Live data from Hacker News

Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

atlasobscura.com

11–20 of 32 posts

Re: Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

#11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because many new accounts are dead. Some are so dead, you can't even vouch for them.

You can vouch for alexi23's comment (just click on the timestamp beside the comment to find the vouch link).

Did not know that. Thanks!

Re: Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

#13
post #4

I'm not sure why alexi23's comment is dead, but it's very poetic. " The Shipping Forecast turns our landscape into a slightly ethereal world, inhabited by communities we are connected to but know nothing about “I feel chastened on nights like this when I see storm force 11, and think there are people out there contending with that weather, putting their lives at risk in pursuit of their livelihood – be it in the navy…

It might be because it's a verbatim quote from http://www.telegraph.co.uk/radio/what-to-listen-to/why-every...

Re: Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

#14
There used to be a similar weather forecast in France, called "Météo marine". It was broadcasted until 2016 on one of the national radio station (France Inter) and had a cult-like following, even (especially?) among people that had no relationship to sailing (or to the sea in general).

It's funny to see that both countries had a similar weather report that was beloved for the same reasons. Even funnier is that some of the "sea areas" described in the OP were mentioned in the french report (eg. Viking)

Marie-Pierre Planchon's voice is a madeleine de Proust to many of my friends.

Re: Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

#15
post #4

I'm not sure why alexi23's comment is dead, but it's very poetic. " The Shipping Forecast turns our landscape into a slightly ethereal world, inhabited by communities we are connected to but know nothing about “I feel chastened on nights like this when I see storm force 11, and think there are people out there contending with that weather, putting their lives at risk in pursuit of their livelihood – be it in the navy…

Ethereal yes. But let's be honest! The late night shipping forecast makes being in bed more cosy. Because they are out there, battling the gale, and we are not.

Re: Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

#16
I think the title is stretching it a bit. Almost no-one actually listens to it and as time goes on, I suspect fewer people have even heard of it. I brought it up in conversation in my office recently and had to explain what it was as it wasn't even on the modern cultural radar.

Re: Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

#17
post #4

I'm not sure why alexi23's comment is dead, but it's very poetic. " The Shipping Forecast turns our landscape into a slightly ethereal world, inhabited by communities we are connected to but know nothing about “I feel chastened on nights like this when I see storm force 11, and think there are people out there contending with that weather, putting their lives at risk in pursuit of their livelihood – be it in the navy…

Ethereal yes. But let's be honest! The late night shipping forecast makes being in bed more cosy. Because they are out there, battling the gale, and we are not.

It's not only what is said, but the timbre of the voice, repetitions and odd names, all these are hallmarks (some types) of the ASMR phenomenon Youtube.

Re: Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

#18
I'm going to propose as a conjecture that (maritime) radio weather reports are universally soothing and nostalgic, were they written by Met Office and broadcast by BBC or not.

I don't know specifics of the UK culture, so maybe they have cultivated the veneration of the Shipping Forecast to immeasurable heights unmatched by its counterparts in other nations, but I'd require some comparative evidence to persuade me that there really is something special about Radio 4 maritime report or how it's experienced (aside from the fact that it's the British weather report and not some other weather report, and thus the populace of Britain finds it more enjoyable than the continental alternatives).

The thing is, I'd expect that every country with a coastline has maritime weather reports and forecasts. And the claims about the connection to Brexit island ethos notwithstanding, the description of the evocative feelings and whatnot didn't sound alien to me at all despite never listening to the BBC Radio 4 Shipping Forecast. However, I do have heard FMI's daily "Weather report for shipping" numerous times, and it sure is part of national "radio mythology" (I remember how some years back patrons of relatively popular internet forum decided try their hand at amateur internet radio: They played music and then read aloud the weather report for shipping.)

1. Weather reports are one of the oldest type of radio content all across the continent. Their format probably has not changed much since the idea was first introduced. (After all, distilled to their most rudimentary basic form, a weather report is a series of numerical readings, and there's only so many ways you can read a collection of numerical readings aloud on radio. The poetic repetition is bound to be soothing.)

2. In countries with a national public broadcaster, such regular programming becomes part of the shared cultural experience; the daily weather report is always in the background, and because of part 1, it remains unchanged as decades pass by. This explains the nostalgia.

3. Why maritime reports could be special? Different from the regular weather reports, the condensed format and terminology of the maritime forecast communicate information whose purpose and use might be slightly alien to non-seafaring populace. At least this is my experience: I understand what kind of implications of "x degrees Celcius" would entail in my daily life; but what about the more, should I say, nautical information (wind speeds and wave heights and alike)? Not so much. Where are the measurement stations with obscure, poetic-sounding names located? No idea. In short, maritime weather reports have certain mystique to them.

4. However, I wouldn't be surprised if the Met Office and BBC were the original forerunners of this kind of public service; BBC is one of the biggest and best-funded public broadcasters in the world, of course everyone has copied them.

Someone should write a monograph on international cultural history of maritime weather reports?

Re: Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

#19

One song that samples the shipping forecast (that isn't mentioned in this article) is this Tears For Fears track from the 1980s: http://youtu.be/FDUk11Z0bkQ Gives you a good idea of the cadences in the shipping forecast itself. It can be strangely relaxing listening to the shipping forecast on BBC Radio 4.

Listening to the shipping forecast is a kind of modern day ritual, I get something similar out of ASMR videos such as this one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KD6ZktAF_hk

Re: Why the Shipping Forecast Is So Beloved in the UK

#20
Ah... When I hear the shipping forecast at 1am on BBC Radio 4, I've stayed up too late. It's interesting how Radio 4 is used... The shipping forecast and also apparently how it's used as one of the ways to see if the UK is still standing.

But now I'm reminded, it's 1:33, so I'm going to sleep now.

Post reply on HN