Live data from Hacker News

Spotify files for its IPO

axios.com

61–70 of 218 posts

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#61
post #46

I don't think this is a good long term investment. Disclaimer: I worked for a Spotify competitor in the past, so i have a pretty solid understanding of how the business works. I think it is a bad investment for one simple reason: Spotify purchases its main product (music) from a oligopoly. I'd estimate that 95%+ of the tracks streamed (by total playtime) are from one of the 3 major music labels: Universal, Sony or Wa…

I don't have any opinion on how good of an investment Spotify is, but the power balance between Spotify and the labels may not be as lopsided as you think.

Rap Caviar, a playlist curated by Spotify, is making music into hits: http://www.vulture.com/2017/09/spotify-rapcaviar-most-influe...

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#62
Wow way to try to maximize how much you can dump employee options and stock into an IPO before the lawsuit and others like it materialize. This is nuts. Lawsuit yesterday start of IPO process today.

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#63
post #60
post #46

I don't think this is a good long term investment. Disclaimer: I worked for a Spotify competitor in the past, so i have a pretty solid understanding of how the business works. I think it is a bad investment for one simple reason: Spotify purchases its main product (music) from a oligopoly. I'd estimate that 95%+ of the tracks streamed (by total playtime) are from one of the 3 major music labels: Universal, Sony or Wa…

I think this has a good chance of being a good long-term investment for one simple reason. Spotify has something that few companies have but all dream of: pricing power. The other week, my kids were watching TV and my wife and I were in the kitchen and one of them yelled out, "Mom, something popped up on Netflix saying the price is going up. What should I do?" My wife and I said the same thing instantly: "Just hit ok…

Why wouldn't everyone just go to Apple/Google Music if Spotify raised their prices? None of them have exclusive content or features that rival Netflix's exclusive library, I don't see why Spotify have any meaningful pricing power. I'm one of those people who hit OK this year when Netflix raised their price, but I'll immediately leave Spotify if they raise their prices and the competition don't - they have nothing sticky for me.

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#64
post #60
post #46

I don't think this is a good long term investment. Disclaimer: I worked for a Spotify competitor in the past, so i have a pretty solid understanding of how the business works. I think it is a bad investment for one simple reason: Spotify purchases its main product (music) from a oligopoly. I'd estimate that 95%+ of the tracks streamed (by total playtime) are from one of the 3 major music labels: Universal, Sony or Wa…

I think this has a good chance of being a good long-term investment for one simple reason. Spotify has something that few companies have but all dream of: pricing power. The other week, my kids were watching TV and my wife and I were in the kitchen and one of them yelled out, "Mom, something popped up on Netflix saying the price is going up. What should I do?" My wife and I said the same thing instantly: "Just hit ok…

Netflix can do that only because they have their own content with a large following. Unless Spotify feels like getting a bunch of popular artists to distribute with them, they're screwed.

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#65
post #60
post #46

I don't think this is a good long term investment. Disclaimer: I worked for a Spotify competitor in the past, so i have a pretty solid understanding of how the business works. I think it is a bad investment for one simple reason: Spotify purchases its main product (music) from a oligopoly. I'd estimate that 95%+ of the tracks streamed (by total playtime) are from one of the 3 major music labels: Universal, Sony or Wa…

I think this has a good chance of being a good long-term investment for one simple reason. Spotify has something that few companies have but all dream of: pricing power. The other week, my kids were watching TV and my wife and I were in the kitchen and one of them yelled out, "Mom, something popped up on Netflix saying the price is going up. What should I do?" My wife and I said the same thing instantly: "Just hit ok…

This is also magnified by the fact that they have buying power in a way Netflix does not. Netflix has had to product a ton of their own content to retain users, I'm increasingly considering leaving Netflix in favor of Hulu simply because they have far more content from traditional TV channels (from my perspective Netflix is just becoming a worse HBO).

Spotify on the other hand, doesn't have the issue of content being removed from it in the same way. Additionally due to the legacy of radio, there is a generally accepted amount that you should pay per play. This continues to the fact that spotify could over time expand into other areas of the music industry such as being a platform for artists to sell merchandise and concert tickets which is the most viable way for small artists to make money.

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#66
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this has a good chance of being a good long-term investment for one simple reason. Spotify has something that few companies have but all dream of: pricing power. The other week, my kids were watching TV and my wife and I were in the kitchen and one of them yelled out, "Mom, something popped up on Netflix saying the price is going up. What should I do?" My wife and I said the same thing instantly: "Just hit ok…

Why wouldn't everyone just go to Apple/Google Music if Spotify raised their prices? None of them have exclusive content or features that rival Netflix's exclusive library, I don't see why Spotify have any meaningful pricing power. I'm one of those people who hit OK this year when Netflix raised their price, but I'll immediately leave Spotify if they raise their prices and the competition don't - they have nothing sti…

Same reason people don't move from Amazon to Wal-Mart, or Apple to Android, or Netflix to...I don't even know what. Spotify is objectively better as a service, people love it, and we are creatures of habit. There are other factors like social and all the playlists you've created. Besides, people derive value from things based on more than price alone. You might not see why they have pricing power but the fact is they have over 60 million paying subscribers so they must be doing something right. And is the ~$10/month meaningful for any of those subscribers? Probably not at all. I mean, you're going to tell me that people line up to buy a $1,000 iPhone which costs 25% more than a previous model but perhaps an extra $2/month for Spotify (#12 app on App Store - right in between Gmail app and Uber) is going to cause an exodus? I'll take the other side of that one.

