Live data from Hacker News

Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

theverge.com

41–50 of 85 posts

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#41

$94.6 billion net worth at present per Bloomberg. I know he is basically guaranteed to be running all of these sales off a sale schedule set far in advance for obvious reasons. However, I'd probably be doubling up those $1 billion sales until/unless this market gives out. Raising $6 or $10 billion - enough to fund Blue Origin for maybe a decade - by selling out of a $94 billion base, sure beats doing the same out of…

All of this is entirely dependent on whimsy. Amazon P/E is basically in the clouds. They and Telsa in some ways are basically impossible to value. So, people make difficult guesses. Though I agree that because AMZN could probably simply 'turn on profit' at any time, and so the classical P/E is not a great measure ... at the same time ... a small dip in something could ruin them. It only takes just a little bit of ret…

> though I agree that because AMZN could probably simply 'turn on profit' at any time

I'm confused—Amazon is profitable already, no?

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#42

$94.6 billion net worth at present per Bloomberg. I know he is basically guaranteed to be running all of these sales off a sale schedule set far in advance for obvious reasons. However, I'd probably be doubling up those $1 billion sales until/unless this market gives out. Raising $6 or $10 billion - enough to fund Blue Origin for maybe a decade - by selling out of a $94 billion base, sure beats doing the same out of…

I can't help but wonder what it's like to have that kind of money.

Does such a person ever wake up, and wonder how the dice rolled so amazingly in their favor?

Or do they wake up and stand proud, recognizing that they are so successful because of their own hard work and intelligence?

Do they ever think about how insane life is that they ended up with 94 billion, while some people are starving?

I'm not making any moral projection here. I'm not saying there's anything right, or wrong, about that situation. I'm just genuinely curious what it feels like to be in their shoes.

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#43
post #30
post #26

My initial question was how did he sell $1B and not affect the share price substantially. And sure enough, the share price did drop a bit. But average trading volume is about 2 billion shares, which is about $2B. It's pretty crazy that the market has so much liquidity that $2B of AMZN changes hands every day, and that it could soak up a $1B sale and barely change the price.

Minor correction: Google finance shows average volume at 3.7M shares, which at $1,100 per share is about $4B daily. Selling a billion dollars is still a significant chunk, so your point stands.

Over 3 days of selling (according to the article), that's only an average of about 8% of daily volume.

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#44
post #22
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Provided the security/asset is held for a year or more, it is taxed as Long-Term Capital Gains, and given quite the tax break. It is even possible to pay 0% federal rate on sale of stock, I did it on my 2016 return.

> It is even possible to pay 0% federal rate on sale of stock, I did it on my 2016 return. Up to the top of the 15% bracket, yes, or $37,950 in total income for single earners in 2017 ($75,900 joint). It's easy to pay little in long-term cap. gains taxes if you are retired (or unemployed) with a cheap-to-moderate lifestyle. But not possible for ~$1 billion in gains, like Bezos' sale :-).

>> But not possible for ~$1 billion in gains

Quite possible given enough trust lawyers and accountants. Mitt Romney managed to own a lot of his stock in his Roth IRA. The PayPal gang is famous for paying almost zero taxes though the same tricks. Yes, you dont get to spend it until retirement, but he isnt spending the billion, he is just reinvesting it.

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#45
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The taxes (what, 20% capital gains?) seems an excellent deal for the ecosystem where he grew his company: a stable political system, strong asset protection enforced by strict laws, an educated workforce in a relatively unpolluted environment, etc.

Pretty sure offering those things to Bezos didn't cost the gov't $200M. And at any rate, most of the money will probably go for an airport that will never be used in some influential senator's state.

The highways that carry his shipments cost a lot.

The Commerce Clause that protects his sales from state sales tax and made his mail-older company competitive against local stores made him a bundle too.

Most Federal tax revenue is spent on military (low gas prices for Amazon deliveries) and entitlements, not infrastructure projects.

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#46
post #26

My initial question was how did he sell $1B and not affect the share price substantially. And sure enough, the share price did drop a bit. But average trading volume is about 2 billion shares, which is about $2B. It's pretty crazy that the market has so much liquidity that $2B of AMZN changes hands every day, and that it could soak up a $1B sale and barely change the price.

