Live data from Hacker News

Firefox bullshit removal

gist.github.com

141–150 of 183 posts

Re: Firefox bullshit removal

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't believe your personal convenience trumps everyone's right to privacy.

A crash log doesn't violate your privacy, nor does usage statistics when properly anonymized. Sometimes telemetry is just telemetry.

> A crash log doesn't violate your privacy

Says who?

If that's the case then ask the user to email you the log. Instead, we get covert eavesdropping.

Re: Firefox bullshit removal

#142
post #8

"These are used by Mozilla to spy on you, and are as such a significant risk to privacy." Wow that's a big claim. Any proofs that the data collected is not anonymous? It sounds a lot like fear-mongering

I would rather expect the one collecting the data to prove that they are anonymous. And MetaData anyway? In many countries they may be used without a court order. A false sense of security is the worst.

Re: Firefox bullshit removal

#144
post #92
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was under the impression the search deals are merely which engine are the default. How does having the default search be Google make the Mozilla corp beholden to Google?

If Google is paying what Yahoo was, it's $300 million a year for the default search option on Firefox. Google pays Apple billions to stay the default on the iPhone as well.

So if Google stopped paying Apple, what would they do? Switch to Bing? I'm sure their users would love that

Re: Firefox bullshit removal

#145
I think we are going full circle from IE5 times. Those days activeX was bad as it can get.. today's browsers are full of features like that.. and now it's not safe anymore to use them.. did we learn anything from flash ?

Re: Firefox bullshit removal

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't believe your personal convenience trumps everyone's right to privacy.

A crash log doesn't violate your privacy, nor does usage statistics when properly anonymized. Sometimes telemetry is just telemetry.

Properly anonymised doesn't exist. Every mechanism has been broken.

Re: Firefox bullshit removal

#147
post #140

I'm puzzled that he sees websockets as a privacy hazard. From what I understand, WS connections are CORS protected (though the model is slightly different than standard CORS for historical reasons) and were designed somwhat friendly to proxies. So what is the problem? (Though browsers don't seem to honor proxy settings for WS in practice. I guess, this coughs be corrected. Does anyone know the reasons for that?) WebR…

You don't need to decrypt TLS to know where it's going. SNI leaks the domain in plaintext and if SNI isn't enabled you can just use the IP address.

Re: Firefox bullshit removal

#148
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think he's just pointing out the irony of someone purporting to aid the security-conscious having an expired cert on his own site. Unless this is really some meta-level social commentary on how people will trust a complete stranger's website despite an invalid cert because he seems like a nice guy.

Why do few pages of readonly text advice need a certificate that badly?

The wrong read-only text gets you arrested.

Re: Firefox bullshit removal

#149
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wired, it gives me a location 3 miles away from my house. Smartphone, it want to use GPS. That's kind of cheating, isn't it?

Smartphone, it want to use GPS. That's kind of cheating, isn't it? It is, but it also shows just how much information people could leak if they casually dismiss any permissions prompting with "allow" (or even worse, have such permissions be granted by default.)

Which makes the removal of the location feature (or the default off) all the more better.

Re: Firefox bullshit removal

#150
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On the contrary. Maybe if you're on a hardwired desktop, but for everything else it is incredibly accurate. You don't even need to have GPS in your device -- WiFi is plenty. Try it: https://whereamirightnow.com/ It puts my laptop exactly where I am.

Wired, it gives me a location 3 miles away from my house. Smartphone, it want to use GPS. That's kind of cheating, isn't it?

The OP said wifi w/o GPS. Give that a shot maybe?
Post reply on HN