE) guys to do it), it's not very likely. As for MySQL — as far as I'm concerned there is essentially no reason to choose it over PostgreSQL, and a project which does so is thus instantly suspect. If they've made an error that grave, what other errors have they made?…

Why do you consider choosing MySQL over Postgres a grave error? There are some cool features in Postgres. I am going to learn more about partial indexes, that looks useful! But there is plenty of precedent for large, successful MySQL projects. Uber, for example, switched from PostgreSQL to MySQL in 2016. https://eng.uber.com/mysql-migration/

Re: Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network

#120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

...successfully runs a vast majority of web services on the internet.

I always love the argument that PHP runs 70% of the web. Water covers 70% of earth surface, therefore I should build my house on water. http://i.imgur.com/Fp5pw9o.png

That's a horrible analogy.
Post reply on HN