Live data from Hacker News

Building a Lightroom PC

paulstamatiou.com

41–50 of 232 posts

Re: Building a Lightroom PC

#41
post #5

So, the main reason he switched to a Windows machine was to use the latest/fastest hardware with Adobe Lightroom and Premiere, but then he goes on to say the Lightroom and Premiere don’t take advantage of many core CPUs, the fastest GPUs, fastest SSDs, etc... And Windows is fine after tweaking and adjusting dozens of settings. I’ll just stick with a Mac.

Mac isn't really an option if you want a powerful desktop though, unless you want to spend $5k I guess...

Re: Building a Lightroom PC

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fair point :) I should reconsider. The UltraSharp line is factory calibrated but yea that doesn't mean much as it varies between display.

In what sense are they calibrated if things vary between displays?

Factory calibration is a thing in UltraSharp line, can't be compared to hardware calibration but works pretty well out-of-the-box.

http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/reviews/dell_up2718q.htm#hardwar...

Re: Building a Lightroom PC

#43

> PCPartPicker.com is one relatively new resource that I have found to be invaluable. Just the greatest site ever, if you're into building your own PCs. Fun to browse other builds, and then it makes it so simple to put together a system.

I second that - Anyone reading this thinking about building a PC, make sure you use this site. Can't stress that enough.

Re: Building a Lightroom PC

#44
post #8

Step 1. Be wealthy :P I am always enamored with the simplicity of one's living space being directly proportional to wealth. I try hard to not have much stuff, but my living options are seemingly always going to be working class style places with pretty much the antithesis of what is apparent in this photo. Of course the camera lies, and I shouldn't compare my insides to some else's outsides. There's probably a new pu…

Have you given up on making some money?

I guess no? But I did for sure notice a change in my ambition / perspective a while ago after I crossed the theoretical threshold mentioned quite a bit a few years ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1381927

I guess I value time more now? Honestly I may have to sit on your question a while and maybe it was one that was lingering when I posted my comment.

Re: Building a Lightroom PC

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fair point :) I should reconsider. The UltraSharp line is factory calibrated but yea that doesn't mean much as it varies between display.

In what sense are they calibrated if things vary between displays?

They do a base calibration. Do a Google search for Dell Calibration report. It shows what they calibrate. Keep in mind, it's still a pretty loose calibration. I've never once gotten two of the same models that look the same out of the box.

Re: Building a Lightroom PC

#46
post #43

> PCPartPicker.com is one relatively new resource that I have found to be invaluable. Just the greatest site ever, if you're into building your own PCs. Fun to browse other builds, and then it makes it so simple to put together a system.

I second that - Anyone reading this thinking about building a PC, make sure you use this site. Can't stress that enough.

Second that, it pulls data from a number of retailers and has localized sites with local retailers which is a nice touch.

Something I noticed is that if the item price can’t be displayed you can search around the item options and enter your own pricing to get a feel of the price of the system if parts would be in stock

Re: Building a Lightroom PC

#47
post #41
post #5

So, the main reason he switched to a Windows machine was to use the latest/fastest hardware with Adobe Lightroom and Premiere, but then he goes on to say the Lightroom and Premiere don’t take advantage of many core CPUs, the fastest GPUs, fastest SSDs, etc... And Windows is fine after tweaking and adjusting dozens of settings. I’ll just stick with a Mac.

Mac isn't really an option if you want a powerful desktop though, unless you want to spend $5k I guess...

[deleted]

Re: Building a Lightroom PC

#48
I've had similar a experience doing Android Development. I much prefer OS X over Windows 10 for doing work, but performance can be a real issue.

Over time, and with every new yearly incremental software refresh, compile times on my MacBook getting slower and slower, it started to hurt productivity. So looking at options for new hardware, I realized I could either spend $3000 on a new Mac, that on paper might not even be that much faster then my current machine, or just throw together a PC from components for a bit over $1000 and get a much faster machine.

There is just no good Mac option if you're looking for a simple i7, 32GB RAM, 256 SSD for a reasonable price.

Re: Building a Lightroom PC

#49
post #27
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think that Premier does really take advantage of video cards. I saw a video where they had switched a really old GTX 660 vs a 1080ti and the render time was not changed between them.

It's possible the operation bandwidth limited in which case at some point a faster card won't speed it up any more. But gpu acceleration vs software is an enormous difference in premiere

In our workload this is definitely the case. When on the GPU the processing is almost infinitely quick. It's the transfer to and from the GPU memory which takes the time. This might be the case in the parent post.

There was a guy who managed to go directly from the SATA controller to GPU memory by modifying the Linux kernel for some postgres database queries and got massive speedup. Would love it if that sort of optimization could be more readily available.

Post reply on HN