Live data from Hacker News

Million Short allows users to remove up to the top 1M sites from a search set

forbes.com

1–10 of 59 posts

Re: Million Short allows users to remove up to the top 1M sites from a search set

#2
The actual site (millionshort.com) seems hugged to death. I was excited to try it.

If it takes off, I wonder if the phenomenon will give a boost to affiliate sites. If you can't be there in the top results, align with those who can.

Re: Million Short allows users to remove up to the top 1M sites from a search set

#3
This is a cute idea, but there are some genuinely useful sites this winds up skipping over. Wikipedia is a great resource for quickly understanding a topic enough to drill down in to more precise research.

Where I see this being useful is searching for current events. For example a search for a local double-shooting I've been following returned some information I hadn't seen before. It would probably be good for them to focus on more news-oriented searching as that's where there's a serious echo chamber among the top websites.

Re: Million Short allows users to remove up to the top 1M sites from a search set

#6
I’ve always wanted to see a search engine thar takes the top SEO tips and penalizes sites that use them.

For example searching for how to grow a garden. I never want to see howtogrowagarden.com. I’d prefer to find more genuine l, non seo juiced advice.

Re: Million Short allows users to remove up to the top 1M sites from a search set

#8
post #6

I’ve always wanted to see a search engine thar takes the top SEO tips and penalizes sites that use them. For example searching for how to grow a garden. I never want to see howtogrowagarden.com. I’d prefer to find more genuine l, non seo juiced advice.

Many SEO tips, like using H1 tags, make the site more usable IMO. I imagine removing the top million leaves you with some pretty ugly sites.

I’d like to remove just the top 10K or 100K.

Re: Million Short allows users to remove up to the top 1M sites from a search set

#9
post #6

I’ve always wanted to see a search engine thar takes the top SEO tips and penalizes sites that use them. For example searching for how to grow a garden. I never want to see howtogrowagarden.com. I’d prefer to find more genuine l, non seo juiced advice.

Problem is that SEO is tied to appearing relevant, so to penalize SEO is to penalize relevancy. Splitting SEO from relevancy is often a matter of making better search

Searching for least-relevant can be pretty random: it's easy to point at the center of a circle, but the edge of the circle is not a point

Re: Million Short allows users to remove up to the top 1M sites from a search set

#10
I use million short to search for howtos written by real craftsmen in their field.

One example is an end-grain cutting board that I made recently. For most things Ike that, the top 1000 are dominated by made-for-Pinterest blogs or major sites that aggregate low quality content that's good enough to get hits but not good for much more than that.

Post reply on HN