To prevent any accusations of insider trading, these sales tend to be announced months in advance and scheduled, so any movements on the sale day are more likely to be naieve investors reacting.

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The taxes (what, 20% capital gains?) seems an excellent deal for the ecosystem where he grew his company: a stable political system, strong asset protection enforced by strict laws, an educated workforce in a relatively unpolluted environment, etc.

I would much rather that Bezos be allowed to keep all of his capital gains but have appropriate antitrust enforcement step in and reduce Amazon's market power a bit. The recent upsurge of counterfeit products are evidence that Amazon is abusing its market power to the point of harming consumers.

Seriously, all the bait and switches happening on Amazon is crazy. So many people getting screwed because a product built up good reviews then switches out for a counterfeit.

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#48
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would much rather that Bezos be allowed to keep all of his capital gains but have appropriate antitrust enforcement step in and reduce Amazon's market power a bit. The recent upsurge of counterfeit products are evidence that Amazon is abusing its market power to the point of harming consumers.

What market does Amazon have a monopoly, and how are they abusing it or what prohibited practices did they use to establish such a monopoly? It looks like they may have 44% of internet retail by public companies; and that's big, but it doesn't include private companies, and it doesn't fit my definition of a monopoly. It is certainly large enough that they should be scrutinized and attempts to increase share through p…

I don't think Amazon has fully crossed any lines just yet, but I do think it's bound to happen fairly soon just due to scale.

My point is meant to compare antitrust enforcement to the other mechanisms that are viewed by some as necessary to prevent large corporations from causing negative externalities.

Arguably if proper antitrust enforcement had been done in the finance industry, then no firms would have become too big to fail and all of the perverse incentives underscored by regulators post 2008 could have been avoided.

The problem is that since our regulatory state rewards size, there is a strong incentive to become large and hence too big to fail. As Amazon becomes a bigger and bigger part of the economy, it could start using the same rent-seeking tactics that financial firms used in 2008 to get major corporate welfare.

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#49
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It is even possible to pay 0% federal rate on sale of stock, I did it on my 2016 return. Up to the top of the 15% bracket, yes, or $37,950 in total income for single earners in 2017 ($75,900 joint). It's easy to pay little in long-term cap. gains taxes if you are retired (or unemployed) with a cheap-to-moderate lifestyle. But not possible for ~$1 billion in gains, like Bezos' sale :-).

>> But not possible for ~$1 billion in gains Quite possible given enough trust lawyers and accountants. Mitt Romney managed to own a lot of his stock in his Roth IRA. The PayPal gang is famous for paying almost zero taxes though the same tricks. Yes, you dont get to spend it until retirement, but he isnt spending the billion, he is just reinvesting it.

No, the Romney move is still not possible in Bezos' shoes. Bezos couldn't have invested in Amazon in his IRA when it was worth nothing:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-directed_IRA#Permitted_in...

> IRA funds are allowed to be invested in private companies. ... The IRS puts restrictions on private equity investments that can be made by an IRA. It cannot purchase stock that the IRA holder already owns. ... In most cases, neither the IRA holder nor any disqualified persons to the plan can be employed by the company while the IRA has an equity position in that company.

Re: Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would much rather that Bezos be allowed to keep all of his capital gains but have appropriate antitrust enforcement step in and reduce Amazon's market power a bit. The recent upsurge of counterfeit products are evidence that Amazon is abusing its market power to the point of harming consumers.

Seriously, all the bait and switches happening on Amazon is crazy. So many people getting screwed because a product built up good reviews then switches out for a counterfeit.

Indeed. I've been burned enough times that I'd actually join a class action lawsuit at this point. It's pretty ridiculous.

Amazon needs to take full responsibility for counterfeiting. I'm tempted to charge back certain purchases instead of going through the normal highly annoying process.

Being able to return an item no questions asked is not an appropriate remedy for getting a counterfeit product. It's a major hassle to box something back up and return it, and Amazon does not have a good solution for situations when the product that arrives is completely broken or is total junk/DOA.

Post reply on HN