Live data from Hacker News

Does wearing glasses weaken your eyesight? (2014)

bbc.com

21–30 of 60 posts

Re: Does wearing glasses weaken your eyesight? (2014)

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Myopia, at least for children, could be the result of lack of exposure to sufficient light during the growing phase ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjdkbcOx05A ).In the research, chicks with exposure to 10000+ lux had prevented myopia, while the other chicks which didn't get exposed to enough light developed myopia. The overall recommendation from the study was for children to get at least 3 hours of outdoor activi…

In contrast to your anecdote, my brother went outside far more often than I did growing up, and his nearsightedness is both much worse and getting worse more quickly than mine (mine has changed between .25 and .5 over the last 10 years, his has changed by something like 2 in the last 5).

Please stop doing this. We all know anecdata isn’t, so why continue to spread the trope? “It’s not data, but...” Then don’t share it.

Re: Does wearing glasses weaken your eyesight? (2014)

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In contrast to your anecdote, my brother went outside far more often than I did growing up, and his nearsightedness is both much worse and getting worse more quickly than mine (mine has changed between .25 and .5 over the last 10 years, his has changed by something like 2 in the last 5).

Please stop doing this. We all know anecdata isn’t, so why continue to spread the trope? “It’s not data, but...” Then don’t share it.

I'm interested in personal anecdotes of statistical counter examples. I'm not going to go make policy decisions off it, but hey, interesting insight into that guy's life for me.

Re: Does wearing glasses weaken your eyesight? (2014)

#25

Knew a co-worker who'd worn glasses her whole life said her eye sight got better after she turned 50. The optometrist told her the muscles around your eye weaken and don't squeeze your eyeball as well, thus changing the focal point.

Someone around that age at my workplace had a moment like that too, in fact he went from near sighted to far sighted and had to get new glasses.

Re: Does wearing glasses weaken your eyesight? (2014)

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In contrast to your anecdote, my brother went outside far more often than I did growing up, and his nearsightedness is both much worse and getting worse more quickly than mine (mine has changed between .25 and .5 over the last 10 years, his has changed by something like 2 in the last 5).

Please stop doing this. We all know anecdata isn’t, so why continue to spread the trope? “It’s not data, but...” Then don’t share it.

The best antidote to an anecdote is one from the opposite angle. At least it starts me thinking who I should believe (if anyone) and why.

Re: Does wearing glasses weaken your eyesight? (2014)

#29

Everyone in my family said to me as a teen why aren't you wearing your glasses? You know your eyesight will get worse. Ten years later as a 27 year old I went to the opticians and they had got worse by .25 which my optician told me is so nelgigible that people drop by that in six months. I know this is hardly a scientific study but I do get suspicious sometimes the advice to wear glasses is coming from the opticians…

It appears to me that there is a very peculiar vacuum of knowledge surrounding eyesight and glasses among the public, and what must surely be willful ignorance amongst opticians.

Re: Does wearing glasses weaken your eyesight? (2014)

#30
All I know on this is that I was near sighted from the 3rd grade on. My vision steadily got worse when I was wearing glasses. When I switched to contacts, it stayed at the same level. Had to go without the contacts for a year and it got worse again.

Finally got lasik and it’s been perfect for 10+ years.

Anecdotal I know, but still...

Post reply on HN