Live data from Hacker News

Words for “yes” in Romance languages

benito-cereno.tumblr.com

31–40 of 172 posts

Re: Words for “yes” in Romance languages

#31

It's interesting that in Catalan you may say oi [0] in addition to sí. It is more commonly used in questions and to answer such questions. For example: Plou molt, oi? Oi. There's a construct that is very common and redundant: oi que sí? == right that yes?, which would be translated as an emphatic "right?" [0] http://mdlc.iec.cat/results.asp?txtEntrada=Oi&operEntrada=0

It sounds like a calque of regular Spanish 'a que si' rather than anything else.

Re: Words for “yes” in Romance languages

#32
My favourite on the yes/no front though is the border between Greece and Bulgaria where "Ne" (Не) means no in Bulgarian and, IIUC, yes in Greek.

And then the Bulgarians also have approximately reversed vs Western Europe head movements for yes and no, to maximise confusion :)

Re: Words for “yes” in Romance languages

#33

It's interesting that in Catalan you may say oi [0] in addition to sí. It is more commonly used in questions and to answer such questions. For example: Plou molt, oi? Oi. There's a construct that is very common and redundant: oi que sí? == right that yes?, which would be translated as an emphatic "right?" [0] http://mdlc.iec.cat/results.asp?txtEntrada=Oi&operEntrada=0

It sounds like a calque of regular Spanish 'a que si' rather than anything else.

Not oui in French?

Re: Words for “yes” in Romance languages

#35

It's interesting that in Catalan you may say oi [0] in addition to sí. It is more commonly used in questions and to answer such questions. For example: Plou molt, oi? Oi. There's a construct that is very common and redundant: oi que sí? == right that yes?, which would be translated as an emphatic "right?" [0] http://mdlc.iec.cat/results.asp?txtEntrada=Oi&operEntrada=0

It sounds like a calque of regular Spanish 'a que si' rather than anything else.

A calque wouldn't take such a particular word as "oi". The sentence makes sense coming from oral language, where you say oi to ask for confirmation and add the rest to specify in which direction. People do say "eh que sí", which, cal que or not, follows the same pattern, and even "a que sí", which definitely copies the Spanish expression.

Re: Words for “yes” in Romance languages

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It sounds like a calque of regular Spanish 'a que si' rather than anything else.

Not oui in French?

If you read the article, this is a pattern in a number of languages, so there's no reason for it to come from French. It's also unlikely because the pronunciation is very different: https://forvo.com/word/oi/#ca

Re: Words for “yes” in Romance languages

#39

Sardinian for yes is 'eja' which I've read is derived differently from the two methods suggested here though I haven't seen any suggestions on what that derivation might be.

Sounds a lot like "etiam" in Latin which if you break it apart looks like et + iam or "and now", but this site has some translations including "yes" http://archives.nd.edu/cgi-bin/lookit.pl?latin=Etiam

Re: Words for “yes” in Romance languages

#40
"So we can look at, for example, Old Irish, where they said tó to mean yes"

Really? In modern Irish we substitute Tá for yes but it's not really yes. We don't have yes or no, we repeat the verb of the question positively or negatively. Tá is kind of 'am', níl 'am not' like

"Are you going to watch Mrs Browns Boys tonight?" "I am not."

Are they really comparable? Maybe somewhere along the line Tá (pronounced 'taw') was taken for 'yes'.

Post reply on HN