Live data from Hacker News

Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

nme.com

501–510 of 545 posts

Re: Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

#501
post #130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They don't confiscate the phones. They put them in a locked bag and hand the bag back to you. There are places throughout the venue that you can get the back unlocked to use your phone.

In other words, they don't confiscate, they deface the phones.

You've used the word 'deface' throughout this thread and I don't understand it. How is putting a phone in a bag defacing it?

Re: Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

#502
post #467

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't be ridiculous. Fear of terrorism is not the only factor. Cellphones are one of the past century's greatest contributions to public safety. If you want to be antagonistic about the threat of a bombing, how about a more commonplace example: you're a very drunk young girl who's been separated from her friends at the concert and a pushy, aggressive guy you don't know is trying to get you into his car to go home wit…

> Or how about this? > Or how about this? > Don't act like cellphones have no practical use sigh Humans have survived for hundreds of thousands of years without cellphones. For any new tech, you can continually imagine scenarios where survival "absolutely depends on" having this tech. How about this? You're sitting in your ISS sleep capsule and suddenly the station starts to depressurize. You hop into your reentry-sa…

Please don't troll.

Re: Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

#503

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Part of my human experience may include checking how the babysitter is doing with the kids. I'm not going to do that in a way that disrupts the show, but I still want that access.

Then you don't go to the show. Sorry but you talk about checking in on the babysitter as if it's some universal law. It's not you don't have to, and if you feel like you can't go out and enjoy a show without checking in then don't go to the show. And yes I have kids.

Why do you believe FYGM is an appropriate response?

Re: Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

#504
post #87

I experienced the Yondr phone prison last night for the first time (at a Chris Rock show). While I detest people being disruptive with their phones, I don’t think this is the right solution. From a practical standpoint, it took a lot longer to get into and out of the venue when phones had to be locked up. Checking your phone when you pop out to the toilet meant waiting in a queue to have your phone unlocked, and bein…

I agree. I'm an adult, if you ask me to not use my phone I will comply. If other adults can't do the same, then simply ask them to leave. Yondr feels patronising, almost like we are being treated like children. That being said, I generally don't go to gigs anymore because its getting more like flying. Expensive tickets with hidden fees, being forced to queue neatly like school children, searches, and then the overpri…

Agreed ... I mean, this is basically the same as the cinema. You're told not to use your phone. People are asked not to be noisy, and turn off their phones, etc. The majority are civil and there's the occasional bad egg, but hey ... it's a gathering of people - there's always going to be a level of compromise.

Re: Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

#505

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We need a new etiquette and I'm not sure our culture can support one right now. Video: A few seconds, once or twice, is ok. Photos: No flash photography Audio: Record the whole show if you want. Isn't that how most Phish music is distributed? I am fine with artists putting hard limits on their audience. If they believe it will improve their art, let's give them the benefit of the doubt. It might help or hurt them fin…

I find it really depends on the venue and the audience. If you are playing to an audience of mostly musicians and music appreciation types, the cell phones are hardly seen. It's the general crowd who isn't really there for the music that are the types to record an entire show. I veer towards snobbery saying it like that, obviously, but it's like seeing two people at an art gallery. The one snapping pics of everything…

>It's the general crowd who isn't really there for the music

I guess it wouldn't be surprising to find that it'd be the people who are most interested in doing something or going somewhere so they could tell people about it, rather than for the experience itself.

Re: Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

#506
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the viscerality of this response is fascinating. Putting your phone in a case is a "prison", and you must check it every time you go to the toilet, and you're concerned about a terrorist attack -- enough to want your phone, but not enough to stay home, as if your apps could somehow save you. > Treat people like adults. If they break the rules, ask them to leave. Isn't that what we've been trying for the past…

Don't be ridiculous. Fear of terrorism is not the only factor. Cellphones are one of the past century's greatest contributions to public safety. If you want to be antagonistic about the threat of a bombing, how about a more commonplace example: you're a very drunk young girl who's been separated from her friends at the concert and a pushy, aggressive guy you don't know is trying to get you into his car to go home wit…

Why even leave the house then if your life is so terror filled? It's a concert not a war zone.

Re: Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

#508
post #268

Earlier quoted context omitted.

needs to call you to escape a dangerous situation Can you describe a scenario for me? Because I'm having a very hard time imagining one where the teenager is immediate peril (otherwise they could just unlock the phone in the next room) yet the best person to help them is not in the building. Maybe it's unfair, but it just sounds like helicopter parenting to me.

Let's imagine that my child is at a party or other social engagement and they want deniable reason to escape. [0] There may be excessive peer pressure, illegal activity, or any other pre-arranged reason they may need to bail on something without incurring the loss of face that could be socially devastating. If I have my phone, they can text me with some pre-arranged message ("x"), and I will feign an emergency and ge…

Why even let them leave the house if the world is such a horrible and dangerous place.

Seems like bad parenting if you're knowingly putting in situations where such horrors exist that they'd need to escape them.

Re: Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

#509
post #87

I experienced the Yondr phone prison last night for the first time (at a Chris Rock show). While I detest people being disruptive with their phones, I don’t think this is the right solution. From a practical standpoint, it took a lot longer to get into and out of the venue when phones had to be locked up. Checking your phone when you pop out to the toilet meant waiting in a queue to have your phone unlocked, and bein…

"There have been a number of times when I’ve been split up from friends at large venues - not being able to text each other to meet up is inconvenient."

Dude.

What do you think people did at Rolling Stones or Zeppelin concerts in the 60-70's?

What do you think people did at Michael Jackson concerts in the 80's?

What do you think people did at Nirvana and Pearl Jam concerts in the 90's?

People have lived without text messaging far longer that we've had it. If this is your chief complaint, I think you need to think harder about the problem space.

Re: Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”

#510

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let's think of a million different hypothetical situations in which not having a phone is bad. Result: you sound helpless.

It does make me wonder how they cope when they travel overseas. Do they still use their phones as much there? Do they just accept the large bill?

I'm anti phones in gigs, but spent a while overseas and the phone was really helpful... as an offline device.

- Save docs of maps for later. - Save docs of the names of place you want to go (translated into the local language and in your own language) - Similar for a few key locations (ok - mostly the hotel).

Makes a big difference when you can't read the local language... but yeah, being connected, not needed - and I could have done all that with bits of paper.

Post reply on HN