I ran some tests of my own with simulated automated trading strategies over the past few years of historical Bitcoin price data. I used a genetic algorithm to encode a range of time parameters for MACD, along with different trading triggers and amounts. After a day or two of running it against a huge number of permutations and generations optimized for highest overall return, I came to a similar conclusion: the fitte…
Depending on the automated strategy, they can dramatically reduce risk though. That has value well beyond the simple return of buy and hold, where if you don't time the sell perfectly, it's all useless. I think that's the big advantage automated trading strategies can have if designed well.
Yes - I found that to be true in my testing as well. The configurations optimized for highest absolute returns did very poorly in unfavorable market conditions (and max drawdown became significant), while there were some that performed moderately well and were much less affected by downturns in the market. Like most investments, it really comes down to the same thing: risk vs return.