Live data from Hacker News

Facebook's Zuckerberg will not appear before British MPs

bbc.co.uk

11–20 of 130 posts

Re: Facebook's Zuckerberg will not appear before British MPs

#11

Facebooks PR seems all over the place. It seems to go like this: 1) Blame users/say it wasn't as bad/not a breach 2) Controversy gets worse 3) Apologise, say we got it wrong, working on it I think this is especially dumb as FB took out a personally-signed-by-Zuckerberg letter in 6 UK sunday papers last weekend. It looks very fake.

> FB took out a personally-signed-by-Zuckerberg letter in 6 UK sunday papers last weekend

Were they identically worded?

Re: Facebook's Zuckerberg will not appear before British MPs

#12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes is this a new thing? I don't remember in the past the committees being so publicly snide and unpleasant like they seem to be now. Maybe it wasn't televised so prominently before? And the most strange part is how they now have celebrity appearances as well - comedians and actors?

They always let loose a little - you can go back and look at old transcripts and see much the same thing. There's a certain element of it becoming slightly worse due to being televised. In an era where there is a huge gap between government rhetoric and practice, it can be a useful way to signal ones 'principles' even as one files obediently through the government lobby when it comes to voting on actual legislation.

[deleted]

Re: Facebook's Zuckerberg will not appear before British MPs

#13
Arrogant little boy king.

This is a major PR blunder. It's hard to imagine such attitude will make the parliament more lenient. Facebook just played a vital role in the manipulation of British democracy in one of the most important decisions in a century. But the CEO responsible couldn't care to fly over and explain himself. If what Facebook wanted was to be forgiven (or at least forgotten), and to secure more accommodating regulation, they just made that a lot harder for themselves.

Re: Facebook's Zuckerberg will not appear before British MPs

#14

Facebooks PR seems all over the place. It seems to go like this: 1) Blame users/say it wasn't as bad/not a breach 2) Controversy gets worse 3) Apologise, say we got it wrong, working on it I think this is especially dumb as FB took out a personally-signed-by-Zuckerberg letter in 6 UK sunday papers last weekend. It looks very fake.

> FB took out a personally-signed-by-Zuckerberg letter in 6 UK sunday papers last weekend Were they identically worded?

Yes, but it wasn't signed by the CPO, the board, or anyone, they were all signed by Zuckerberg so I think it looks especially fake to take out those ads (which are especially targeted at the 'political class' IMO) and then refuse to come before MPs.

Source: https://cdn.cnn.com/cnnnext/dam/assets/180325071038-01-faceb...

Re: Facebook's Zuckerberg will not appear before British MPs

#15
post #13

Arrogant little boy king. This is a major PR blunder. It's hard to imagine such attitude will make the parliament more lenient. Facebook just played a vital role in the manipulation of British democracy in one of the most important decisions in a century. But the CEO responsible couldn't care to fly over and explain himself. If what Facebook wanted was to be forgiven (or at least forgotten), and to secure more accomm…

Normally I'd think this comment is a bit too lowbrow for the orange site, but I think it's justified in light of just how fundamentally the world shifted due to the Brexit vote. If this breach was part of that then people should be incredibly angry.

Re: Facebook's Zuckerberg will not appear before British MPs

#18
Saying this is a strategic mistake may be a bit too early to tell. It depends on whether this issue will slowly disappear in the media and minds of people (like most things). He has no legal obligation to appear if I understand correctly. The select committee mainly consists of MPs who objected Brexit. Of course they try to make their point that the vote was skewed or manipulated. If, on the other hand, the pressure stays on, it may very well be a strategic mistake not to appear.

Re: Facebook's Zuckerberg will not appear before British MPs

#20
post #4

It feels like Zuck is in panic and listening too much to his PR advisors who are likely telling him to stay out of the public until the storm settles. Not a smart move on this particular case

To be fair being called in front of MP's is like a ritualised grilling, nothing ever comes out of it other than total humiliation for the victim.

I would not mind in this case. Some people may need that to see the new perspective.
Post reply on HN