Live data from Hacker News

Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

news.ycombinator.com

41–49 of 49 posts

Re: Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

#41
post #6

Late tonight probably.

The emails are going out now. Thanks for your patience (and please check your spam folders).

The applications were really good this time. We invited more groups to interviews than we have in the past, but we still had to turn down a lot that are probably good.

Re: Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

#42
Shot down in flames a few minutes ago. At least they sent a well crafted email. I would love to see the specific negative feedback as to why they rejected us, but I understand that it would add to their workload.

Anyway, for me the best part of the YC process was the exercise of completing the application. It was much less daunting than sitting down to write a business plan. It forced me to codify my plans in broad terms, and that has been very helpful.

Now, back to the races.

Re: Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

#43
post #40

Don't forget to check your spam filters just in case! =P. I asked my friend who got accepted and he said that they sent it pretty late and that the email only goes to the leader on the app. Goodluck to everyone!

FWIW our rejection was sent to all founders emails.

Re: Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

#44
post #41
post #6

Late tonight probably.

The emails are going out now. Thanks for your patience (and please check your spam folders). The applications were really good this time. We invited more groups to interviews than we have in the past, but we still had to turn down a lot that are probably good.

How much do you look at the news.yc username correlation in your decision making?

Re: Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

#45
post #44
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The emails are going out now. Thanks for your patience (and please check your spam folders). The applications were really good this time. We invited more groups to interviews than we have in the past, but we still had to turn down a lot that are probably good.

How much do you look at the news.yc username correlation in your decision making?

It's hard to quantify, but it definitely helps when you feel like you know what someone's like from reading their comments.

A text application form is such a low-bandwidth source. Reading the applications, we feel like we're just starving for information about what the people are really like. So any additional context helps a lot.

Re: Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

#46
post #11

I like National Geographic: pangolins http://youtube.com/watch?v=r2cyp8k8uuM pygmy seahorse http://youtube.com/watch?v=k4q3sBuCkRQ critter cam, turtles: http://youtube.com/watch?v=Q_D51Ui_XMI These things calm me.

http://cuteoverload.com

Yeah, exactly. Cute overload. nature does it better.

Re: Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

#47
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, if you make it to the interview, your odds are excellent. In our batch roughly 50% of interviewees made it, and that number increased in subsequent batches. I've suspected that the application phase is where all of the downward pressure comes in--since they get so many, and the interview weekend only has so many slots available for talking to people. The quality of the applicants that make it to the interview ha…

But you still shouldn't bet on it. That was my point. It wouldn't matter if the odds later on were 90% or 10%, that's still several potentially wasted weeks. Just keep going.

I absolutely agree.

The teams most likely to get in are also the ones most likely to be working on their startup already. If you're not going to be working on your startup with or without YC, I suspect your odds of getting in are significantly lower (and probably moreso as time goes by, given the number of applicants and the number that are already started on their project--at least two that I talked to had applied and interviewed previously but not gotten in...they'd been either working on new ideas since then, or had gone on to launch something, and were back for another swing at YC with new or evolved ideas). I suspect at least one of those teams I talked to will get in this time. Stubbornness, self-confidence, risk-taking, and simple hard work are all things that YC appreciates...and they appreciate them because they're traits that lead to successful startups.

Re: Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

#48
post #45
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How much do you look at the news.yc username correlation in your decision making?

It's hard to quantify, but it definitely helps when you feel like you know what someone's like from reading their comments. A text application form is such a low-bandwidth source. Reading the applications, we feel like we're just starving for information about what the people are really like. So any additional context helps a lot.

Would it be possible to specifically mail those who were rejected?I do understand it would be time consuming for you guys, it would be really helpful to all

Re: Ask YC: When can we expect to know our YC application status?

#49
post #48
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's hard to quantify, but it definitely helps when you feel like you know what someone's like from reading their comments. A text application form is such a low-bandwidth source. Reading the applications, we feel like we're just starving for information about what the people are really like. So any additional context helps a lot.

Would it be possible to specifically mail those who were rejected?I do understand it would be time consuming for you guys, it would be really helpful to all

It would be less helpful than you might think. Strange as it sounds, there's often no answer to the question of why groups are rejected. I tried to explain it here: http://ycombinator.com/whynot.html
Post reply on HN