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#67
How will this IPO fare for, say, software developers who worked there for 5 or 6 years?

I had an offer on the table from them in 2011 but decided to go with Amazon instead. I'm always curious how the road not taken would have turned out.

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#68
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this has a good chance of being a good long-term investment for one simple reason. Spotify has something that few companies have but all dream of: pricing power. The other week, my kids were watching TV and my wife and I were in the kitchen and one of them yelled out, "Mom, something popped up on Netflix saying the price is going up. What should I do?" My wife and I said the same thing instantly: "Just hit ok…

Why wouldn't everyone just go to Apple/Google Music if Spotify raised their prices? None of them have exclusive content or features that rival Netflix's exclusive library, I don't see why Spotify have any meaningful pricing power. I'm one of those people who hit OK this year when Netflix raised their price, but I'll immediately leave Spotify if they raise their prices and the competition don't - they have nothing sti…

I was agreeing with you as I read these replies but then I thought of what would actually happen if Apple Music raised their prices. I think I would stay. All the music and likes/dislikes that it has about me are a pain to move. And also I really value Beats 1 and that is worth the price raise to me alone. So maybe we really are creatures of habit.

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#69
post #46

I don't think this is a good long term investment. Disclaimer: I worked for a Spotify competitor in the past, so i have a pretty solid understanding of how the business works. I think it is a bad investment for one simple reason: Spotify purchases its main product (music) from a oligopoly. I'd estimate that 95%+ of the tracks streamed (by total playtime) are from one of the 3 major music labels: Universal, Sony or Wa…

I work for one of the big three, though just a technical staff, so I am no where close to knowing the full details of how licenses are signed, but enough to understand at the high level.

I see your points and I think they are very real. Streaming is one of the biggest sources of revenue today for the major players. Territories in music industry is what's squeezing business like Spotify. You can have a deal such that Warner has exclusive right in North America for all licenses, and can then sell to Spotify. Then perhaps another deal is reserved to a Sony-owned label in Eastern Europe. So if Sony doesn't want to sign the deal with Spotify, sure, Greek users may never get to play that song on Spotify.

I remember jumping from Apple Music and YouTube to Spotify because Spotify offers by paying monthly subscription, I have instant access to many music catalogs. Unlike Apple Music, I had to pay $0.99 or whatever per album/song. I am not sure if that has changed since, but it was the #1 reason I left Apple Music.

Since the Big Three has made so much more from streaming deals, they are going to choke Spotify's throat, but also have to deal with Spotify. After all, there is a solid and a strong growth of active users on the Spotify platform.

Big Three will flex muscles, but they won't just let the deal fail. Both sides need the revenue desperately. Netflix is in the same position but it has been producing its original contents so Netflix is less dependent on outsider producers. I think Spotify will do the same: create its own label and production companies, sign artists and make deals with the Big Three at various levels. Perhaps even buy a show ticketing company. Maybe begin to create a broadcast and video platform.

Warner Music Group's owner (Access Industries) is an investor of Spoifty (Access Technology Venture is owned by Access Industries which owns WMG). There's a humor whenever I look at music industry: we play the game of music chair, because your ex-worker might just show up to your conference call the next day representing another music company. Since artist X may have separate deals with separate labels (which in turns separate music recording companies), or because WMG needs Sony's help in India or whatever, in conclusion everyone has a stake in Spotify at the end of the day, even if you are not a direct investor of Spotify.

Unfortunately, every dollar collected is split up 50 times just because it takes many parties to publish a music and then collect the money. Everyone wants a piece, and everyone will have a piece. The pie might be small, but just enough to feed.

Re: Spotify files for its IPO

#70
post #60
post #46

I don't think this is a good long term investment. Disclaimer: I worked for a Spotify competitor in the past, so i have a pretty solid understanding of how the business works. I think it is a bad investment for one simple reason: Spotify purchases its main product (music) from a oligopoly. I'd estimate that 95%+ of the tracks streamed (by total playtime) are from one of the 3 major music labels: Universal, Sony or Wa…

I think this has a good chance of being a good long-term investment for one simple reason. Spotify has something that few companies have but all dream of: pricing power. The other week, my kids were watching TV and my wife and I were in the kitchen and one of them yelled out, "Mom, something popped up on Netflix saying the price is going up. What should I do?" My wife and I said the same thing instantly: "Just hit ok…

Ignorant question (I'm not very familiar with the music business): what do the labels provide to the artists - why do they need to sign with Time Warner/Sony/etc at all, rather than just releasing their music to all distribution channels (Spotify/Apple Music/etc) themselves? I understand for smaller artists the labels can help provide advertising to them, but the larger, well-known stars you mention seem like they should have leverage to negotiate themselves?
Post reply on HN