Live data from Hacker News

A newly discovered moon tunnel

washingtonpost.com

11–20 of 188 posts

Re: A newly discovered moon tunnel

#11
post #4
post #2

When such discoveries are made who "owns" that real estate?

Whomever can occupy it. Outer Space Treaty prohibits national claims but not use for peaceful purposes. So if you sit on it, you own it.

According to link above the treaty prohibits all sovereign claims.

However, getting there can be made into a reasonable barrier to competition. Sure you can also exploit the moon, but how are you going to get there?

Re: A newly discovered moon tunnel

#12
I wonder how stable such tubes would be? No water erosion, no earthquakes, even though they must have formed at a time that was more geologically active. They could be on the edge of collapse if say, a large vehicle drove in them. Am I wrong?

Just a first thought. Other than that, they could probably serve as a goal for human spaceflight, an intermediate step between walking on the moon and colonizing mars.

Re: A newly discovered moon tunnel

#13
post #2

When such discoveries are made who "owns" that real estate?

"Who Owns the Moon? | Space Law & Outer Space Treaties" - https://www.space.com/33440-space-law.html

We'll see how much those words on papers mean when real value is to be had up there.

Re: A newly discovered moon tunnel

#14
> And many scientists have long dreamed of building bases inside natural moon caves, where lunar explorers might sleep safely in inflatable homes, protected from the storms above.

What "storms" are the authors talking about here?

Re: A newly discovered moon tunnel

#16

> And many scientists have long dreamed of building bases inside natural moon caves, where lunar explorers might sleep safely in inflatable homes, protected from the storms above. What "storms" are the authors talking about here?

Maybe solar storms? The Sun sends out quite a lot of radiation from time to time. Earth is protected by its magnetic field and atmosphere, the Moon and Mars not so much.

Re: A newly discovered moon tunnel

#17

> And many scientists have long dreamed of building bases inside natural moon caves, where lunar explorers might sleep safely in inflatable homes, protected from the storms above. What "storms" are the authors talking about here?

Solar storms, where the danger is solar radiation...same thing we're concerned might cause health risks en route to Mars.

Re: A newly discovered moon tunnel

#18

> And many scientists have long dreamed of building bases inside natural moon caves, where lunar explorers might sleep safely in inflatable homes, protected from the storms above. What "storms" are the authors talking about here?

[deleted]

Re: A newly discovered moon tunnel

#19
post #8

For a more technical description, the paper is here: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/2017GL074998/full . "Detection of intact lava tubes at Marius Hills on the Moon by SELENE (Kaguya) Lunar Radar Sounder" Intact lunar lava tubes offer a pristine environment to conduct scientific examination of the Moon's composition and potentially serve as secure shelters for humans and instruments. We investigated the SE…

If the moon had ancient volcanic activity and thus, why is it, after observable impact from various bodies - shown in the craters all over the surface, and the sumizing of the fact that water was deposited to earth from extra-orbital impacts... does the moon have zero water or atmosphere?

Where did water originate?

(I didn't know how to format that question any better, so please forgive the fumbly format)

Re: A newly discovered moon tunnel

#20

I wonder how stable such tubes would be? No water erosion, no earthquakes, even though they must have formed at a time that was more geologically active. They could be on the edge of collapse if say, a large vehicle drove in them. Am I wrong? Just a first thought. Other than that, they could probably serve as a goal for human spaceflight, an intermediate step between walking on the moon and colonizing mars.

> no earthquakes No but how about moon-quakes? Ok, not geologically active you say. But moon's been bombarded by asteroids it's surface is full of craters. Creating a crater wouldn't that be an equivalent of a moon-quake?
Post reply on HN