Live data from Hacker News

China spends $300M to buy lab produced meats from Israel

fanaticalfuturist.com

11–20 of 25 posts

Re: China spends $300M to buy lab produced meats from Israel

#11
post #6
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have little background about the cultured meat, and this link made me curious: wouldn't cancer cells be good candidate cells for creating this type of meat?

I also have little background, but I'd imagine the type of meat that cancer cells create is not the same as the type that tastes good.

[deleted]

Re: China spends $300M to buy lab produced meats from Israel

#12

This title is misleading (no one has spent a dollar as far as I can tell) and the article gets several facts wrong. For instance, it says "Meat The Future" is a clean meat company when in fact it's a sort of marketing and design group. There is no way China could buy meat from them. Poorly researched clickbait.

There seems to be a better article from a more reliable source: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/china-israel-tr...

And there is one company: https://www.supermeat.com/ and two other which seems to be the same org labeled as non-profit or startup: https://www.futuremeat.org/

Re: China spends $300M to buy lab produced meats from Israel

#13

I remember when the first lab meat burger patty was announced it was like $300K to produce. There aren't long term studies into what lab produced meat means for the human body right? It's pretty new and very niche still - but knowing how China has "very loose rules" on these kind of topixs (I'm no expert in policies but it does feel like that), this looks like a great move to speed up (by injecting a lot of capital i…

If the FDA approves it for sale I'll likely be one of the early adopters.

I'd love to see meat that is better for the environment and does away with the ethical concerns of pig, chicken and cow farms.

Re: China spends $300M to buy lab produced meats from Israel

#16
post #10
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have any evidence why cancer shouldn't taste good?

"good" steak, for instance is marbled. i'm not sure how you can get that with uncontrolled growth of one type of tissue. best case scenario you grow a huge chunk of cancerous muscle, and grind it with fat to make ground beef.

But suppose I don't care about fat, in fact I want my meat to be as lean as possible.

Re: China spends $300M to buy lab produced meats from Israel

#17
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"good" steak, for instance is marbled. i'm not sure how you can get that with uncontrolled growth of one type of tissue. best case scenario you grow a huge chunk of cancerous muscle, and grind it with fat to make ground beef.

But suppose I don't care about fat, in fact I want my meat to be as lean as possible.

i'm not sure what the point of that is. not sure about everyone else, but the main motivation for eating meat is that it tastes good. without fat, 100% muscle would be very dry/tough. you might as well eat tofu.

Re: China spends $300M to buy lab produced meats from Israel

#18

This title is misleading (no one has spent a dollar as far as I can tell) and the article gets several facts wrong. For instance, it says "Meat The Future" is a clean meat company when in fact it's a sort of marketing and design group. There is no way China could buy meat from them. Poorly researched clickbait.

Meat The Future has (or at least used to have) a small lab in Manchester, UK with a dozen or so chemical engineers. I tasted their "meat" last August it was god awful ...

Re: China spends $300M to buy lab produced meats from Israel

#19
post #7
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I also have little background, but I'd imagine the type of meat that cancer cells create is not the same as the type that tastes good.

Do you have any evidence why cancer shouldn't taste good?

Tumours are typically poorly organised tissues with areas of dead cells (necrosis) and very fibrous reactions from surrounding tissue (desmoplastic reaction). A steak made out of a large tumour would look patchy, and have areas of cheesy looking dead tissue that will belch yellow goo when you touch it. It will also be very chewy. Additionally, most cancers develop in tissues that are the equivalent of the gizzards, whereas most human meat consumption is muscle tissue.

Re: China spends $300M to buy lab produced meats from Israel

#20
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But suppose I don't care about fat, in fact I want my meat to be as lean as possible.

i'm not sure what the point of that is. not sure about everyone else, but the main motivation for eating meat is that it tastes good. without fat, 100% muscle would be very dry/tough. you might as well eat tofu.

> you might as well eat tofu.

I guess this is a bad time to say I love tofu?

I'm more concerned whether or not it's technologically possible without health risks.

Post reply on HN