Live data from Hacker News

Gov. Jerry Brown signs AB168: bans employers from asking about salary history

ocregister.com

1–10 of 19 posts

Re: Gov. Jerry Brown signs AB168: bans employers from asking about salary history

#5

Good step. Should also remove background checks, credit checks, and drug tests.

Why?

My father-in-law was just embezzled by his accountant. It's mostly been spent, so he will get pennies in the dollar back. (I'm not well versed in legal matters...I had no idea crime could be so profitable, even after you get caught.)

It sucks that he got screwed over, but it'll suck more if the next guy has the same experience.

There must be some kinds of questions employers can be permitted to ask to help this?

Re: Gov. Jerry Brown signs AB168: bans employers from asking about salary history

#6

Good step. Should also remove background checks, credit checks, and drug tests.

Why? My father-in-law was just embezzled by his accountant. It's mostly been spent, so he will get pennies in the dollar back. (I'm not well versed in legal matters...I had no idea crime could be so profitable, even after you get caught.) It sucks that he got screwed over, but it'll suck more if the next guy has the same experience. There must be some kinds of questions employers can be permitted to ask to help this?

Isn't that more of a customer/vendor relationship? Do accountants lose their CPA for stuff like that?

Re: Gov. Jerry Brown signs AB168: bans employers from asking about salary history

#7

Good step. Should also remove background checks, credit checks, and drug tests.

Why? My father-in-law was just embezzled by his accountant. It's mostly been spent, so he will get pennies in the dollar back. (I'm not well versed in legal matters...I had no idea crime could be so profitable, even after you get caught.) It sucks that he got screwed over, but it'll suck more if the next guy has the same experience. There must be some kinds of questions employers can be permitted to ask to help this?

[deleted]

Re: Gov. Jerry Brown signs AB168: bans employers from asking about salary history

#8
Looks like this is the fourth state to make this move, so we should have data by now on how well this actually works. Have the numbers shown up anywhere?

It appears that the "intuitive" ways of reducing wage disparity sometimes have counter-intuitive real-world outcomes. And making the difference you want to make sometimes requires a lot more research and study than just the "there should be a law..." sort of armchair economics.

Re: Gov. Jerry Brown signs AB168: bans employers from asking about salary history

#9

Good step. Should also remove background checks, credit checks, and drug tests.

Why? My father-in-law was just embezzled by his accountant. It's mostly been spent, so he will get pennies in the dollar back. (I'm not well versed in legal matters...I had no idea crime could be so profitable, even after you get caught.) It sucks that he got screwed over, but it'll suck more if the next guy has the same experience. There must be some kinds of questions employers can be permitted to ask to help this?

A background check would have done nothing to warn him. If he ends up in court over it, it will be public record, and that's all you need.
Post reply on HN