Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Minimal native MP3 player for Mac

catnapgames.com

71–80 of 120 posts

Re: Show HN: Minimal native MP3 player for Mac

#71
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I never understood why Apple always hides functionality beneath undiscoverable gestures. Especially on iOS where once I had a friend complain that they cannot see the time that a message was sent or received. I had to show them to hold and swipe so they can see the hidden column of times. I guess they don’t want to clutter up at the interface with things like labels and options.

Of course, it would make it cluttered which would make finding the most used information harder. But sometimes a quick look at the manual is all that's needed, > Tip: To see what time a message was sent or received, drag a bubble to the left. https://help.apple.com/iphone/11/#/iph82fb73ba3

You can't add much more indirection than making someone credentialize in a manual to do something as trivial as showing timestamps. Better hope you catch that one-liner tip and then remember it when you're back in the app at some other point in time.

I'd rather every app just have a hamburger menu with a menagerie of settings so that those settings can exist even if they're too hard to design for. Instead designers write blog posts that shame everyone for making those menus in the first place.

Hidden gestures is the worst UX of all. For the same reason Siri will never replace a CLI -- completely probabilistic, unknown interface.

Re: Show HN: Minimal native MP3 player for Mac

#72

Features: • not iTunes You know, iTunes wasn’t so bad before they convoluted the UI/UX to shit...looking at the music app on iOS 5-6 vs iOS 10-11 is like comparing a walkway to a labyrinth. The amount of steps taken backwards in Apple’s UI / UX is staggering. Even the simple replacement of the Spotlight bar from an unobtrusive widget in the top right corner to a giant box in the middle of the screen, directly coverin…

iTunes never worked. It's why applications like Ephpod and others were developed. It's terrible, and every UI / UX update makes it more so.

Re: Show HN: Minimal native MP3 player for Mac

#73
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Obviously it will have less quality than a FLAC/CDDA original but not less than MP3 (unless you actually set the bitrate too low). This is incorrect. Lossy-to-lossy transcodes always incur a quality loss. It is known

The same kind of loss as caused by using cheap audio cables instead of golden cables perhaps... (sarcasm) It would make sense to speak about quality loss if it was about FLAC originals but not if the originals are already MP3. You can't save what is not there.

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Minimal native MP3 player for Mac

#74
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Obviously it will have less quality than a FLAC/CDDA original but not less than MP3 (unless you actually set the bitrate too low). This is incorrect. Lossy-to-lossy transcodes always incur a quality loss. It is known

The same kind of loss as caused by using cheap audio cables instead of golden cables perhaps... (sarcasm) It would make sense to speak about quality loss if it was about FLAC originals but not if the originals are already MP3. You can't save what is not there.

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Minimal native MP3 player for Mac

#77
post #11

Features: • not iTunes You know, iTunes wasn’t so bad before they convoluted the UI/UX to shit...looking at the music app on iOS 5-6 vs iOS 10-11 is like comparing a walkway to a labyrinth. The amount of steps taken backwards in Apple’s UI / UX is staggering. Even the simple replacement of the Spotlight bar from an unobtrusive widget in the top right corner to a giant box in the middle of the screen, directly coverin…

Exactly, the problem is that they kept fixing things that weren't broken and making random illogical UI changes until the program got so over-engineered and bloated that it was a chore to use. The program worked fine, but I guess the team of engineers wanted to keep their jobs so they kept including these unnecessary "fixes".

And pushing you done the path of buying stuff from the iTunes Store. The UI funnels you into the store by default, not to your media collection.

Re: Show HN: Minimal native MP3 player for Mac

#78
post #72

Features: • not iTunes You know, iTunes wasn’t so bad before they convoluted the UI/UX to shit...looking at the music app on iOS 5-6 vs iOS 10-11 is like comparing a walkway to a labyrinth. The amount of steps taken backwards in Apple’s UI / UX is staggering. Even the simple replacement of the Spotlight bar from an unobtrusive widget in the top right corner to a giant box in the middle of the screen, directly coverin…

iTunes never worked. It's why applications like Ephpod and others were developed. It's terrible, and every UI / UX update makes it more so.

It worked for me pretty well before they hit the double digit version numbers. Back when the icon was green/blue

Re: Show HN: Minimal native MP3 player for Mac

#79

Features: • not iTunes You know, iTunes wasn’t so bad before they convoluted the UI/UX to shit...looking at the music app on iOS 5-6 vs iOS 10-11 is like comparing a walkway to a labyrinth. The amount of steps taken backwards in Apple’s UI / UX is staggering. Even the simple replacement of the Spotlight bar from an unobtrusive widget in the top right corner to a giant box in the middle of the screen, directly coverin…

Yup, in iOS 10 they ruined the Music app, in iOS 11 they ruined the Podcast app... I wonder which one's next...

Re: Show HN: Minimal native MP3 player for Mac

#80

Great start! Would need something to easily mass edit ID3 tags and also rename files based on tags - any good solutions? Surprisingly, I couldn't find a suitable CLI tool so far either.

There's the "id3" mass tagger utility which supposedly can do that: https://squell.github.io/id3/

I haven't used it though, I've settled for MusicBrainz Picard for now.

Post reply on HN