Live data from Hacker News

Pingfs: A filesystem where data is stored as ICMP Echo packets (2016)

github.com

41–45 of 45 posts

Re: Pingfs: A filesystem where data is stored as ICMP Echo packets (2016)

#42
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, I’m irritated because of the programmer’s attitude, which is quite systemic in programming and has been for a while.

Well, it's not merited, and you're being rude. I'm saying this as someone who references the POSIX standard several times a week to ensure portability. This kind of tool is a toy project and is by its nature highly dependent on non-portable interfaces.

If you’re against GNU and Linux like I am then it is very much merited.

I utterly fail to see how being honest and direct by expressing my irritation is rude and am both insulted and appalled by what I perceive to be the Anglo-Saxon definition of rude hoisted upon me. I could just as easily turn this around and say that your lack of consideration for what is a different value system is just as rude. The entire argument around “rudeness” is nonsense, I’m not at all sorry to write.

Re: Pingfs: A filesystem where data is stored as ICMP Echo packets (2016)

#43
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, it's not merited, and you're being rude. I'm saying this as someone who references the POSIX standard several times a week to ensure portability. This kind of tool is a toy project and is by its nature highly dependent on non-portable interfaces.

If you’re against GNU and Linux like I am then it is very much merited. I utterly fail to see how being honest and direct by expressing my irritation is rude and am both insulted and appalled by what I perceive to be the Anglo-Saxon definition of rude hoisted upon me. I could just as easily turn this around and say that your lack of consideration for what is a different value system is just as rude. The entire argume…

Buddy, I hate GNU and Linux as much as you do. More, probably. You and I are on the same side here. You can either continue to attempt to extract yourself from me into a special class of person for which your behavior is supposedly acceptable, or take a good look at yourself and decide to be better in the future.

Re: Pingfs: A filesystem where data is stored as ICMP Echo packets (2016)

#44
Of course the gut reaction to this is "why?" and the obvious answer is "because I can"... that's fine, but there's been plenty of filesystems built on protocols or things that weren't really supposed to be filesystems.

I remember way back when gmail first announced giving away 1GB of storage, there were a bunch of hacky things to turn SMTP into a real filesystem.

So, I get the answer to "why make this weird filesystem", but I'd really like to know: why is this weird filesystem, weirder or more intriguing than the others that have come before it.

Re: Pingfs: A filesystem where data is stored as ICMP Echo packets (2016)

#45
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you’re against GNU and Linux like I am then it is very much merited. I utterly fail to see how being honest and direct by expressing my irritation is rude and am both insulted and appalled by what I perceive to be the Anglo-Saxon definition of rude hoisted upon me. I could just as easily turn this around and say that your lack of consideration for what is a different value system is just as rude. The entire argume…

Buddy, I hate GNU and Linux as much as you do. More, probably. You and I are on the same side here. You can either continue to attempt to extract yourself from me into a special class of person for which your behavior is supposedly acceptable, or take a good look at yourself and decide to be better in the future.

I’m not doing anything wrong.
Post reply on HN