My father is a senior, tenured professor of mechanical engineering. He's won a bunch of prizes and fellowships. He's probably one of the best in his field. I don't ever recall anything about substantial raises. In fact, all I ever hear out of him is that they're cutting staff, restricting bonuses and cutting raises. This coming from a man who works on research and the related papers/books almost every waking hour of…
Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
101–110 of 121 posts
Re: Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
#102"A glance at scholarly journals or university-press catalogs might make one wonder how much of this "research" is advancing knowledge and how much is part of a guild's need to credentialize its members." A glance? Really? Judging the life's work of a few thousand people who got into academia to do research is easily judged in a 'glance'? It's interesting that some would like universities to be little more than vocati…
It's a fair point, but he's probably focusing on the arts and soft sciences because those degrees are the most overpriced for the value they deliver. To put it another way, an MIT grad with an engineering degree is going to be much better off career-wise than a Harvard grad who majored in gender studies.
the most overpriced for the value they deliver.
For some values of 'value'. Because you can't put a dollar sign on everything, right? I feel much better about the value I got from my humanities classes than I ever did about my computer science classes, whether or not that translates directly into money-earned.Re: Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
#103Earlier quoted context omitted.
See another article currently on the front page: Realtime Linux: academia v. reality http://lwn.net/SubscriberLink/397422/27eef125e03b8a2d/ "I actually took the time to spend a day at a university where I could gain access to IEEE papers without wasting my private money. I picked out twenty recent realtime related papers and did a quick survey. Twelve of the papers were a rehash of well-known and well-researched topi…
That's funny. If you took a look at startups, you'd find that 99% of them are me-too crap. Badly designed websites for Yet Another Social Networking Gimmick, bad mobile apps, outlandish bad business ideas, etc. 1% of them ever truly go anywhere. 0.1% of them change the world. My point is that anytime you randomly sample a field of work of any kind, you're going to get an exponential distribution of quality with a few…
Funnily enough, one such attempt (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Accomplishment) finds that per capita scientific achievement seems to start declining around the 1920s or 1930s, which is also (with WWII and whatnot) the beginning of the modern university system.
Re: Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
#104Earlier quoted context omitted.
It's a very good question, and hardly a trivial one. Quite a lot of science is nearly worthless, and only published to pad the author's cv. A couple of blog posts on the topic: http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2010/06/24/all_those_wo... http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2010/06/25/what_to_do_w...
Lasers were thought to be a laboratory curiosity when they were invented. On the other hand, you have a ton of academics who are convinced that the "semantic web" is the next big thing. Part of the problem with science is that it's an activity where it's very hard to have any useful metric. Even experts in the field have a tough time deciding whether a given research direction is going to be fruitful. They're often w…
Why do we need this? By every metric I know of, governments spend orders of magnitude more on science than they did in the 1800s. Are we getting orders more "Profit!"?
Re: Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
#105This article is rubbish.
(Did you see what I did there? I responded to a worthless comment with an equally worthless one.)
Re: Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
#106I don' think that this is news to anyone that works in higher ed. I work at a University and its repeated all throughout the campus. Basically administrators want to set up their own little empires on the campus and make themselves seem indispensable. I'm pretty sure things like this happen at most large organizations in some form.
When it gets out of control it's a sure sign of a management problem.
Re: Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
#107But when people are able to shift the costs to others or borrow money from those who lend to anybody, many aren't careful at all. And the market responds to take advantage of this.
Re: Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
#108Earlier quoted context omitted.
Lasers were thought to be a laboratory curiosity when they were invented. On the other hand, you have a ton of academics who are convinced that the "semantic web" is the next big thing. Part of the problem with science is that it's an activity where it's very hard to have any useful metric. Even experts in the field have a tough time deciding whether a given research direction is going to be fruitful. They're often w…
1) Fund lots of science. Why do we need this? By every metric I know of, governments spend orders of magnitude more on science than they did in the 1800s. Are we getting orders more "Profit!"?
Re: Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
#109Earlier quoted context omitted.
Lasers were thought to be a laboratory curiosity when they were invented. On the other hand, you have a ton of academics who are convinced that the "semantic web" is the next big thing. Part of the problem with science is that it's an activity where it's very hard to have any useful metric. Even experts in the field have a tough time deciding whether a given research direction is going to be fruitful. They're often w…
1) Fund lots of science. Why do we need this? By every metric I know of, governments spend orders of magnitude more on science than they did in the 1800s. Are we getting orders more "Profit!"?
Re: Colleges Serve the People Who Work There, Not the Students
#110Isn't the old joke that colleges are the only place where the employees get all of the good parking and the paying customers get the shitty, far away parking.
Man, if only that was the truth here at KU. Everyone has shit parking here unless you carry a massive title or tenure. maybe 100 cars total don't have to hike up a hill.