Live data from Hacker News

Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

bloomberg.com

21–30 of 84 posts

Re: Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

#21
post #15

Can we advance some kind of peace treaty? Google's philosophy is to "put users first and the rest will follow" [0] Amazon wants to be the world's most customer centric company. [1] - [0] https://www.safaribooksonline.com/library/view/the-google-wa... - [1] https://www.amazon.jobs/working/working-amazon

No, Google's philosophy is to put Google first, and that's exactly as it should be. Everything else is just marketing to make their users believe they matter.

Re: Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

#22

This is one reason why the Roku is such a great streaming platform, they're neutral. You can receive VUDU (Walmart), Prime Video (Amazon), and YouTube/Play Movies (Google). The only thing you cannot receive is Apple's ecosystem (but no non-Apple streaming hardware can as far as I know). Same reason why Spotify is so prevalent, they too are neutral in this war between titans. I have no sympathy for Google or Amazon in…

Exactly right. I bought a roku last week for this reason. I support vendors that believe in openness and inclusion.

Re: Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

#24

This is one reason why the Roku is such a great streaming platform, they're neutral. You can receive VUDU (Walmart), Prime Video (Amazon), and YouTube/Play Movies (Google). The only thing you cannot receive is Apple's ecosystem (but no non-Apple streaming hardware can as far as I know). Same reason why Spotify is so prevalent, they too are neutral in this war between titans. I have no sympathy for Google or Amazon in…

I may be wrong but Google can block itself from being shown on Roku right? It seems weird to call Roku neutral when it's not them but Google calling the shots.

Re: Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

#25

This is one reason why the Roku is such a great streaming platform, they're neutral. You can receive VUDU (Walmart), Prime Video (Amazon), and YouTube/Play Movies (Google). The only thing you cannot receive is Apple's ecosystem (but no non-Apple streaming hardware can as far as I know). Same reason why Spotify is so prevalent, they too are neutral in this war between titans. I have no sympathy for Google or Amazon in…

Amazon just pulled Twitch from Roku

Re: Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

#26
post #15

Can we advance some kind of peace treaty? Google's philosophy is to "put users first and the rest will follow" [0] Amazon wants to be the world's most customer centric company. [1] - [0] https://www.safaribooksonline.com/library/view/the-google-wa... - [1] https://www.amazon.jobs/working/working-amazon

Well, seemed like you worked for both of them, maybe you should write a couple letters.

Re: Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

#27
post #7

they were never good at each other. To have the best of two worlds is to have one Chromecast and one Fire TV. At least I don't need an Apple TV nowadays because Chromecast is good enough for local streaming and some occasional mirroring from Mac (although not the same quality as Apple TV).

Or just use a device and content delivery platform that isn't developed by a content producer... like Roku, Kodi, etc.

What's to say Google doesn't pull YouTube API access from Roku or Kodi next? This salvo at Amazon isn't their first, and may not be their last.

Re: Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

#28

This is one reason why the Roku is such a great streaming platform, they're neutral. You can receive VUDU (Walmart), Prime Video (Amazon), and YouTube/Play Movies (Google). The only thing you cannot receive is Apple's ecosystem (but no non-Apple streaming hardware can as far as I know). Same reason why Spotify is so prevalent, they too are neutral in this war between titans. I have no sympathy for Google or Amazon in…

fun fact Roku was spun out of netflix just so they could remain neutral https://www.fastcompany.com/3004709/inside-netflixs-project-...

Re: Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

#29

Curious, is this a violation of net neutrality? This seems even worse for the consumer than simply having to pay more. At least then you still can get access. Do we clamor for the government to come regulate it? Be careful when considering this so as not to be inconsistent with your reasoning behind NN for ISPs.

No. This is not developing an app for a certain device.

Re: Google Blocks YouTube Access from Amazon's Streaming Devices

#30
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed this absolutely sucks. Amazon fired the first shots tho. This is their fault and they should put Google products back up on their store.

What did Amazon do?

Amazon removed the Chromecasts from the Amazon store.

Because Google refused to allow Amazon to cast to Chromecasts.

There was once a time when the Amazon Video and Netflix apps on Amazon Kindle Fire could stream to Chromecast, Google then changed their protocol to prevent that (you now need to use their proprietary library for it).

Amazon reacted by removing the Chromecast from their store.

Post reply on HN