Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

marc.info

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 23 posts

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#11

Post by Slansitartop »

coldacid wrote: post #4
commandlinefan wrote: post #3

I've lost count of how many times I've googled a question, had the first hit be SO, and the top answer to the question be "Have you ever heard of Google, n00b"? (Thread locked).

I've lost track of the number of times that I've gone to a question that actually deals with what I'm looking for just to find that it's locked and marked duplicate of a completely different question. Complete pain in the ass.

Yeah, the moderation there needs improvement. When ever I use it I almost have to spend as much time preempting invalid attempts to close my question as I do actually asking it.

Then there's also the conceit that SO has hit upon a definition of what a good technical question is (or, more specifically, what isn't a valuable technical question), and they stick to it despite any evidence to the contrary. I've seen questions that fail their over-restrictive criteria that have far better answers than many that do.

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#12

Post by smsm42 »

Looks like the case of snobbery outbreak right there. I mean, you can have issues with depth and precision and other stuff on SO answers - in any huge project, there are good things and there are bad things, and in fact there are tons of bad things you can pick out if the project is large enough. But ignoring the fact that lots of developers successfully use it to exchange information and enrich their knowledge and claiming it's just "some random site" is just ignoring the reality. And claiming "no one should be promoting SO in open source community at all" because it's imperfect just begs the question - ok, what should one be promoting instead? What is the perfect site which is as good an information source as SO and yet has none of its downsides? If this is not specified - in the same place - it just sounds as empty snobbery. SO is a practical tool, it's imperfect, it has obvious and known flaws - but dismissing it wholesale out of hand is only appropriate if one has better tool that solves the same problem, and better. So far I haven't seen any suggestions for that.

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#13

Post by deadliftpro »

jpalomaki wrote: post #9

Main issues for me: 1)too eager closing of questions for whatever reason 2)number of answers for given question growing over time and best answers not getting the best position.

I concur. Main issue I have faced is people down voting questions even when the question is perfectly valid and reasonably well explained(imo). It sometimes looks to me that when a question is about 'under the cover' stuff and not superficial 'how do i get this done/i did this but got this output', it would be down voted.

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#14

Post by Caveman_Coder »

deadliftpro wrote: post #13
jpalomaki wrote: post #9

Main issues for me: 1)too eager closing of questions for whatever reason 2)number of answers for given question growing over time and best answers not getting the best position.

I concur. Main issue I have faced is people down voting questions even when the question is perfectly valid and reasonably well explained(imo). It sometimes looks to me that when a question is about 'under the cover' stuff and not superficial 'how do i get this done/i did this but got this output', it would be down voted.

I had this happen when I was obtaining my degree a couple of years ago. I forget the issue exactly, but I had this homework problem that I was able to solve using Python docs but what was happening underneath wasn't really "clicking" in my brain. So I posted the problem I solved, my solution, along with my actual question about the underlying issue. I got a lot of "did you check the documentation?" and "is this for HW?"...sadly my question was closed and I never got an answer.

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#15

Post by aldanor »

commandlinefan wrote: post #3

I've lost count of how many times I've googled a question, had the first hit be SO, and the top answer to the question be "Have you ever heard of Google, n00b"? (Thread locked).

Quite a few times I’ve googled something only to hit SO answer as the first match where the accepted answer is my own... Oh, right...

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#16

Post by Flimm »

I was curious, and I did a search for "deleted:1 user:me" to see if any of my posts had been deleted, and six had, almost all of them I had deleted myself. For context I have posted around 200 posts on Stack Overflow.

Being able to see deleted posts is indeed an eye-opener, and I also wish more people had this ability, but for a different reason. It makes you aware of the amount of very low quality posts that get posted to Stack Overflow, not to mention spam.

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#17

Post by icc97 »

smsm42 wrote: post #12

Looks like the case of snobbery outbreak right there. I mean, you can have issues with depth and precision and other stuff on SO answers - in any huge project, there are good things and there are bad things, and in fact there are tons of bad things you can pick out if the project is large enough. But ignoring the fact that lots of developers successfully use it to exchange information and enrich their knowledge and c…

When a site is as big as SO you can never fit all the people all of the time.

1. It's community run

2. they make their money through legitimate means of job ads which fits perfectly

3. the ads they do have are to community voted places eg Sheldon Brown from cycling SE

4. It's about as transparent as you can get

5. The people with the most points almost always really know their shit

6. It's one of the few places on the Internet you can make yourself marketable by being helpful. I can prove my knowledge to potential companies through my answers

Or let's just all go back to Experts Exchange.

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#18

Post by icc97 »

commandlinefan wrote: post #3

I've lost count of how many times I've googled a question, had the first hit be SO, and the top answer to the question be "Have you ever heard of Google, n00b"? (Thread locked).

I'm not sure what you search for but that has never happened to me in about 7 years of searching.

You can always appeal to get a question re-opened. You can see who voted to close it and then send them a message.

The worst place for things getting closed is Skeptics SE, but that's a hotbed of controversy and the moderators on there deserve danger money.

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#19

Post by oliver_quartic »

Flimm wrote: post #16

I was curious, and I did a search for "deleted:1 user:me" to see if any of my posts had been deleted, and six had, almost all of them I had deleted myself. For context I have posted around 200 posts on Stack Overflow. Being able to see deleted posts is indeed an eye-opener, and I also wish more people had this ability, but for a different reason. It makes you aware of the amount of very low quality posts that get pos…

Indeed. My stats are 4000 answers, zero deleted (other than by myself). The guy in the post is probably doing something wrong if 10% of his are being deleted.

Re: Unfortunately, StackOverflow is difficult-to-avoid nowadays…

#20

Post by smsm42 »

Flimm wrote: post #16

I was curious, and I did a search for "deleted:1 user:me" to see if any of my posts had been deleted, and six had, almost all of them I had deleted myself. For context I have posted around 200 posts on Stack Overflow. Being able to see deleted posts is indeed an eye-opener, and I also wish more people had this ability, but for a different reason. It makes you aware of the amount of very low quality posts that get pos…

Yes, I see candidates for deletion in review queue, and most of it is either garbage or "I have this complex problem, please solve it for me after I give you the most vague description of it". Like the one I just saw recently where somebody has a huge pile of legacy Perl code and has trouble figuring it out (and that's all, no specific Perl question). I can feel their pain, but what can be done here except giving the poor soul a hug? So this kind of questions gets closed. And probably the person asking it is very frustrated, but really, what can one do here?
Post reply on HN