Live data from Hacker News

YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 763 posts

Re: YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

#11
post #10
post #5

Who wants to open a free-speech based forum site?

That's not a popular idea here on HN. Former YC'er created https://gab.ai which is what you're looking for, and now they have a full video streaming / tipping system.

Didn’t that YC’er get expelled from the Ycombinator community for harassing other founders with alt-right slurs?

Re: YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

#12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's not a popular idea here on HN. Former YC'er created https://gab.ai which is what you're looking for, and now they have a full video streaming / tipping system.

Didn’t that YC’er get expelled from the Ycombinator community for harassing other founders with alt-right slurs?

What makes a slur specifically "alt-right"?

Re: YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

#14
post #5

Who wants to open a free-speech based forum site?

Voat already exists and already has a reputation for being both terrible and a ghost town.

The problem with voat is it basically the dregs of reddit so no-one respectable wants to be associated with it. But if reddit bans enough stuff that is semi-respectable and those people are able to hold their nose to migrate to voat they might end up making voat respectable enough to overcome their current poor reputation.

Re: YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

#15
This is very dismaying to see

I have used Youtube in the past for seeing how to install gun accessories, put guns together, how to fix malfunctions, etc. Watching those videos has made me a more knowledgeable, and hence more responsible gun owner. This is an especially large blow for people who are part of niche communities, like reloading ammo for 100+ year old rifles. A lot of historical content will be lost.

The new youtube rules will also get rid of entertainment channels like Hickock45 and Demolition Ranch (the proceeds of which help subsidize the creator's other channel, Vet Ranch)

I'm also pretty disappointed in Reddit. They made a new admin account yesterday to anonymously post the new rules. I believe this is the first time that's been done for an announcement, usually they're posted by a CEO or a specific individual. /r/gundeals was a fantastic community and I don't know if anything comparable exists elsewhere online. There were lots of links posted by regular users, but when dealers posted themselves they really made an effort to engage with buyers. Crappy vendors/products were usually called out in the comments. Other than optics, I can't imagine why reddit would ban strictly law-abiding communities while allowing illegal and toxic ones to flourish.

Re: YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Voat already exists and already has a reputation for being both terrible and a ghost town.

The problem with voat is it basically the dregs of reddit so no-one respectable wants to be associated with it. But if reddit bans enough stuff that is semi-respectable and those people are able to hold their nose to migrate to voat they might end up making voat respectable enough to overcome their current poor reputation.

Maybe that will happen but I don't think the site will be Voat. Its reputation is far too toxic at this point.

Re: YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

#17

This is due to US Section 230 legislation changing this week, spurred by the actions and legal battles of backpage.com https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2018/03/21/59... "The Backpage saga has galvanized lawmakers to act on bills amending Section 230 with the goal of stemming online sex trafficking. The legislation allows more state and civil lawsuits against websites related to online sex trafficking, f…

How does Section 230 relate to banning videos about completely legal firearms accessories?

Re: YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Voat already exists and already has a reputation for being both terrible and a ghost town.

The problem with voat is it basically the dregs of reddit so no-one respectable wants to be associated with it. But if reddit bans enough stuff that is semi-respectable and those people are able to hold their nose to migrate to voat they might end up making voat respectable enough to overcome their current poor reputation.

It has reached that point. I'm moving to voat.

Re: YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

#19

This is due to US Section 230 legislation changing this week, spurred by the actions and legal battles of backpage.com https://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2018/03/21/59... "The Backpage saga has galvanized lawmakers to act on bills amending Section 230 with the goal of stemming online sex trafficking. The legislation allows more state and civil lawsuits against websites related to online sex trafficking, f…

How does Section 230 relate to banning videos about completely legal firearms accessories?

[deleted]

Re: YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans

#20

This is very dismaying to see I have used Youtube in the past for seeing how to install gun accessories, put guns together, how to fix malfunctions, etc. Watching those videos has made me a more knowledgeable, and hence more responsible gun owner. This is an especially large blow for people who are part of niche communities, like reloading ammo for 100+ year old rifles. A lot of historical content will be lost. The n…

gundeals was the only sub that I had ever actually made a direct bookmark too. I've never seen another community quite like it.
Post reply on HN