Live data from Hacker News

Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

firstthings.com

21–30 of 77 posts

Re: Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

#21
post #13

Disney didn't pay a few billion for the Star Wars property to just end the war. The resistance/rebels will be fighting forever.

Nobody is going to buy tickets to "Star Peace".

I can't speak for everyone, but I would definitely have bought tickets to Star Peace. Especially over "Star Wars: even more cgi edition".

Re: Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

#22
Assuming this is at all serious (which I doubt), it would be a rather cynical, facile, and insipid reading of both The Last Jedi and history itself. The most egregious point (of the many to choose from that I could dissect) is the following:

> But she has absorbed the rebels’ self-serving narrative, and it prevents her from realizing that the Skywalkers and the Rebellion—or Resistance, or whatever they are calling themselves now—have no answers.

The answer is "not fascism." The Empire and First Order are fascist regimes. Fighting fascism is the answer. There is no perfect system. But systems that support the systematic oppression of all people via threat of violence are evil.

Re: Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

#23
post #15

Please note: I think this piece is satiric. Please see the end note: Caleb Cohoe is associate professor of philosophy at Metropolitan State University of Denver. Samantha Cohoe is a Latin teacher, writer of young adult fiction, and frequent contributor to twitter.com. The views expressed in this article are not endorsed by and do not in any way represent the opinions of their employers or Leo Strauss. They should als…

If it is satirical, they're trolling a seriously conservative Roman Catholic site.

Re: Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

#25
post #12

There is some overfitting happening here but generally speaking I agree with the analysis. People I interact with from my own generation and younger can see that our established institutions may have failed to secure the near future for existing and arriving generations, and they are permanently shunning those institutions wherever possible. You can see this in IT as well where we have myriad foundational problems at…

Yeah, simple answer: we need heroes and villains for a story.

But I think there is some cultural "zeitgeist" reflected in the more optimistic original Star Wars and the cynicism of the current reboot.

I find it refreshingly actually. When the original Star Wars came along it seemed to shut down the cynicism of Sci Fi that had dominated up to that point (Soylent Green, West World, Logan's Run, Rollerball, etc.).

Re: Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nobody is going to buy tickets to "Star Peace".

I can't speak for everyone, but I would definitely have bought tickets to Star Peace. Especially over "Star Wars: even more cgi edition".

I can see it now. Two hours of Luke, Leia and Han just hanging out talking about how awesome things are without the empire, maybe make fun of C3PO a bit have a few drinks then just cruise around checking out how chill all the planets are now.

Re: Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

#27

Assuming this is at all serious (which I doubt), it would be a rather cynical, facile, and insipid reading of both The Last Jedi and history itself. The most egregious point (of the many to choose from that I could dissect) is the following: > But she has absorbed the rebels’ self-serving narrative, and it prevents her from realizing that the Skywalkers and the Rebellion—or Resistance, or whatever they are calling th…

The empires are just attempting to establish peace throughout the universe. The rebels, on the other hand, appear to want chronic instability and violence, getting entire civilizations obliterated due to their dislike for authority figures.

Re: Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

#28

Assuming this is at all serious (which I doubt), it would be a rather cynical, facile, and insipid reading of both The Last Jedi and history itself. The most egregious point (of the many to choose from that I could dissect) is the following: > But she has absorbed the rebels’ self-serving narrative, and it prevents her from realizing that the Skywalkers and the Rebellion—or Resistance, or whatever they are calling th…

Except, of course, for the point about saving the horses and leaving the stable boy.

Re: Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

#29
post #15

Please note: I think this piece is satiric. Please see the end note: Caleb Cohoe is associate professor of philosophy at Metropolitan State University of Denver. Samantha Cohoe is a Latin teacher, writer of young adult fiction, and frequent contributor to twitter.com. The views expressed in this article are not endorsed by and do not in any way represent the opinions of their employers or Leo Strauss. They should als…

According to Leo Strauss' esoteric doctrine, satire is one of the best ways to communicate truth through the disillusioning power of the comic, such as Aristophanes in Plato's Symposium.

Re: Millennials Strike Back: An Esoteric Reading of the Last Jedi

#30

Assuming this is at all serious (which I doubt), it would be a rather cynical, facile, and insipid reading of both The Last Jedi and history itself. The most egregious point (of the many to choose from that I could dissect) is the following: > But she has absorbed the rebels’ self-serving narrative, and it prevents her from realizing that the Skywalkers and the Rebellion—or Resistance, or whatever they are calling th…

The standard disclaimer at the end has some non-standard text:

> The views expressed in this article are not endorsed by and do not in any way represent the opinions of their employers or Leo Strauss. They should also not be taken to express the views of the authors.

Post reply on HN