Live data from Hacker News

Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

exstreamist.com

61–70 of 462 posts

Re: Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

#61
post #23

I was thinking about this the other day, and I was wondering whether the fact that my kids are not exposed at all to commercials might make them more susceptible to advertising when they grow up.

Alternatively, I can envision them being more skeptical about advertisements. It'd be great to see some long-term studies done on this.

Re: Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

#62
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think TV was actually less stupid in the past, but boy do I get sick of watching the same commercials fifty times watching a football game.

It might not have been, but the comparison makes it more evident.

I don't follow, but I think what's more likely at work here is nostalgia glasses.

Re: Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

#63
post #21
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ALL shows have product placement. Some more blatant than others. You can't get around that.

That is simply not true, firstly most cartoons and anime, but also other shows that come with a higher budget seem to be able to avoid product placements.

> That is simply not true, firstly most cartoons and anime...

https://anime.stackexchange.com/questions/4257/have-there-be...

Those are just the most obvious product placements, recognizable to folks who can't read all the little japanese labels on things that appear in the background.

There are also shows which are nothing but vehicles for products.

Re: Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

#64
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, but you never have to watch what you don’t want, including ads.

If you believe you are not watching ads when you watch Netflix, you need to look into the product placement in their shows. Drinks, watches, cars, clothes, all brands and even quite a few locations... it is all paid for, to entice you to buy.

Product placement and ads both serve the purpose of promoting something, but they're not really the same thing at all. I mean, both cars and bikes serve the purpose of transportation, but I don't think many people would argue that driving a car is basically riding a bike.

Re: Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

#65
post #36

If you have kids who watch netflix, it's interesting how they recoil in disgust at advertising interrupting a show. And it carries over to YouTube too - if they see pre-roll they skip as soon as possible. It'll be interesting when they're teens what kind of media related app will be the 'it' app for them

Interesting.

The one good thing with ads on the web is that it works as a micropayment.

I wonder how a service like Youtube would work without ads ?

I currently have a no-ads subscription on Youtube (packaged with a google music, so it is pretty attractive to me) but I don't think this service would work as a gated subscribe only website.

Re: Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

#66
post #33
post #5

I accidentally watched some TV the other day. Having not seen any regular programming for at least a year, I was amazed at how much ... dumber it has become. Also, why did we sit through so many commercials for so long? It feel a little like a twilight zone episode, where we sit there watching a box telling us what to buy.

>I was amazed at how much ... dumber it has become I had the same reaction this Thanksgiving when I was at my Dad's. I don't think it actually has become dumber, we're just not used to it anymore. I felt like I was watching commercials with a bit of content sprinkled in. I cut the cord about six years ago.

It's amazing how many channels do "in show" advertising as well.

It started with station logo water marks and now its amazing to see how much of the lower right hand corner of the screen is seen by networks as acceptable to use for advertising another show while the current show or sporting event is running.

Re: Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

#67
post #5

I accidentally watched some TV the other day. Having not seen any regular programming for at least a year, I was amazed at how much ... dumber it has become. Also, why did we sit through so many commercials for so long? It feel a little like a twilight zone episode, where we sit there watching a box telling us what to buy.

I think the “Frosty the Snowman” special on live TV ran almost 90 minutes... the commercials were agonizing. Also, kids are consuming a lot of highly effective YouTube ads.

What ads? I block everything for my family. While I do have cable for certain things, my wife and I DVR everything and FF through the ads. I find advertising distasteful and I don't suffer through it. I will likely go straight Internet in 2018.

I can get straight unlimited 1GB connection Internet for $99 month. I pay another $45 for the cable. It's difficult to get BBC and BBC America without cable or satellite, and I watch both all the time.

Re: Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

#68
post #5

I accidentally watched some TV the other day. Having not seen any regular programming for at least a year, I was amazed at how much ... dumber it has become. Also, why did we sit through so many commercials for so long? It feel a little like a twilight zone episode, where we sit there watching a box telling us what to buy.

I only started watching west wing least year.

I was shocked that network tv could produce something so smart, balanced, thoughtful, albeit 20 years ago.

Re: Kids in ‘Netflix Only’ Homes Saved from 230 Hours of Commercials a Year

#69
Every minute a kid watches a stupid Netflix kids show is a wasted minute they can be stimulating their brain positively instead of numbing it with manufactured industrialized content.

Having said that my kids do get a couple hours on the weekend and it's actually fascinating to see what happens when they put the iPad away. It's almost like they need a half hour or so to re-adjust to real life after all the stupid content they just watched.

Then they go outside and do what kids do best - be kids.

Post reply on HN