Live data from Hacker News

World's richest 500 see their wealth increase by $1T this year

theguardian.com

1–10 of 284 posts

Re: World's richest 500 see their wealth increase by $1T this year

#3
post #2

This article provides paragraph after paragraph of supporting data that the richest have gotten richer, but none that I can see supporting its claim that “billions of poorer people across the world have seen their wealth standstill or decline”.

Is it possible for everyone’s wealth to increase? I think they might be assuming this is not possible and there if richest wealth increases by this much it had to come from the rest?

Re: World's richest 500 see their wealth increase by $1T this year

#4
post #2

This article provides paragraph after paragraph of supporting data that the richest have gotten richer, but none that I can see supporting its claim that “billions of poorer people across the world have seen their wealth standstill or decline”.

Is it possible for everyone’s wealth to increase? I think they might be assuming this is not possible and there if richest wealth increases by this much it had to come from the rest?

Rich people tend to have most of their worth in stock. In theory, assuming your stock got more expensive, you get richer without anyone in particular getting poorer.

Re: World's richest 500 see their wealth increase by $1T this year

#5
post #2

This article provides paragraph after paragraph of supporting data that the richest have gotten richer, but none that I can see supporting its claim that “billions of poorer people across the world have seen their wealth standstill or decline”.

While a technically valid criticism, is it really that controversial? Costs are increasing faster than wages at low income levels - which is easy when wages are largely stagnant or declining due to increased competition driven by labor surplus and automation.

Re: World's richest 500 see their wealth increase by $1T this year

#6
post #2

This article provides paragraph after paragraph of supporting data that the richest have gotten richer, but none that I can see supporting its claim that “billions of poorer people across the world have seen their wealth standstill or decline”.

Is it possible for everyone’s wealth to increase? I think they might be assuming this is not possible and there if richest wealth increases by this much it had to come from the rest?

The notion that wealth is a fixed-size pie is central to the long-debunked economic error known as mercantilism.

Re: World's richest 500 see their wealth increase by $1T this year

#7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is it possible for everyone’s wealth to increase? I think they might be assuming this is not possible and there if richest wealth increases by this much it had to come from the rest?

Rich people tend to have most of their worth in stock. In theory, assuming your stock got more expensive, you get richer without anyone in particular getting poorer.

Inflation = everyone in cash got poorer

Re: World's richest 500 see their wealth increase by $1T this year

#8
post #2

This article provides paragraph after paragraph of supporting data that the richest have gotten richer, but none that I can see supporting its claim that “billions of poorer people across the world have seen their wealth standstill or decline”.

Is it possible for everyone’s wealth to increase? I think they might be assuming this is not possible and there if richest wealth increases by this much it had to come from the rest?

In real terms this could happen if productivity increased, and was able to lead to increased standard of living for everyone. This probably did happen for some large subset of the population, by some definition of "standard of living."

Re: World's richest 500 see their wealth increase by $1T this year

#9
post #2

This article provides paragraph after paragraph of supporting data that the richest have gotten richer, but none that I can see supporting its claim that “billions of poorer people across the world have seen their wealth standstill or decline”.

Is it possible for everyone’s wealth to increase? I think they might be assuming this is not possible and there if richest wealth increases by this much it had to come from the rest?

The central idea of capitalism is that voluntary exchange enriches both parties. So the answer to your first question is yes.

Re: World's richest 500 see their wealth increase by $1T this year

#10
post #2

This article provides paragraph after paragraph of supporting data that the richest have gotten richer, but none that I can see supporting its claim that “billions of poorer people across the world have seen their wealth standstill or decline”.

Is it possible for everyone’s wealth to increase? I think they might be assuming this is not possible and there if richest wealth increases by this much it had to come from the rest?

Yes it is possible for everyone's wealth to increase.

In the year 1900 Global GDP was 1 Trillion. Today it is 77 Trillion.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_world_product

In Layman's the Global Pie is growing. The number of people living in extreme poverty has fallen DRASTICALLY over the last 25 years. https://twitter.com/humanprogress/status/913901718823489538

So the people with the smallest piece of the pie are slowly getting a larger piece, but the people who already have the biggest piece of pie are getting even bigger pieces faster. But because the pie is growing, it doesn't mean that their larger piece is making someone else get a smaller piece.

The only people who have a proportionally smaller piece than they used to are in the middle class. Which is what happens when first world work more closely with developing nations. Taking more people out of extreme poverty but putting slight downward pressure on the middle class.

Post reply on HN