Live data from Hacker News

Where the STEM Jobs Are (and Where They Aren’t)

nytimes.com

1–10 of 16 posts

Re: Where the STEM Jobs Are (and Where They Aren’t)

#3
OK, this is not a geographical thing that I gleaned from the title but more a simple summing of the graduates in the four STEM areas and the number of job openings in those areas.

It appears that in spite of the much touted shortage given as the reason the H1-B program must be expanded that the number of graduates for every field far exceeds the number of job openings except for computer science - where it is roughly the same. Where are these underemployed STEM graduates going - the article points to STEM graduates who gave up on academic careers/paths to go into computer programming/data analysis.

Re: Where the STEM Jobs Are (and Where They Aren’t)

#5
Another in the long line of clickbaits. While it starts out by making a case for lack of non-CS jobs, it slowly devolves into an ad for "Insight Data Science Fellows Program".

Then to avoid being marked as native advertising, it adds info about data sciences division at University of California, Berkeley. The article then ends abruptly without having a satisfying conclusion.

Is it just me or we can't seem to get lot of infomration from the media without some kind of covert advertisement in between?

Re: Where the STEM Jobs Are (and Where They Aren’t)

#6
post #5

Another in the long line of clickbaits. While it starts out by making a case for lack of non-CS jobs, it slowly devolves into an ad for "Insight Data Science Fellows Program". Then to avoid being marked as native advertising, it adds info about data sciences division at University of California, Berkeley. The article then ends abruptly without having a satisfying conclusion. Is it just me or we can't seem to get lot…

http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html

Almost all news is paid for outside of current events and politics (although those sections are biased by the editorial room). Pay enough money and you’ll get into the NYT, it just takes the right PR agency to pitch the story correctly.

Re: Where the STEM Jobs Are (and Where They Aren’t)

#7
Much better data on what people actually do with their majors has been gathered by the Brookings Institution's Hamilton Project. This initiative, published earlier in 2017, looks at career paths for about three million people, major by major. A link is here:

http://www.hamiltonproject.org/charts/median_earnings_for_la...

What Brookings/Hamilton observes ... and the NYT overlooks ... is that lots of people with STEM majors find work in relevant fields that happen to be classified in irrelevant ways. For example, math majors tend to show up as financial analysts, actuaries, high school math teachers, etc.

There's a lot of quant work on Wall Street these days, all of which is classified as financial sector work, even though it's STEM-intensive and miles away from gabbing about mutual funds with retirees.

Re: Where the STEM Jobs Are (and Where They Aren’t)

#9
post #5

Another in the long line of clickbaits. While it starts out by making a case for lack of non-CS jobs, it slowly devolves into an ad for "Insight Data Science Fellows Program". Then to avoid being marked as native advertising, it adds info about data sciences division at University of California, Berkeley. The article then ends abruptly without having a satisfying conclusion. Is it just me or we can't seem to get lot…

News is free. News costs money to produce. Do the math.
Post reply on HN