Live data from Hacker News

Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

smithsonianmag.com

11–20 of 72 posts

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#11
It's been going on longer than the article suggests. When I went trick-or-treating in the 1960s, my parents did not allow us to eat anything that was home-made or not in a sealed package, because they were worried about deliberate poisoning.

Around 1972 or 73 on Halloween, some neighborhood kid found a razor blade in an apple. Turned out he'd inserted it himself as a prank.

A lot of things have much earlier roots than can be found with searches of documents.

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#12
post #8

My kids are very aware that Halloween candy may be poisoned. Every year, after they finish trick-or-treating they will lay the buckets of candy on the table for inspection[1]. I will then taste several packs to make sure they are safe. If I do not show any side effects we conclude that the candy eaten was good. The kids wait patiently for a couple of weeks as I repeat the process and certify that all the candy they b…

This actually just sounds like a really elaborate "tax" on your children's stash. If you fear the candy is actually dangerous, then perhaps you'd be better off just buying some from the store and distributing it to your kids, that ways they don't run the risk of loosing their parent.

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#13
post #8

My kids are very aware that Halloween candy may be poisoned. Every year, after they finish trick-or-treating they will lay the buckets of candy on the table for inspection[1]. I will then taste several packs to make sure they are safe. If I do not show any side effects we conclude that the candy eaten was good. The kids wait patiently for a couple of weeks as I repeat the process and certify that all the candy they b…

This actually just sounds like a really elaborate "tax" on your children's stash. If you fear the candy is actually dangerous, then perhaps you'd be better off just buying some from the store and distributing it to your kids, that ways they don't run the risk of loosing their parent.

Clearly his post was humorous and intended to poke fun at people's paranoia of poisoned candy.

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#14
post #6

And then there’s this headline today on my local news website... Candy laced with bath salts poses risk this Halloween http://www.wral.com/candy-laced-with-bath-salts-poses-risk-t...

No one is spending their money to give your kids free drugs on Halloween. I saw a similar story from the local news channel about marijuana edibles being passed out. As the original article says, poisoned candy is not really a thing. I'd be more concerned about your kids being hit by a drunk (or distracted) driver on Halloween than eating something poisoned.

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#15
post #7

If anyone knows of a good general technique to persuade a person that their fear of something is overblown, I'd be interested in seeing a link. In my experience, trying to do this results in anger.

I find the same attitude has now permiated American politics. You can say something as neutral as, "I'm very cautious of getting riled up by overblown narratives that lack factual evidence or are presented in an obviously inflammatory manner" and suddenly you're the anti-Christ.

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#16

It's been going on longer than the article suggests. When I went trick-or-treating in the 1960s, my parents did not allow us to eat anything that was home-made or not in a sealed package, because they were worried about deliberate poisoning. Around 1972 or 73 on Halloween, some neighborhood kid found a razor blade in an apple. Turned out he'd inserted it himself as a prank. A lot of things have much earlier roots tha…

Back in 2nd grade my friend got a small snickers bar at school that he discovered had a hole in the wrapper and a same size/shape hole also extending further into the candy bar. I recall it being a small squarish kind of hole, you could sort of see it going into the candy bar.

No idea if he did it himself or not, but he never admitted it. It could easily have been some part of a toy that poked into it.

After school we went to his house and cut it to pieces with a knife in his kitchen. It was an exciting adventure, we were eager to see what might be inside. Never found anything, though I'm not sure what we were expecting to find.

We didn't eat it either. But it did freak me out enough as a kid that for awhile after I would check for candy wrapper breaches.

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#17
post #6

And then there’s this headline today on my local news website... Candy laced with bath salts poses risk this Halloween http://www.wral.com/candy-laced-with-bath-salts-poses-risk-t...

This is why people don't trust the media. They make up a story out of nothing or stretch it to to a point where it has no relation to what actually happened. This article for instance is given a title and claim that bath salts are being mixed with candies but provide nothing to back it up. The video points out the drugs are being made to look like candy, not being mixed with it. They pull in two unrelated sources to drive buzz. Police found drugs in Franklin County then the reporter went to their own Sheriff for a generic candy statement. It is about 650 miles between the two counties.

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#18

Seems that Wikipedia is a better starting point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoned_candy_myths I would date my understanding of the myth to be from 1980, informed by a friend's mum, so the myth was oral tradition by then, across the pond in the UK. So a handful of years after 1974 the meme had spread. This had morphed into an 'only in America' story for those of us outside the U.S. - we believed this happened on…

> This had morphed into an 'only in America' story for those of us outside the U.S. - we believed this happened on a regular Halloween basis in America

As an outsider I never got the impression that this actually happened/happens in America, more that this is some strange fear American's have.

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#19
Fears aside, I suspect that the larger tragedy is that Halloween treats are now mostly sugary candy and chocolate. I remember a time when there was much more variety. I also remember how quickly things changed after the first (likely unsubstantiated) scare in my community.

Re: Where Did the Fear of Poisoned Halloween Candy Come From? (2013)

#20
Despite the constant fear mongering of "stranger danger", turns out most people don't actually want to kill you.

One of the things I like about the sharing economy (Uber, Airbnb, etc) is that we're slowly being reminded that it's okay to trust our neighbors, despite the constant attempts by the media to spread fear.

Post reply on HN