Live data from Hacker News

Tesla ‘on Autopilot’ slams into parked fire truck on freeway

mercurynews.com

1–10 of 184 posts

Re: Tesla ‘on Autopilot’ slams into parked fire truck on freeway

#2
I wonder if it is imprudent to create too many vehicles that have partial self-driving capability before we have ones that can do 100% of it. Instead of to the point where you can take your attention away from the road, but not to the point where it can reliably avoid accidents on your behalf. Too many people aren't wise enough to use the partial autonomous technology without abusing it.

Re: Tesla ‘on Autopilot’ slams into parked fire truck on freeway

#3

I wonder if it is imprudent to create too many vehicles that have partial self-driving capability before we have ones that can do 100% of it. Instead of to the point where you can take your attention away from the road, but not to the point where it can reliably avoid accidents on your behalf. Too many people aren't wise enough to use the partial autonomous technology without abusing it.

I have a feeling Tesla knew this and didn't care. The marketing value of "Autopilot" is too great.

Re: Tesla ‘on Autopilot’ slams into parked fire truck on freeway

#4

I wonder if it is imprudent to create too many vehicles that have partial self-driving capability before we have ones that can do 100% of it. Instead of to the point where you can take your attention away from the road, but not to the point where it can reliably avoid accidents on your behalf. Too many people aren't wise enough to use the partial autonomous technology without abusing it.

I have a feeling Tesla knew this and didn't care. The marketing value of "Autopilot" is too great.

[deleted]

Re: Tesla ‘on Autopilot’ slams into parked fire truck on freeway

#5
Seems fairly impressive that nobody was killed.

Will this turn out to be another "brightly lit sky" autopilot bug, like the 2016 semi truck incident?

https://www.tesla.com/blog/tragic-loss "Neither Autopilot nor the driver noticed the white side of the tractor trailer against a brightly lit sky, so the brake was not applied"

Re: Tesla ‘on Autopilot’ slams into parked fire truck on freeway

#6

I wonder if it is imprudent to create too many vehicles that have partial self-driving capability before we have ones that can do 100% of it. Instead of to the point where you can take your attention away from the road, but not to the point where it can reliably avoid accidents on your behalf. Too many people aren't wise enough to use the partial autonomous technology without abusing it.

Maybe they could take some ideas from the rail industry, which have been dealing with this issue for quite some time now.

Engineers are required to to make some kind of input to verify that they're still alert, or the train stops[1] if they haven't done anything in X seconds.

Obviously you wouldn't want the car to just stop in the middle of the road, but there could be something like that designed.

[1] https://www.quora.com/If-a-train-driver-falls-asleep-what-ha...

Re: Tesla ‘on Autopilot’ slams into parked fire truck on freeway

#7

I wonder if it is imprudent to create too many vehicles that have partial self-driving capability before we have ones that can do 100% of it. Instead of to the point where you can take your attention away from the road, but not to the point where it can reliably avoid accidents on your behalf. Too many people aren't wise enough to use the partial autonomous technology without abusing it.

Maybe they could take some ideas from the rail industry, which have been dealing with this issue for quite some time now. Engineers are required to to make some kind of input to verify that they're still alert, or the train stops[1] if they haven't done anything in X seconds. Obviously you wouldn't want the car to just stop in the middle of the road, but there could be something like that designed. [1] https://www.qu…

[deleted]

Re: Tesla ‘on Autopilot’ slams into parked fire truck on freeway

#9

Seems fairly impressive that nobody was killed. Will this turn out to be another "brightly lit sky" autopilot bug, like the 2016 semi truck incident? https://www.tesla.com/blog/tragic-loss "Neither Autopilot nor the driver noticed the white side of the tractor trailer against a brightly lit sky, so the brake was not applied"

Wait, so is non (human-) visible wavelengths not part of the autopilot system?

Re: Tesla ‘on Autopilot’ slams into parked fire truck on freeway

#10

Seems fairly impressive that nobody was killed. Will this turn out to be another "brightly lit sky" autopilot bug, like the 2016 semi truck incident? https://www.tesla.com/blog/tragic-loss "Neither Autopilot nor the driver noticed the white side of the tractor trailer against a brightly lit sky, so the brake was not applied"

Wait, so is non (human-) visible wavelengths not part of the autopilot system?

Tesla, to save money, is trying to build autopilot from regular video cameras in visible spectrum. EDIT: Some models still contain other sensors, but Musk has been trying to go with purely optical for a long time.
Post reply on HN