Live data from Hacker News

Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

spectrum.ieee.org

81–90 of 127 posts

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yet there are some resources that are hard to privatise, for instance the atmosphere. Government regulation is what turns the commons (which are open to tragedy) into either tightly regulated (for example, dumping of hazardous materials) or a free market (for example, emissions trading). Without the government interference, the market wouldn't exist. To some extent that goes all the way down to buying your groceries,…

> nothing would be stopping someone with a bigger gun coming in and stealing whatever groceries they want That's why we need government - to prevent violence and stealing. Free market can work only in non-violence environment. However, government tries to do much more than that. And this I consider as a problem, namely excessive regulation.

Even Hayek, so beloved of Thatcher and Reagan, sought to regulate and price externalities due to failures of the free market:

“Nor can certain harmful effects of deforestation, or of some methods of farming, or of the smoke and noise of factories, be confined to the owner of the property in question or to those who are willing to submit to the damage for an agreed compensation. In such instances we must find some substitute for the regulation by the price mechanism.” (From Road to Serfdom)

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had a conversation with a guy creating a crypto startup recently. It only took five minutes in before the thin veneer of an actual business model fell away and the real motive—free money—starting coming out. His position, distilled: if people are stupid enough to give me money, who am I to say no? I suggested his easy money might not be so easy if (for US investors) the SEC, FTC, CFTC, etc. crack down and claw back…

I agree with your friend. Dumb people will give away their money anyway. Might as well give it to me. What's wrong with free money as long as I'm not doing illegal stuff.

Morals, ethics?

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had a conversation with a guy creating a crypto startup recently. It only took five minutes in before the thin veneer of an actual business model fell away and the real motive—free money—starting coming out. His position, distilled: if people are stupid enough to give me money, who am I to say no? I suggested his easy money might not be so easy if (for US investors) the SEC, FTC, CFTC, etc. crack down and claw back…

I agree with your friend. Dumb people will give away their money anyway. Might as well give it to me. What's wrong with free money as long as I'm not doing illegal stuff.

probably because being legal is not a sufficient condition for being ethical

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree with your friend. Dumb people will give away their money anyway. Might as well give it to me. What's wrong with free money as long as I'm not doing illegal stuff.

Morals, ethics?

If investors are giving money based on lies, there’s a legal system in place to help them recover failed fraudulent investments. I’d wager in many cases investors know exactly what they’re investing in. So I don’t see any ethical/moral conflicts in a lot of these BS cryptocurrency schemes, just a lot of wasted potential and a somewhat shameful divergence from the idealistic core tech - private, trustless transactions through a decentralized blockchain (bitcoin).

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Morals, ethics?

If investors are giving money based on lies, there’s a legal system in place to help them recover failed fraudulent investments. I’d wager in many cases investors know exactly what they’re investing in. So I don’t see any ethical/moral conflicts in a lot of these BS cryptocurrency schemes, just a lot of wasted potential and a somewhat shameful divergence from the idealistic core tech - private, trustless transactions…

Stunned by that comment. Stunned.

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If investors are giving money based on lies, there’s a legal system in place to help them recover failed fraudulent investments. I’d wager in many cases investors know exactly what they’re investing in. So I don’t see any ethical/moral conflicts in a lot of these BS cryptocurrency schemes, just a lot of wasted potential and a somewhat shameful divergence from the idealistic core tech - private, trustless transactions…

Stunned by that comment. Stunned.

.

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#87

The crypto space to me is really frustrating. I've seen friends become something very close to scammers, I can't have interesting technical discussions about the topic without being called doomsayer and even when I pitch an idea what to use the Blockchain for, all I get is:"let's do an ICO and raise a shitton of money!" although that doesn't really make sense towards what I'm proposing. I feel like the nerd in class…

A lot of my ideas for blockchain technology work a lot better using ETH for example, rather than yet another token. I think we'll need to wait a few months/years before the ICO craze dies down and we can get back to focusing on building tech on top of Bitcoin/Ethereum without the word ICO.

My ideas tend to be the same. I don't see any reason not to go ahead and build them.

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#88

The crypto space to me is really frustrating. I've seen friends become something very close to scammers, I can't have interesting technical discussions about the topic without being called doomsayer and even when I pitch an idea what to use the Blockchain for, all I get is:"let's do an ICO and raise a shitton of money!" although that doesn't really make sense towards what I'm proposing. I feel like the nerd in class…

I had a conversation with a guy creating a crypto startup recently. It only took five minutes in before the thin veneer of an actual business model fell away and the real motive—free money—starting coming out. His position, distilled: if people are stupid enough to give me money, who am I to say no? I suggested his easy money might not be so easy if (for US investors) the SEC, FTC, CFTC, etc. crack down and claw back…

> if (for US investors) the SEC, FTC, CFTC, etc. crack down and claw back investor money

A counter argument I saw first on Hacker News and then in real life approximates “decentralised currencies make it impossible for governments to enforce laws.” (Obviously wrong, shockingly so, but appears to be a meme in the crypto community.)

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#89

The crypto space to me is really frustrating. I've seen friends become something very close to scammers, I can't have interesting technical discussions about the topic without being called doomsayer and even when I pitch an idea what to use the Blockchain for, all I get is:"let's do an ICO and raise a shitton of money!" although that doesn't really make sense towards what I'm proposing. I feel like the nerd in class…

I had a conversation with a guy creating a crypto startup recently. It only took five minutes in before the thin veneer of an actual business model fell away and the real motive—free money—starting coming out. His position, distilled: if people are stupid enough to give me money, who am I to say no? I suggested his easy money might not be so easy if (for US investors) the SEC, FTC, CFTC, etc. crack down and claw back…

It reminds me very much of 1998/1999. 9 out of 10 "startups" at that point were outright scams and they barely even tried to hide it.

Same goes for the crypto space these days. It was sad to watch in tech 20 years ago, and sad to watch now.

Re: Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails

#90
post #6

As an aside, is there anyone else extremely disappointed with the quality of discussion over at /r/cryptocurrency? This conflict over IOTA has been unfolding for a long time and the guys on that subreddit defend it fanatically, accusing DCI of "FUD"ing IOTA. I am not sure if the subscriber base is technically illiterate or users that hold a given coin have a strong incentive to dismiss any criticism. As someone fasci…

The only thing any crypto subreddit is good for is laughing at the silly memes for 15 minutes before your morning coffee.

They are utterly useless echo chambers filled with trolls otherwise.

Post reply on HN