Live data from Hacker News

Let Me Ruin This for You: The Schadenfreude of Criticism

thesmartset.com

51–52 of 52 posts

Re: Let Me Ruin This for You: The Schadenfreude of Criticism

#51
post #10

The author is essentially saying that criticism is a tool to hurt others. I find this idea interesting, and worthwhile to think about. A question I now have is, in this theory, who does one want to hurt exactly? Is it always the subject of my scorn I want to hurt with criticism, or is it more complicated than that - if I rant about Java on Twitter (I don’t do Java dev anymore), who do I want to hurt? Java devs? Oracl…

> The author is essentially saying that criticism is a tool to hurt others.

Interesting opinion. Criticism takes effort, something I am not willing to waste on those I don't consider worthy of my time. If I want to hurt someone, I ignore them. They get no feedback from me, no information on how to improve themselves.

Re: Let Me Ruin This for You: The Schadenfreude of Criticism

#52
post #26

"But all critics think they’re doing the world a favor. If they didn’t believe this delusion, criticism wouldn’t get written." I disagree, some people just like to burst bubbles. I think it makes them feel better.

The world needs pessimists as much as it needs optimists.

I do not agree. Nothing wrong with a person who sees the glass half full if that person knows that 50% of the glass is occupied. Optimists can still keep it real.
Post reply on HN