Live data from Hacker News

Founding Stories Are Myths

medium.com

11–20 of 63 posts

Re: Founding Stories Are Myths

#11

Let's not ignore the fact that Sam Walton had enough cash to buy a department store at the age of 27. That helps too.

> Let's not ignore the fact that Sam Walton had enough cash to buy a department store at the age of 27. That helps too. So poor people should never try to be an entrepreneur because the world is rigged against them? Well that surely will help reduce the wealth inequality.

OP didn't suggest that though. Many people have a black-and-white ideal in which entrepreneurship means making the next Facebook or Amazon and end up aiming too high for their own means.

Re: Founding Stories Are Myths

#13
The author is criticizing a genre of narrative that I like to call "career porn." Consider the similarities between "how I started this company" type stories and actual porn:

* It depicts something everyone fantasizes about and offers a quick if ultimately unsatisfying release. Who doesn't imagine themselves building something amazing and being idolized by magazines and the general public?

* It happens in an unrealistic sort of magical fairy land, often in the founder's own hazy, romanticized recollections of their past.

* It only shows beautiful companies/people. You don't need to found a space exploration company to be happy just like you don't need to be with a model.

* It offers no real guidance for how to achieve what it's depicting, leaving viewers confused at best and frustrated at worst. This article touches on the fact that people seem to think all they need is an idea, when that's not what it takes.

* It's most popular with those who are either frustrated with their careers/romantic lives, or are otherwise trying to satisfy a need they feel isn't being met. This one is a little shaky because plenty of people enjoy actual porn in healthy ways, so forgive me for the stretch.

The comparisons go on and on. How healthy your relationship with each is depends on how much exposure to the realities of each field you have had and how mature you are as a person/profession.

Re: Founding Stories Are Myths

#14
post #12
post #6

I got drawn in by the clickbait title

Title does a disservice to the writing. It is a good read.

Is it? Perhaps the headline should be "Why You Should Ignore THIS Founder’s Story About How They Started Their Company"

I feel like if the author is going to make a broad generalization about founding stories, he should use more than 1 example. I don't count Netflix as one of his examples because he simply says "That didn’t actually happen." So to combat Reed saying this is how I started Netflix... the author just says "no" without any proof. Who am I going to believe? The founder or a blogger?

Re: Founding Stories Are Myths

#15
Either someone told me, or I read somewhere in a book, about how these things are called "business lies" and that it is supposedly OK to do in the name of making money

No harm no foul if everyone feels better about themselves right?

/s

Re: Founding Stories Are Myths

#16
post #13

The author is criticizing a genre of narrative that I like to call "career porn." Consider the similarities between "how I started this company" type stories and actual porn: * It depicts something everyone fantasizes about and offers a quick if ultimately unsatisfying release. Who doesn't imagine themselves building something amazing and being idolized by magazines and the general public? * It happens in an unrealis…

>It only shows beautiful companies/people. You don't need to found a space exploration company to be happy just like you don't need to be with a model.

We certainly don't hear much about efforts or successes in anyone's effort to "disrupt" the toilet paper industry, yet it's something most people use daily. It's not sexy, but we all care a lot when it sucks.

Re: Founding Stories Are Myths

#17
post #14
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Title does a disservice to the writing. It is a good read.

Is it? Perhaps the headline should be "Why You Should Ignore THIS Founder’s Story About How They Started Their Company" I feel like if the author is going to make a broad generalization about founding stories, he should use more than 1 example. I don't count Netflix as one of his examples because he simply says "That didn’t actually happen." So to combat Reed saying this is how I started Netflix... the author just sa…

It is a good read.

You read it. You feel about it. You formulate an opinion (pro/con). You learn something. You doubt something.

That’s what a good read is.

Re: Founding Stories Are Myths

#18
It doesn't just stop at the successful startup stories. It's the same style of stories we face in products successful stories, job offers and love stories. examples:

REGAINE (hair loss treatment) only works for some people, not everyone and if you use it consistently twice a day for the rest of your life.

A job at Google/Facebook/haskell job requires you to study day and night for algorithms/functional programming/implement a lot of random programs to get a hold of all of that.

This couple is in love for 50 years, and they ignore how they had lots of fights and had to have lots of compromises from each of them, with a lot of discipline to show care for each other to maintain this love over the years.

These folks got amazing new houses/entered StanfordU because they worked non stop for the past few years while not spending on other luxury items or they will work tirelessly for the rest of their live to pay the debt.

Life is a grind

Re: Founding Stories Are Myths

#19
I don't think it's fair to use that one small piece of Netflix lore as the counter example to the point of the article. I'd categorize Reed Hastings as having one of the more long-term views/strategies in tech and business in general, and he would be the first to say that Netflix became what it has become not because of the lightbulb moment, but because of the long slog they've endured to get where they are. Using that Netflix example comes across as clickbaity.

Not to mention, that particular Netflix myth has nothing to do with the importance of having a lightbulb moment. The point is to provide a north star for the company about the importance of always keeping the customer/user experience top of mind. By charging late fees that exceeded the value of a video, Blockbuster had lost sight of the customer experience, which contributed to Blockbuster's downfall. Meanwhile, maintaining its intense focus on the customer experience helped Netflix navigate what was an impressive shift from mailing DVDs to streaming video online.

Re: Founding Stories Are Myths

#20
post #9

Let's not ignore the fact that Sam Walton had enough cash to buy a department store at the age of 27. That helps too.

Well, he didn't exactly have the money. He borrowed $20k from his father in law and used $5k from his own military savings. No small sum I suppose. (around $300k adjusted for inflation). But also not a "small million dollar loan". ($4 million inflation adjusted even IF it were true.) But Sam's real story is not the rags to riches. It the brilliant and hard work that took him from riches to extraordinary success.

Dude turned that million dollar loan into $140M though. People tend to omit that part for some reason.
Post reply on HN