Live data from Hacker News

Holy mackerel: Civilisation begins with fishing

spectator.co.uk

1–9 of 9 posts

Re: Holy mackerel: Civilisation begins with fishing

#2
Fascinating. I feel like every year or so a new book is written along the topic of something like this though: Fish, Salt, Grain, Money, Paper, etc and how that thing was responsible for modern civilization. I commend the author for bringing this idea to the forefront but its likely disingenuous to think that Fish and Fishing has as the author says, "created the modern world" more so than any of these other things.

Re: Holy mackerel: Civilisation begins with fishing

#3

Fascinating. I feel like every year or so a new book is written along the topic of something like this though: Fish, Salt, Grain, Money, Paper, etc and how that thing was responsible for modern civilization. I commend the author for bringing this idea to the forefront but its likely disingenuous to think that Fish and Fishing has as the author says, "created the modern world" more so than any of these other things.

Still makes for a fascinating read... Plus eventually we'd be able to run ml on the articles to reach a concensus maybe xD

Re: Holy mackerel: Civilisation begins with fishing

#5
post #3

Fascinating. I feel like every year or so a new book is written along the topic of something like this though: Fish, Salt, Grain, Money, Paper, etc and how that thing was responsible for modern civilization. I commend the author for bringing this idea to the forefront but its likely disingenuous to think that Fish and Fishing has as the author says, "created the modern world" more so than any of these other things.

Still makes for a fascinating read... Plus eventually we'd be able to run ml on the articles to reach a concensus maybe xD

I'd speculate that all modern humans were capable of forming civilizations, and like a supercooled fluid would crystalize into one around any workable nucleation site.

Re: Holy mackerel: Civilisation begins with fishing

#6

I always had a pet theory that Omega-3 kick-started the development of the human brain. Not sure if the science agrees completely but it does suggest a correlation.

Aquatic ape hypothesis [^1] is quite convincing.

I have learned about it at freediving course as it explains our natural capabilities of apnea.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aquatic_ape_hypothesis

Re: Holy mackerel: Civilisation begins with fishing

#8
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Still makes for a fascinating read... Plus eventually we'd be able to run ml on the articles to reach a concensus maybe xD

I'd speculate that all modern humans were capable of forming civilizations, and like a supercooled fluid would crystalize into one around any workable nucleation site.

If they wanted to. Agriculture has been one of the worst changes for average quality of life.