Live data from Hacker News

Pass-Thru Income Deduction

evergreensmallbusiness.com

31–40 of 94 posts

Re: Pass-Thru Income Deduction

#31
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I might be wrong but I think that tax rate is not 20%. I think the deduction is 20%. If I understand it correctly then what it means is that if you have earned $100k then you are taxed only on $80k and 20% (20K in this case) is your deduction. Can someone confirm/deny it.

Yes, it is a deduction of 20%.

Capped at 20% of your ordinary income.

Re: Pass-Thru Income Deduction

#32

I'm no expert, but from what I've seen, many people who are reading this should not get their hopes up. If you're a software developer operating either as a sole proprietorship or as an S corporation, I don't think you'll get the deduction. (If you have an LLC, that doesn't mean anything to the IRS; it's treated either as a "disregarded entity", i.e. a sole proprietorship, or as an S or C corp if you've taken that el…

I believe the new tax bill excludes architecture and engineering from that list. In other words, they would get the deduction.

Re: Pass-Thru Income Deduction

#34

One of the worst things about the current tax code (and soon-to-be new tax law) is the cost of compliance. You can argue about high tax or low tax and who should pay more than whom, but cost and time to comply does not create any value and is an artificial way that we make our country less competitive. This article is a clear example of that, laying out 10 different things you need to know with complicated formulas f…

Congress is full of lawyers who assume that everyone has access to lawyers. That's why everything is so complex. In reality the big guys have lawyers on retainer and can handle the laws and the little guy is at a disadvantage.

The same happens in a lot of companies. IT develops rules for IT people and the regular user is screwed.

Re: Pass-Thru Income Deduction

#35

This was a handy guide. I learned something. I was under the assumption the 20% deduction was only on the income you took as a distribution, NOT all of the income. I literally jumped for joy... then I read #5, and had a sad. I still come out better than I originally thought, but not as good as #4 led me to believe.

As I understand it, your original assumption was correct. The 20% only applies to distribution income, not to W-2 income. But the 20% deduction is limited to 50% of the W-2 income. So to maximize the deduction and minimize payroll taxes, the business owner will try to set his W-2 wages at 40% of the pass-through income, or two sevenths (~28.57%) of the business income before owner wages.

Re: Pass-Thru Income Deduction

#36

if you are happy that you can save some money this way, i think you are super lame. i am sad that over paid people like me and most of yall are now even less responsible for helping poor people (among other things, i know... )

like freeing up income to donate to charities that actually move people out of poverty?

Re: Pass-Thru Income Deduction

#37

if you are happy that you can save some money this way, i think you are super lame. i am sad that over paid people like me and most of yall are now even less responsible for helping poor people (among other things, i know... )

You can always donate the surplus to private entities.

Re: Pass-Thru Income Deduction

#38

Should everyone be thinking of becoming a pass through business? Person Inc. works for Big Business Inc. Everybody pays 20% tax and we are all happy.

A simple rule of thumb seems to be that if you work for the income don't bother becoming a pass thru. If other people or real estate work to generate the income, go for it!

If you are rich enough, go for it.

Re: Pass-Thru Income Deduction

#39

if you are happy that you can save some money this way, i think you are super lame. i am sad that over paid people like me and most of yall are now even less responsible for helping poor people (among other things, i know... )

like freeing up income to donate to charities that actually move people out of poverty?

is that the first thing on people's mind when they take home more money?

Re: Pass-Thru Income Deduction

#40

if you are happy that you can save some money this way, i think you are super lame. i am sad that over paid people like me and most of yall are now even less responsible for helping poor people (among other things, i know... )

like freeing up income to donate to charities that actually move people out of poverty?

im all for that, but i doubt that this provision in the tax bill is going to result in a net increase in charitable giving. and its compounded by the fact that r’s will use the huge deficit they just created as an argument for cutting services for poor people.
Post reply on HN