Live data from Hacker News

What Happened to Threadless?

racked.com

61–70 of 112 posts

Re: What Happened to Threadless?

#61
post #48

Threadless announced Artist Shops in 2015 and rolled them out to Threadless’s general community in early 2016. Artist Shops, still in existence, allow designers to sell items printed with any design (allowed by Threadless’s terms and conditions) directly to customers and receive royalties on each sale.... The shift to a more equitable royalties and rights model removed the gamification elements of Threadless that mad…

Why is it so surprising? From both the designer and shopper perspectives, the Old Way does seem better. With the Old Way: Designer: does N work to create a design and has X% chance of winning $2500. They focus on what they love (i.e. design) and can get a nice quick payout if they're good. This is even better than a lottery, because it has the same excitement, but talent is also a factor which is very motivating. The…

[deleted]

Re: What Happened to Threadless?

#62
post #2

The article fails to mention that there is a ton of competition and Threadless has been trounced by Redbubble, Society6, Teepublic, etc. Plus, t-shirts alone is not enough to sustain a site. Stickers, iPhone cases, mugs, etc etc. Threadless is a good example of the dangers of premature profitability.

[deleted]

Re: What Happened to Threadless?

#64

> Threadless fans report that the shirts now appear in UK T.J. Maxx stores Over here they're known as TK Maxx.

I think the TK Maxx name is not only in the UK but all over Europe (maybe there are exceptions)

According to wiki:

"TK Maxx (Australia, Austria, United Kingdom, Germany, Ireland, Netherlands, Poland)"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TJX_Companies#Store_formats

Re: What Happened to Threadless?

#65

Something else not mentioned in the article is that graphic tees have fallen in popularity in the past decade vs plain t-shirts. I'm just one data point but having purchased from Threadless a few times, I haven't bought one graphic tee in the past five years or more. The novelty of a graphic tee wears off quickly. I'd rather have a more expensive but high quality plain shirt I'll like for years to come.

Have they fallen in popularity or have you aged out of the target market?

Same "single data point" disclaimer, but most of my peers lost interest in them mid-college when they began dressing more mature. The high schoolers I know still wear graphic tees but for whatever reason Threadless never connected with the next generation.

Re: What Happened to Threadless?

#66
post #48

Threadless announced Artist Shops in 2015 and rolled them out to Threadless’s general community in early 2016. Artist Shops, still in existence, allow designers to sell items printed with any design (allowed by Threadless’s terms and conditions) directly to customers and receive royalties on each sale.... The shift to a more equitable royalties and rights model removed the gamification elements of Threadless that mad…

Why is it so surprising? From both the designer and shopper perspectives, the Old Way does seem better. With the Old Way: Designer: does N work to create a design and has X% chance of winning $2500. They focus on what they love (i.e. design) and can get a nice quick payout if they're good. This is even better than a lottery, because it has the same excitement, but talent is also a factor which is very motivating. The…

Well, recreate the old Threadless idea for your own startup and make the millions!

Re: What Happened to Threadless?

#67
post #48

Threadless announced Artist Shops in 2015 and rolled them out to Threadless’s general community in early 2016. Artist Shops, still in existence, allow designers to sell items printed with any design (allowed by Threadless’s terms and conditions) directly to customers and receive royalties on each sale.... The shift to a more equitable royalties and rights model removed the gamification elements of Threadless that mad…

isn't that the way the "American dream" works?

Re: What Happened to Threadless?

#68

Something else not mentioned in the article is that graphic tees have fallen in popularity in the past decade vs plain t-shirts. I'm just one data point but having purchased from Threadless a few times, I haven't bought one graphic tee in the past five years or more. The novelty of a graphic tee wears off quickly. I'd rather have a more expensive but high quality plain shirt I'll like for years to come.

This is a great point. Clothing styles go in and out of fashion on a cyclical basis that is multiple years long.

Re: What Happened to Threadless?

#69
post #4

> Concerns about controlling quality make sense given that artists on Threadless’s forum complain that they’re unable to promote their work because the print quality has dropped to the point that designs flake off after a few washes. Reviewers say the sizing, feel, and weight of Threadless’s shirts is inconsistent and getting worse over time, with some customers reporting that shirts bought five to 10 years ago are s…

Same here. I have a couple of ancient (roughly ten years old) Threadless shirts that still look good, and I have a couple of recent ones (within the last two years) that never fit the same and have not held up.

Since many (most?) designs that are on Threadless are also on Society6, and since Society6 shirts are still relatively high quality, I order from them now instead.

Re: What Happened to Threadless?

#70

Something else not mentioned in the article is that graphic tees have fallen in popularity in the past decade vs plain t-shirts. I'm just one data point but having purchased from Threadless a few times, I haven't bought one graphic tee in the past five years or more. The novelty of a graphic tee wears off quickly. I'd rather have a more expensive but high quality plain shirt I'll like for years to come.

Have they fallen in popularity or have you aged out of the target market? Same "single data point" disclaimer, but most of my peers lost interest in them mid-college when they began dressing more mature. The high schoolers I know still wear graphic tees but for whatever reason Threadless never connected with the next generation.

"for whatever reason Threadless never connected with the next generation"

This is super insightful, and shouldn't be missed here. For them to stay successful for 17 years amongst a 5-10 year age group, they would need to completely refresh their customer base 2-3 times. That type of cultural relevancy is extremely hard, as anyone watching FB/Instagram vs Twitter vs Snap can attest.

Post reply on HN