Live data from Hacker News

The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

spectrum.ieee.org

21–30 of 33 posts

Re: The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

#21
post #19

The article really should have mentioned the BA-609 tiltrotor aircraft. It's the civilian version of the V-22, and nearly ready for production. The BA-609, with the speed and range of an airplane, has tremendous potential, and is the reason why Sikorsky started resealching faster helicopters.

It's in the little slideshow dealy.

Re: The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

#22

Is it just me or the writing style of this article is really weird? It's as if different people have written different sections. Some of it sounds like a pre-flight briefing manual sans the helpful illustrations and other parts sound like a PR fluff piece. For example; >>>But here's the catch. When a helicopter flies forward, the rotor blades experience a dramatic variation in airspeed. That's easy to see if you imag…

The first paragraph assumes you're facing the same way as the pilot - straight ahead. You do have to really build the image of the rotors in your head to follow the paragraph, but I have no complaints.

Both paragraphs were written by an engineer who's deeply involved on the technical side and emotionally connected to the team. Both paragraphs are consistent with their position, and the appropriate tones of voice from a single person in that situation.

Re: The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

#23
post #7
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you mean more massive than a normal helicopter? Why? The article seems to state that the newly available technologies made their new helicopter lighter than before.

"Massively robust" == "very robust"

== "robust"

Re: The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

#24
post #19

The article really should have mentioned the BA-609 tiltrotor aircraft. It's the civilian version of the V-22, and nearly ready for production. The BA-609, with the speed and range of an airplane, has tremendous potential, and is the reason why Sikorsky started resealching faster helicopters.

The V-22 should make for a very interesting engineering story when all of the history comes out. Tiltrotors inherently have a lot of moving parts, plus a very complicated aerodynamic profile as they transition from helicopter mode to airplane mode. It took decades to develop it, at least one fatal accident, and a lot of technology risk throughout, and all the while it was a prime candidate for cancellation. The only thing that saved it was its suitability for the Marine Corps, who needed an aircraft that could carry more Marines a longer distance than helicopters. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:MV-22B_combat_radius_in_Ir...)

It's probably not too far from the truth to say that, just like stealth aircraft, we wouldn't have usable production tiltrotor aircraft today if it wasn't for the political tendency to spend vast amounts of money on unnecessary and implausible military contracts. Not an argument either way, just an observation.

Re: The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

#26
post #15
post #3

Everyone knows Airwolf is faster.

lol, I just popped in here to write that and saw that someone beat me to it. As soon as I saw that title "Fastest helicopter" the only thing that popped in my head "Airwolf" now I have the theme song in my head...

Ah yeah... "The Lady".. :D

Instant flashbacks to Jan-Michael Vincent .. Ernest Borgnine .. Alex Cord (and his cute assistants ;D) ... jeeps ... Valley of the Gods ... eagles .. a cello ... and of course that awesome and super long intro of the first episode with that lizard falling/rolling from the front wheel of the helicopter when it takes off.

As you can notice, the show did make an impression on this 5 year old in the 80's. ;D

Thank you for bringing back the memories! :)

Re: The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

#27
post #17

Why is the double rotor design not more popular than the way most helicopters are made?

My guess is complexity. The double rotors require coaxial drives and the helicopter itself ends up being taller. The top rotor maintenance is going to be more difficult. The Kamov company's helicopters were all(?) double-rotor. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamov Kamen Aerospace has double rotor helicopters without the coaxial drive (interleaved rotors) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaman_Aircraft

Complexity, yes, but for a different reason -- gyroscopic precession. Cyclic inputs for differential lift require that the actual (mechanical) blade adjustment be at an angle to the change in the lift produced. With a single rotor you can accomplish that with a simple mechanical linkage (and a bit of body english -- the angle of input precession is rarely at the "proper" 90 degrees). Counter-rotating blades mean two sets of blade pitch controls (swash plates, rods, followers and linkages, etc.) and, if you want to avoid unplanned pitch adjustments, a servo system that can moderate cyclic control input based on direction (input will be much more sensitive to fore-aft adjustment than to left-right without a compensation circuit).

Re: The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

#28
post #3

Everyone knows Airwolf is faster.

Airwolf is the word we should use to describe things of beauty, intensity, and majesty. Shakespeare is airwolf. James Brown's music is airwolf. Sex so good it makes your spine tingle and your knees buckle -- that's airwolf! And there is nothing more airwolf... than Airwolf.

Re: The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

#29
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My guess is complexity. The double rotors require coaxial drives and the helicopter itself ends up being taller. The top rotor maintenance is going to be more difficult. The Kamov company's helicopters were all(?) double-rotor. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamov Kamen Aerospace has double rotor helicopters without the coaxial drive (interleaved rotors) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaman_Aircraft

Complexity, yes, but for a different reason -- gyroscopic precession. Cyclic inputs for differential lift require that the actual (mechanical) blade adjustment be at an angle to the change in the lift produced. With a single rotor you can accomplish that with a simple mechanical linkage (and a bit of body english -- the angle of input precession is rarely at the "proper" 90 degrees). Counter-rotating blades mean two…

> if you want to avoid unplanned pitch adjustments

I read that as 'detours to the nearest hospital'.

Re: The Fastest Helicopter on Earth

#30
post #13
post #3

Everyone knows Airwolf is faster.

Truely: Airwolf's conventional top speed is 560 km/h compared to the X2's 435 km/h. With turbo boosters, Airwolf could go Mach 1+, so really nothing has progressed past the 1980's. Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airwolf_(helicopter)

Except that airwolf's special capabilities are all fictional.
Post reply on HN