Live data from Hacker News

“Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

reddit.com

201–210 of 278 posts

Re: “Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

#201

While they're at it please remove Yelp. The page that comes up on mobile does not appear to be the one Google indexes. It only shows the first sentence of a few reviews. Clicking Read More or More Reviews bounces you straight to the Google Play Store to install the Yelp app.

Yelp has some of the worst practices in the industry. Quora at least shows you some of what you want, while Yelp will stop at nothing to force you to log in and/or download the app.

Re: “Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

#202
post #82
post #56

I agree that it's quite annoying, but you can already remove it yourself from the search results by adding "-site:pinterest.com" in the query.

I don't want to do that each time, plus pininterset.in or .br will takes it's place.

You can use pinterest.

Re: “Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

#203

I don't see why Pinterest does this to themselves. My main exposure to them is through Google image search and links to their site. So my first several experiences were like this. It left me with a terrible first impression. It makes me wonder if the whole site plays games and tries to waste my time. I usually don't sign up for an account the first few times I encounter a site, so in my mind it's a pretty critical ti…

One of the things that makes me a little bonkers is when people A/B test, find something that works well for, say, 50% of the people, and then dust off their hands and call it done. Because 50% is a lot of people, so it must be good. I'd rather that they ask, "Hey, is there something that would be good for the other half of the users?" Software being infinitely soft, we can often find ways to serve both groups. If Pi…

I had friends in Groupon who used this technique. They claimed that forced sign ups didn't really result in a high enough bounce rate, compared to the number of sign ups they got.

Data driven does a poor job of capturing user annoyance. Someone will tolerate being screwed a few times to get a discount. But after a while, it builds momentum.

Though in many cases, startups don't care. They just want to sell off their numbers and exit.

Re: “Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

#204

I don't see why Pinterest does this to themselves. My main exposure to them is through Google image search and links to their site. So my first several experiences were like this. It left me with a terrible first impression. It makes me wonder if the whole site plays games and tries to waste my time. I usually don't sign up for an account the first few times I encounter a site, so in my mind it's a pretty critical ti…

Agreed on this. What's surprising to meis their success despite the logged in experience not being better at all.

We're getting married, so my fiancée is (obviously) using pinterest for everything - her dress, themes, you name it. And the wedding planner we work with uses Pinterest too, we (try) to share it with them so they get an idea.

Even such a simple feature as sharing a board is a nightmare and wastes 5-10 minutes in every calls we have so the planner can finally find the board. Or a crucial feature as "pinning" is even bad and obstructive. Be it with the chrome addon or whatever other system.

Really don't see how they got so popular and really wonder why no other competitor is entering the market and crushing them.

Re: “Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

#205
Someone gave an example of searching for "IBM Leapfrog" and getting numerous Pinterest results.

I tried that search and only got one Pinterest result in the top 10.

I had no problem getting the text and images using a text-only browser. Could Javascript be the enabler for this Pinterest/Google annoyance?

Here is a quick little script to dump all the text from a Pinterest page; note how much is devoted to SEO and ads. .jpg URLs are wrapped in anchor tags for convenience.

    curl https://www.pinterest.com/pin/509469776569152019/ \
    |exec tr '/;
    /\.jpg\"/{s/\"/viewjpg
/4;};
    $s/$//' > 1.htm ;

    firefox file:///1.htm ;
With respect to LinkedIn, here is an amusing experiment to test the theory that your time means nothing to some web developers: Try signing up for a temporary account with a 10-minute email address from 10minutemail.com. LinkedIn will not inform you that this is an unacceptable email address. LinkedIn will proceed to show you Google ReCaptchas for at least 10 minutes, and perhaps longer.

Re: “Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

#206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

LinkedIn is one of the top sites for dark UX patterns. It is 100% purposeful, just like Pinterest, and designed to increase the all important "engagement" metric.

Does anyone actually ‘engage’ in way other than trying to block their spam? Every 6 months or so they seem to break through and the crap piles up. I was just fighting them off this morning.

As a non recruiter that isn't looking for a job I just find it useful for looking into people from 3rd parties I am currently working with.

Things such as who else they work with, their exact position in their company, where they have worked in the past.

All the social features bolted on are useless to me.

Re: “Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

#207

I say don't get rid of it but give me the option to remove it from my search. There's a bunch of sites I would rather not see in my search all the time. Yes, I know I can do a custom search but I'd be happy to have a "not see x domain in my search" option. If I remember right there were other search engines in the past that had the option. Come on Google give me the option.

From the Reddit comments: This extension can block domains from Google search and it's made by Google. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/personal-blocklist...

good tip thx!

Re: “Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

#208

Someone gave an example of searching for "IBM Leapfrog" and getting numerous Pinterest results. I tried that search and only got one Pinterest result in the top 10. I had no problem getting the text and images using a text-only browser. Could Javascript be the enabler for this Pinterest/Google annoyance? Here is a quick little script to dump all the text from a Pinterest page; note how much is devoted to SEO and ads.…

Some throw away email sites accept incoming email on any domain, so if you have a spare one you can just point your MX record to the site and use that as a throwaway email. I believe most sites don't do DNS lookups when checking for scrap email addresses.

Re: “Pinterest needs to be removed from Google IMO”

#210

I don't see why Pinterest does this to themselves. My main exposure to them is through Google image search and links to their site. So my first several experiences were like this. It left me with a terrible first impression. It makes me wonder if the whole site plays games and tries to waste my time. I usually don't sign up for an account the first few times I encounter a site, so in my mind it's a pretty critical ti…

Agreed on this. What's surprising to meis their success despite the logged in experience not being better at all. We're getting married, so my fiancée is (obviously) using pinterest for everything - her dress, themes, you name it. And the wedding planner we work with uses Pinterest too, we (try) to share it with them so they get an idea. Even such a simple feature as sharing a board is a nightmare and wastes 5-10 min…

My 2 cents : they are popular because they are pretty much the only ones in that pretty specific space.

It does not explain why no other company has tried to copycat them though.

Post reply on HN