Live data from Hacker News

Amazon to Adapt J.R.R. Tolkien’s Globally Renowned Fantasy Novels

businesswire.com

61–63 of 63 posts

Re: Amazon to Adapt J.R.R. Tolkien’s Globally Renowned Fantasy Novels

#61
post #4

In case anyone was curious: > television adaptation will explore new storylines preceding J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Fellowship of the Ring So it's not going to tell the main story itself, which is probably wise given the film adaptations aren't even that old. Maybe it's just me I'm not super-excited by this news. I wish there were more original universes being created with the insane amount of TV money swirling around the…

The worst part is that you probably couldn’t pick a worse franchise to adapt into a Game of Thrones-style show. LotR is all about a Manichean struggle between good and evil, and about dreaming and wanderlust and journies. GoT is about cold, brutal, gritty realpolitik and the realities of power, war, and violence. Shoving GoT themes into a world that was basically built for precisely opposite ideas is lazy and will probably produce jarring, unnatural stories.

Re: Amazon to Adapt J.R.R. Tolkien’s Globally Renowned Fantasy Novels

#62
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hm, I disagree. Usually when you read a book/watch a movie, you do have a pretty good idea who will survive. I mean, even in the original trilogy, most people knew how things would go down since the books were well known. I would say more interesting is how it goes down, and you can still have tension even if you know the final outcome. Same thing with folk tales: you know the hero is going to win, but it is still en…

I guess you have a point. But let me try another counter: how much more enjoyable were the big scenes in Game of Thrones? I think you know the ones I am talking about. I still enjoy rewatching Breaking Bad but the shock and recognition of watching these shows the first time is superior.

Yup, you're right. It does add something for sure. I guess the further away a show/movie strays from common tropes the more important is the value of not knowing what will happen.

Re: Amazon to Adapt J.R.R. Tolkien’s Globally Renowned Fantasy Novels

#63
post #5

There are so many amazing fantasy novels that need movies or TV shows. Tolkien was good, and for his time, amazing. But compared to what we have available today, I wouldn't even put him in the top 10. sigh

Now I'm curious: Who would be in your top ten? For my money, it would include Orson Scott Card, William Gibson, Neal Stephenson, and Isaac Asimov.

My #1 for a movie/tv show would be The Blade Itself series by Joe Abercrombie. The thought of seeing Glokta and Ninefingers portrayed on screen gives me chills.
Post reply on HN