Live data from Hacker News

Automated Vehicles Can't Save Cities

nytimes.com

1–10 of 26 posts

Re: Automated Vehicles Can't Save Cities

#3

cities don't exist in a vacuum. Many towns die because something essential like a coal mine was removed from the economy, just like removing cars (no matter how noble) could kill some cities too.

I wasn't able to read the article. It was completely blank in my browser.

Could you say who is saying that we should remove cars from a city, even to the point that it would kill the city?

Because I've not heard anyone propose that. I've heard of car-free regions of a city, and cities like Venice which effectively had no private cars, and bans on some cars (like gasoline- and diesel-powered vehicles in favor of electric).

But never to the point that it would kill a city.

Re: Automated Vehicles Can't Save Cities

#6
post #3

cities don't exist in a vacuum. Many towns die because something essential like a coal mine was removed from the economy, just like removing cars (no matter how noble) could kill some cities too.

I wasn't able to read the article. It was completely blank in my browser. Could you say who is saying that we should remove cars from a city, even to the point that it would kill the city? Because I've not heard anyone propose that. I've heard of car-free regions of a city, and cities like Venice which effectively had no private cars, and bans on some cars (like gasoline- and diesel-powered vehicles in favor of elect…

[deleted]

Re: Automated Vehicles Can't Save Cities

#7
post #4

I get the argument, but my quality of life will be improved dramatically without the constant road rage-inducing craziness of my 23 minute commute.

It's quite likely that your commute will get longer than 23 minutes as autonomous vehicles remove the barriers to driving and encourage more people to drive, thus increasing congestion.

Re: Automated Vehicles Can't Save Cities

#8
post #4

I get the argument, but my quality of life will be improved dramatically without the constant road rage-inducing craziness of my 23 minute commute.

It's quite likely that your commute will get longer than 23 minutes as autonomous vehicles remove the barriers to driving and encourage more people to drive, thus increasing congestion.

Yeah, but you’ll be able to use all that wait time consuming ads!
Post reply on HN