Live data from Hacker News

Pineapple Fund: Donating $86M of Bitcoins to Charity

pineapplefund.org

31–40 of 227 posts

Re: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86M of Bitcoins to Charity

#31
I think a clearer—or at least a less click-baity—title would be something like:

Pineapple Fund: Donating $86 million USD in/through BTC to charity.

I think the current one makes it sound like they are donating 86M BTC. I know that's above the theoretical maximum, but that's not the point.

Re: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86M of Bitcoins to Charity

#32

It's hard to sell large amounts of bitcoin. Most banks, when they see an incoming wire transfer for $10M marked "bitcoin" will run a mile and close down your account. Hopefully by 'donating' it to these charities, who will probably choose to sell slowly over time or hold it, that alleviates the problem.

[citation needed]

Can confirm first hand this is a serious issue in the industry. There are finally a couple crypto-friendly banks making it easier for holders and businesses. Source- have run a BTC co since 2014.

Re: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86M of Bitcoins to Charity

#33

I think a clearer—or at least a less click-baity—title would be something like: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86 million USD in/through BTC to charity. I think the current one makes it sound like they are donating 86M BTC. I know that's above the theoretical maximum, but that's not the point.

It clearly has $ in the HN post, and the actual site.

And you even know thats above the maximum so your concerns should have been disregarded as erroneous stimuli as the rest of our brains are already programmed to do.

Re: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86M of Bitcoins to Charity

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[citation needed]

Can confirm first hand this is a serious issue in the industry. There are finally a couple crypto-friendly banks making it easier for holders and businesses. Source- have run a BTC co since 2014.

your mistake was calling it a BTC co.

talking with bankers is an art. I have plenty of "software services" that primarily transact in bitcoin and cash out to bank accounts from bitcoin exchanges.

Re: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86M of Bitcoins to Charity

#36
post #17

I'm curious - is this making charitable donations in lieu of taxes on the gains?

you can donate appreciated assets to registered charities and this does allow you to avoid the capital tax AND also get a charitable tax deduction

Re: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86M of Bitcoins to Charity

#37
post #24

This looks sketchy as hell. No personal information attached at all and the domain has who-is protection. How do we know this is legit? (Edit: nvm, misinterpreted the website)

It does irrefutably link a very large amount of bitcoins with the site. https://live.blockcypher.com/btc/tx/c44ad5f83ddc84d08967c765...

He also links to a couple of completed donations. The first is a transfer of of 64.77BTC (approx $1M) to address 1AttfyuVVVpsJ6FzBcJMqkFrPRzFiQoRb6 which is definitely Watsi's BTC address:

https://twitter.com/watsi/status/938241988121583616

I'm having a bit of trouble connecting this transfer back to address 3P3QsMVK89JBNqZQv5zMAKG8FK3kJM4rjt which currently holds the coins that he says will be donated. If true this should be possible though...

EDIT: Oh wait, here is the connection:

https://blockchain.info/tx/d290acbfa7c619ad4215537ae83bfe165...

I have to say, I'm generally pretty skeptical of stuff like this but there is evidence here that this is legit.

EDIT2: They also encoded "pineapplefund.org" in a NULL transaction. Even more reason to believe.

https://live.blockcypher.com/btc/tx/c44ad5f83ddc84d08967c765...

Re: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86M of Bitcoins to Charity

#39
post #7

Speaking of charities, are most of them transparent and accountable with the funds they receive? I’d like to see a ledger of where every cent given to charity was used / spent.

Not that it's not a noble objective. But the accountability stuff costs money which could otherwise be spent on the core purpose.

Re: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86M of Bitcoins to Charity

#40

I think a clearer—or at least a less click-baity—title would be something like: Pineapple Fund: Donating $86 million USD in/through BTC to charity. I think the current one makes it sound like they are donating 86M BTC. I know that's above the theoretical maximum, but that's not the point.

It clearly has $ in the HN post, and the actual site. And you even know thats above the maximum so your concerns should have been disregarded as erroneous stimuli as the rest of our brains are already programmed to do.

He just wanted to show off that he knew the "theoretical maximum" amount of Bitcoins.
Post reply on HN