Live data from Hacker News

Why We Blame Millennials for Everything

citylab.com

51–60 of 95 posts

Re: Why We Blame Millennials for Everything

#51

That was a pretty decent article until the part with video games.

Came here to post this. Gamergate is more than three years old now and yet people still try to dredge it up and smear it as a "misogynist hate campaign" when even a cursory amount of research proves otherwise (not if you only look at headlines of course).

Once again a writer decides to try and project their personal opinions on to a subject they're* interviewing.

Re: Why We Blame Millennials for Everything

#52
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it's rational to blame them for a huge range of issues No, it's not. It's making broad generalizations on a huge group of people. It's like blaming all white people for discrimination or all black people for crime. It's wrong and discriminatory, and makes the assumption that everyone in that group is equally bad. Instead of focusing on a certain age group, focus on the economic forces that gave boomers more opportu…

Economics are not separated from politics. The poor diet of most Americans is a direct result of various subsidies given to the farming lobby. Individual choices allow an individual to be fat, but at a national level it takes vast tracts of land. The growth of Chinese manufacturing is in large part a result of trade policies and our vast growing national debt's impact on currency's. Want long term growth? End deficit…

Do you consider the growth of Chinese manufacturing to be a bad thing? IMO China's economic growth has also helped US economic growth.

Re: Why We Blame Millennials for Everything

#53
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Considering Boomers have actual power right now and plenty of time for their influence to spread; it's rational to blame them for a huge range of issues.

> it's rational to blame them for a huge range of issues No, it's not. It's making broad generalizations on a huge group of people. It's like blaming all white people for discrimination or all black people for crime. It's wrong and discriminatory, and makes the assumption that everyone in that group is equally bad. Instead of focusing on a certain age group, focus on the economic forces that gave boomers more opportu…

You're not up to date on the current rhetoric, it's been decided that all white people are in fact to blame. That's probably why you're getting downvoted to hell.

Re: Why We Blame Millennials for Everything

#55

There is little I dislike more than generational labels. It's lazy and reductionist thinking that allows people to arbitrarily draw lines in whatever way they feel will best push their narrative. Quick, 1981/1982[1] Millennial or X? [1] Those born in 1981/1982 graduated in 2000

Well, to take the bait, considering that according to Wikipedia the range starts from early 1980s with some even considering the beginning at late 1970s, i'd say 1981/1982 is firmly Millenial material.

Although that is probably closer to the Oregon Trail Generation :-)

https://socialmediaweek.org/blog/2015/04/oregon-trail-genera...

Re: Why We Blame Millennials for Everything

#56

There is little I dislike more than generational labels. It's lazy and reductionist thinking that allows people to arbitrarily draw lines in whatever way they feel will best push their narrative. Quick, 1981/1982[1] Millennial or X? [1] Those born in 1981/1982 graduated in 2000

The inconvenience of this argument will do worse than earn you downvotes if you're not careful. It might earn you no votes at all, because there's things far more inflammatory and black and white to take sides on, and that's what's fashionable in the human world

Re: Why We Blame Millennials for Everything

#58

It's simple divide and conquer. The 0.1% know you need somebody to blame for them squeezing you, so they tell boomers' it's millennials' fault and vice versa. It works pretty well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15844087 If that doesn't work, they can always blame immigrants, Islam or blacks.

It could be a conspiracy. Or it could be too many column inches to fill and not enough time to fill them with something insightful. Yeah, probably conspiracy.

Perhaps the greatest unexpected result of the internet is how we dont need papers. Choice in what i read is mine.

Re: Why We Blame Millennials for Everything

#59
post #30
post #10

The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their households. They no longer rise when elders enter the room. They contradict their parents, chatter before company, gobble up dainties at the table, cross their legs, and tyrannize their teachers.

You don’t even need to go back to Ancient Greece. Lazy journalists were kicking this old can, but about Generation X, during the ‘90s.

The point about the quote going back to the ancient Greeks is to show it is an eternal argument.

Except the quote does not originate from the ancient Greeks that is.

Re: Why We Blame Millennials for Everything

#60
Don't you just love the snake millennial chrome extention? "It seems a reader can barely go a week without seeing at least one news headline about how Snake People are “killing” some industry or product. Serpent Society is purportedly wiping out casual dining, golf, diamonds, homeownership, and bars of soap, among other consumer products; news items have also characterized the generation as lazy, vain, and always looking for a handout."
Post reply on HN