Live data from Hacker News

Google Cloud Text-To-Speech Powered by DeepMind WaveNet Technology

cloudplatform.googleblog.com

1–10 of 122 posts

Re: Google Cloud Text-To-Speech Powered by DeepMind WaveNet Technology

#2
The average English word is 4.5 characters and the average English speaker speaks 110-150 words per minute. This means that at $16/1m characters, we can generate speech at a cost between $28.57-39/hr. Per Google's post, WaveNet now costs 50ms of TPU time per 1s of speech generated, meaning, at 100% utilization, a TPU can generate somewhere between $571.40-780/hr. Google's TPUs can be deployed (by third parties) at $6.50/hr. That's some sweet sweet margin.

Re: Google Cloud Text-To-Speech Powered by DeepMind WaveNet Technology

#3

The average English word is 4.5 characters and the average English speaker speaks 110-150 words per minute. This means that at $16/1m characters, we can generate speech at a cost between $28.57-39/hr. Per Google's post, WaveNet now costs 50ms of TPU time per 1s of speech generated, meaning, at 100% utilization, a TPU can generate somewhere between $571.40-780/hr. Google's TPUs can be deployed (by third parties) at $6…

Nice analysis! That's the rub with doing tco analysis. How much value do you put on higher order of manageability?

You should also include a workload volatility component to be entirely fair. Your analysis assumes it's entirely steady state.

(Work at g)

Re: Google Cloud Text-To-Speech Powered by DeepMind WaveNet Technology

#4

The average English word is 4.5 characters and the average English speaker speaks 110-150 words per minute. This means that at $16/1m characters, we can generate speech at a cost between $28.57-39/hr. Per Google's post, WaveNet now costs 50ms of TPU time per 1s of speech generated, meaning, at 100% utilization, a TPU can generate somewhere between $571.40-780/hr. Google's TPUs can be deployed (by third parties) at $6…

I think your math is wrong by a factor of 60. Under your assumptions, one hour of speech is equivalent to 30-40 thousand characters, costing between $0.48-$0.65. That translates to revenue of $9.50-$12.96/hour per TPU.

Re: Google Cloud Text-To-Speech Powered by DeepMind WaveNet Technology

#6
post #5

Are there any voice samples?

You can try it yourself here, just make sure to select English (United States) and Voicetype: Wavenet, as the other languages are not yet using the Wavenet system: https://cloud.google.com/text-to-speech/

Re: Google Cloud Text-To-Speech Powered by DeepMind WaveNet Technology

#7
post #5

Are there any voice samples?

You can try it yourself here, just make sure to select English (United States) and Voicetype: Wavenet, as the other languages are not yet using the Wavenet system: https://cloud.google.com/text-to-speech/

Try changing the pitch by more than +-10 as well, it breaks up quite amusingly

Re: Google Cloud Text-To-Speech Powered by DeepMind WaveNet Technology

#8

The average English word is 4.5 characters and the average English speaker speaks 110-150 words per minute. This means that at $16/1m characters, we can generate speech at a cost between $28.57-39/hr. Per Google's post, WaveNet now costs 50ms of TPU time per 1s of speech generated, meaning, at 100% utilization, a TPU can generate somewhere between $571.40-780/hr. Google's TPUs can be deployed (by third parties) at $6…

"the cloud" is just a better DRM.

Re: Google Cloud Text-To-Speech Powered by DeepMind WaveNet Technology

#9
post #8

The average English word is 4.5 characters and the average English speaker speaks 110-150 words per minute. This means that at $16/1m characters, we can generate speech at a cost between $28.57-39/hr. Per Google's post, WaveNet now costs 50ms of TPU time per 1s of speech generated, meaning, at 100% utilization, a TPU can generate somewhere between $571.40-780/hr. Google's TPUs can be deployed (by third parties) at $6…

"the cloud" is just a better DRM.

How so? They don't sell the model itself, they sell the 'tickets' to allow you to take a picture of it. That is not DRM.

Re: Google Cloud Text-To-Speech Powered by DeepMind WaveNet Technology

#10
post #4

The average English word is 4.5 characters and the average English speaker speaks 110-150 words per minute. This means that at $16/1m characters, we can generate speech at a cost between $28.57-39/hr. Per Google's post, WaveNet now costs 50ms of TPU time per 1s of speech generated, meaning, at 100% utilization, a TPU can generate somewhere between $571.40-780/hr. Google's TPUs can be deployed (by third parties) at $6…

I think your math is wrong by a factor of 60. Under your assumptions, one hour of speech is equivalent to 30-40 thousand characters, costing between $0.48-$0.65. That translates to revenue of $9.50-$12.96/hour per TPU.

I double checked, you are correct:

    16 * (4.5 * 110 * 60) / 1M = $0.475/hr

    16 * (4.5 * 150 * 60) / 1M = $0.648/hr
If you multiply by the number of 50ms in one second (20), you do get $9.5 - $12.96
Post reply on HN