Live data from Hacker News

AMA: NY AG Schneiderman on net neutrality and protecting our voice in government

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 281 posts

Re: AMA: NY AG Schneiderman on net neutrality and protecting our voice in government

#31
Hi Mr. Schneiderman,

NY resident here. Thank you very much for your work. I'm proud to have you as our State AG.

In your view, do the fake comments delegitimize FCC's rule-making process, if the FCC does not delay the vote until after the investigation is over? And can the FCC's Net Neutrality decision (regardless of whether or not they vote to repeal NN) be challenged in the court, on the grounds that the integrity of its rule-making process has been seriously compromised?

Thanks!

Re: AMA: NY AG Schneiderman on net neutrality and protecting our voice in government

#32
post #25
post #10

Would you mind commenting on these findings? They seem to have found that both sides have been stuffing the ballot box: http://www.emprata.com/reports/fcc-restoring-internet-freedo... Also, can you work on net neutrality for all bits? That is Google, Facebook, Twitter, as the main gateways to public discourse treat all comments equally without promoting one viewpoint over another that does not enjoy elite sanction? W…

both paragraphs are whataboutism. The first talks about comment content which the AG did not reference. The second talks about an entirely irrelevant issue and tries to shift the definition of a term to something broader that clouds discussion.

I would disagree. The first says that there is a concern both sides engaged in ballot stuffing while AG seems concerned by a single sides PoV.

The other more importantly is concerned with guaranteeing a triumvirate of gatekeepers doesn't guide discourse in one direction or the other.

Re: AMA: NY AG Schneiderman on net neutrality and protecting our voice in government

#33
Can you briefly expand on what congress is capable of doing to delay or stop this?

I would like to be able to convey specific actions I want to see from my representatives, but I currently only feel comfortable asking "please do something!"

Are we to demand that they require the FCC delay the vote until your investigation has concluded? Do they have that authority?

I was under the impression that the telecom lobby was using the FCC as an end run around congress. What does a delay gain for us if those involved in the vote are beholden to lobbies, not citizens?

Thank you for taking the time to come here today, and for your involvement.

Re: AMA: NY AG Schneiderman on net neutrality and protecting our voice in government

#35
It seems that the internet is being flooded with accounts that use real people's stolen identities and this is yet another example.

Which, if any, laws did the creators of these accounts break by posting these comments to the FCC under other people's identities?

Re: AMA: NY AG Schneiderman on net neutrality and protecting our voice in government

#36
post #14

How do these comments harm real people? Definitely seems shady but I don't really see how using fake names actually hurt anyone.

> How do these comments harm real people?

When they are used to justify policies that harm real people. That question is so silly I first thought it was rhetorical.

Re: AMA: NY AG Schneiderman on net neutrality and protecting our voice in government

#37
post #26

Do you personally believe that this was enabled either passively or actively by the FCC to cloud the public discourse surrounding the net neutrality vote?

As a follow up, if it was intentionally done, can/will there be any legal consequences?

Re: AMA: NY AG Schneiderman on net neutrality and protecting our voice in government

#38

What actions can state and local governments take to support net neutrality? Is New York going to consider revoking cable franchise agreements for companies that do not support net neutrality, or require it (maybe nationwide?) for bidders on franchise agreements?

This might be related so I wanted to tack on a question: Does the FCC, especially Pai consider one of the only options for providers of broadband in the North East considered a competitive market?

Re: AMA: NY AG Schneiderman on net neutrality and protecting our voice in government

#40
post #14

How do these comments harm real people? Definitely seems shady but I don't really see how using fake names actually hurt anyone.

> How do these comments harm real people? When they are used to justify policies that harm real people. That question is so silly I first thought it was rhetorical.

Do you really think regulatory decisions are made based on which side gets more public comments? And that that is so obvious anyone who disagrees is silly?
Post reply on HN