Live data from Hacker News

Calls for Twitch to police 'sexual streaming'

bbc.com

81–89 of 89 posts

Re: Calls for Twitch to police 'sexual streaming'

#81
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They try to emotionally manipulate their viewers into donating to them. Or they try to form a real bond. There’s some clear mix of genuine value for the lonely donators and id assume emotional abuse on the part of the streamers.

I had to laugh if showing some cleavage, saying thank you or talking to you is emotional manipulation or even abuse. Maybe there is really some truth to the lonely nerd. It's probably just people stuck in their teens or teenagers. It's exactly like the teenage girls loving some star they never met and thinking they'll get married and all. The more I read and think about it the more I'm asking myself how there can suc…

> It's exactly like the teenage girls loving some star they never met and thinking they'll get married and all.

The difference here being that this star acknowledges you existing as soon as you "donate" 5$, the more money you donate the more acknowledged you supposedly become, there is a direct feedback channel here that didn't exist like that before.

It also ties heavily into the whole "attention economy" concept and I'm also very certain it's not a healthy lifestyle for the Streamers themselves, reminds me very much about that whole situation of the commoditization of interpersonal relationships that's been happening in Japan with Hostess clubs [0].

You may think this is funny, that some people are willing to pay for casual social interactions, but only because you've been lucky enough to have a functional family/friend network to fulfill those particular needs for you. Yet, not everybody is lucky like that, quite many people feel very lonely most of the time (as they are pretty much alone) but that it's not a healthy way of living for humans so they are looking for ways to cope.

The real sad thing is that this is very likely one of the main motivations for streamers and donators alike; The feeling to belong, the be acknowledged.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8pW0RV2nSg0

Re: Calls for Twitch to police 'sexual streaming'

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Watching the world drift further and further towards moral prudery is so disheartening, especially when so much social progress was made on this front during the 60s and 70s. Society is so cyclical :/

I'm not sure where you got the ideal that moral prudery is involved here, but it has nothing to do with that. The people who want "twitch girls" off the site do not have any objections to cam girls. The problem is that they're hijacking a service that was built for and by a specific community. Twitch has a large number of sex workers who are just using it as a conduit to find "customers" and are not contributing to t…

Now as a payback we should start video game streaming on sexy cam websites !

Re: Calls for Twitch to police 'sexual streaming'

#84

If this is such a problem, then clearly there is a demand for it. Perhaps create a channel just for sexual streaming. The only question is, what to call it?

Well, they can't do that, because it would give the impression that they're tolerating it. Which they are, but they can't leave that impression.

Re: Calls for Twitch to police 'sexual streaming'

#87
post #84

If this is such a problem, then clearly there is a demand for it. Perhaps create a channel just for sexual streaming. The only question is, what to call it?

Well, they can't do that, because it would give the impression that they're tolerating it. Which they are, but they can't leave that impression.

Assuming the streamer proves they are at or above the legal age of consent for their location, why could this not be tolerated?

Re: Calls for Twitch to police 'sexual streaming'

#88
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, they can't do that, because it would give the impression that they're tolerating it. Which they are, but they can't leave that impression.

Assuming the streamer proves they are at or above the legal age of consent for their location, why could this not be tolerated?

I'm not saying that it shouldn't be tolerated. But other people don't want it to be tolerated, usually hardcore religious people.

With Twitch officially prohibiting it and streamers doing it anyways, those people will be angry at the streamers, not so much at Twitch.

Re: Calls for Twitch to police 'sexual streaming'

#89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Taking advantage of an emotionally vulnerable person, or as you put it "showing some cleavage, saying thank you or talking to you" is abusive. Just because you trivialize it (which you should feel ashamed for doing, very harmful attitude) doesn't mean its not abusive or wrong.

> "... or talking to you" is abusive Please tell me you're kidding.

Are you a Russian trollbot? I just read your comment history.

The agenda seems to be:

1) disrupt empathy/modern thought on mental issues

2) promote Russia

3) demean the US

You literally wrote you were in awe of Russia’s builders and that the US is at fault for North Korea. Wtf????

Post reply on HN