Live data from Hacker News

Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

motherboard.vice.com

271–280 of 333 posts

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#271
post #174

One thing is that most people really dont need gigabit connection. I'd think most people couldn't tell the difference between 10mbps & 1gig. Maybe 25-100 mbps is required if you have 8 kids each streaming their own movies. Maybe 5g is enough and the fiber rollout is a waste of resources. Upstream backups are a little different. It doesn't work quick enough with dsl. But isn't that important.

I have FIOS and aside from finally syncing my online backups, I've been struck by how little difference / improvement there is over cable. I'm not a gamer so the latency doesn't matter. My TV isn't 4k so no help there and I suspect video "CDNs" will be the primary fix for most of the market.

What is the best use case for fiber? I feel like I'm missing it.

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#272
post #158

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fwiw, $140 is quite a lot. We shared what everyone was paying for Fios here at work. I'm on the upper end of $65 for 50/50 (no TV). The lowest we found was 1G for $40. the trick seems to be to cancel and sign up again for the new user deals.

The $140 includes the $49 “Ultimate Entertainment Pack”. It’s literally every single pay channel. Without that I paid $91 per month for gigabit Internet, TV with Prime channels and Phone.

As I mentioned, the lowest we found here at work was 1Gig for $40.

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#273

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fwiw, $140 is quite a lot. We shared what everyone was paying for Fios here at work. I'm on the upper end of $65 for 50/50 (no TV). The lowest we found was 1G for $40. the trick seems to be to cancel and sign up again for the new user deals.

He also mentioned that he gets a TV package. I believe gigabit is $70 a month stand alone from Verizon.

As I mentioned, the lowest we found here at work was 1Gig for $40.

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#274

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is my tribe accused of this time? Kicking out groups that don't hew to the party-line on YouTube. Not only the genuinely far-right, but also moderates, mainstream Republicans, and various sub-cultural enthusiasts. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CTI4Bm5OxkU My peeps are trying to expand broadband, so I guess none of us got the memo. As I referenced above, old-media interests and local interests oppose the expans…

Sorry, I’m losing the narrative: Was the Far Left for or against Google Fiber? More residential broadband (last mile) competition would have saved online advertising?

Was the Far Left for or against Google Fiber?

For. However they are against actual Free Speech unmolested by censorship from corporate giants, and they would not have such power on their side, had Google Fiber succeeded.

More residential broadband (last mile) competition would have saved online advertising?

It would have let Tech kill off old media, or at least kill it off sooner, which would have changed the market power of old media's ad money.

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#275

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They simply haven't developed the weapons to destroy the WISPs yet, but unless the political climate in states/cities changes, they will. Basically, authoritarianism rears its ugly head in the US once again, across corporate, national, state, and local levels. The same general kind of gaming of the system which resulted in interstates dividing white from non-white neighborhoods is now maintaining the media status quo…

> Basically, authoritarianism rears its ugly head in the US once again, across corporate, national, state, and local levels. The same general kind of gaming of the system which resulted in interstates dividing white from non-white neighborhoods is now maintaining the media status quo. On one side, it's the corporatism and Crony Capitalism the left traditionally complains about, now wielded by the Far Left as a non-go…

Except this is a GOP agenda...You are just accusing anything involving regulations as "Leftist" without acknowledging it is the standard banners of your own party that enable it.

I am not a Republican. I've always voted Democrat.

When your expectations are 180-deg out of whack, it's time to re-visit your world view and assumptions.

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#276
post #120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google Fiber hit a lot of roadblocks along the way that slowed things down. You have the lawsuit from AT&T against local government in Louisville[0]. There was also a lot of arguments[1][2] around the country for Google trying to access utility poles to hang their wires. Incumbents tried their hardest to prevent Google from hanging new wires. Many of the laws in-place today make it difficult for new companies to hang…

Your analysis is backwards. There aren't special laws that "make it difficult for new companies to hang wires." The issue was not Google hanging its own wires, but Google contractors moving AT&T's wires in order to make space on the poles. Louisville passed special laws to enable one company to relocate another company's property on utility poles. I think those laws are a good idea, but its hard to blame AT&T for not…

> a team of four guys with heavy equipment have spent the last three hours trenching fiber 50 feet through my tiny yard. That's the second visit, and there will be one more, and that's not counting running the fiber down the main road which required months of permitting and surveying. I strongly suspect that's why Google pulled out of Fiber.

I wouldn't be surprised if this was a huge factor. Everyone likes to blame regulation for fibre failures, but the "last mile" of fiber to the premise, like many wired broadband technologies before it, is often a nightmare.

Reminds me of this story, where one Norwegian ISP started asking customers to dig their own trench: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/05/norwegian-isp-di...

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#277

Maybe it's because I live in a wealthier and more dense metropolitan area where there is actually still some semblance of competition between them, but over that same time period both major ISPs in the area have stepped up the speeds they offer and prices haven't risen to match(as far as I can tell). Their lowest tier service is 50mbit, which was just a few years ago one of the highest. Both are offering gigabit to t…

But the technology for these speeds were available 15 years ago. The ISPs did not offer them or build them out to consumers, and this attributed to the lack of competition. Without Google trying to enter the scene, most internet consumers would not have realized they could get better. Also, these ISPs are overcharging for their service. Google's pricing allowed people to peer into the fact that they were being cheate…

Well, what I was getting at is that Google did seem to have a tangible effect. Either they did or some other parties in the area, I'm not sure. But based on the jump in available speeds and prices remaining roughly the same, someone at the big incumbents was worried about disruption.

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#278

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's always amusing to observe the kind of rhetorical gymnastics folks will try to employ to blame "the left" for the excesses of unregulated capitalism that the right tirelessly champions.

If you follow the numbers of who is regularly accepting money from Comcast - both Democrats and Republicans are happy to take their money. "Politico reports that 15 of the 18 members of the Senate Judiciary Committee, which will hold a hearing on the Comcast deal on March 26th, have taken some form of contribution from Comcast." [1] https://www.theverge.com/2014/3/10/5491908/comcast-buys-cong... "...Comcast has canva…

Of course they are, neither party is left of center on the political spectrum.

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#279

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your analysis is backwards. There aren't special laws that "make it difficult for new companies to hang wires." The issue was not Google hanging its own wires, but Google contractors moving AT&T's wires in order to make space on the poles. Louisville passed special laws to enable one company to relocate another company's property on utility poles. I think those laws are a good idea, but its hard to blame AT&T for not…

" (Incidentally, a team of four guys with heavy equipment have spent the last three hours trenching fiber 50 feet through my tiny yard. That's the second visit, and there will be one more, and that's not counting running the fiber down the main road which required months of permitting and surveying...) " Do you live northwest of Austin, where 18 inches below the surface there is about two feet of solid limestone?

Not even 18 inches in some places - more like 5 inches. You can get through it with heavy equipment - something like this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7720jUW_aIk

Re: Eight Years On, Google Fiber Is a Faint Echo of the Disruption Promised

#280
Vice Media itself is a creature of the old media. It may successfully transform itself into a new media company. I've noted a lot of Far-Left ideological bias there, however. In my estimation, it's the 2018 equivalent of Fox News, just on the other side of the political spectrum.
Post reply on HN