Live data from Hacker News

Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

azarask.in

61–70 of 90 posts

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#61
post #29

The fisheyetabs extension has similar goals, at least for avoiding scrolling and making tabs easier to locate (no grouping though). The implementation might not be flawless, but I'd like to think that the concept is sound. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/4845/ Disclaimer: I'm the author of f.e.t.

It's not compatible with Firefox 3.6.7. Will you be updating it?

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#62
post #21
post #13

What's wrong with the Chrome method of opening new tabs right next to the current tab? This way related things tend to stay together. This one "feature" was why I switched to Chrome. This seems like an overly complicated solution in search of a problem.

> What's wrong with the Chrome method of opening new tabs right next to the current tab? Firefox already does this.

It does now? Back when I used Firefox, Firefox did not do that out of the box, so I used the Tabs Open Relative extension.

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#63
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Uh, I massively dislike working with a fat bunch of windows. How can the title of one Firefox window as tab group can be as expressive as a group of tabs you've persisted in Tab Candy with your own label? Indeed I do. One of these days I'll get around to adding an extension that allows me to queue links without opening them in tabs. If you don't know any, i like Read it Later( http://readitlaterlist.com/ ). Anything…

Springpad is pretty good, has mobile clients and all

Springpad makes a great dumptruck-I can throw a bunch of links in it, and than actually organize them, unlike with something like Instapaper. I can also put books, todos, etc in with the bookmarks. No, I dont work for them, just a recent convert.

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#64
post #60

I just realized that Aza Raskin is Jef Raskin's son. One of Jef's main locus of attention was the zooming user interface (ZUI). This centers around the fact that an interface doesn't really have to have borders at all, just the ability to zoom. Zoom in to get detail; zoom out to view more of the world. Tab Candy is Jef's ZUI brought to the web browser. Cool!

Man, did he have anything to do with Prezi? The zooming/boarderless idea just seems so fitting. It was a great day in UI when that started catching on.

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#65
Pretty cool demo. I use Vimperator[1] to do most of my browsing. The experience is quite good. It would be interesting if Tab Candy will have apis to drive these features. Then vimperator commands could call them like,

:group Work - current tab into the Work group

:switch Todo - switch to the Todo group

etc

The features look great. But after using Vimperator, I prefer keyboard alternatives to the drag-and-drop stuff shown.

[1] - http://vimperator.org

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#66
The tab grouping feature seems like it would be useful for me. It would be nice if the groups/pages were saved as folders/bookmarks so it could be retrieved later. They never mentioned what happens when FF was closed. And also if they could display the bookmarks/folders in the same fashion.

I am NOT interested in them looking into what pages I go to or my searches so they can direct ads or price search results. Data sharing should only be to people I know AND approve in advance.

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#67
This whole effort is misguided. I can't fathom wanting to name a group of tabs. As it is I barely ever take the initiative to organize bookmarks, and those are permanent.

People don't need a filing cabinet for something that should be ephemeral and self-limiting. When your desk gets buried under a skin of receipts, junk mail envelopes, and water-ringed Economists from last May, the only proper organizational tool is a trash can. Tabs are just a modern incarnation of the same problem.

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#68
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yup. So does Firefox. (And Opera, for that matter... Chrome did not invent these features.)

The shipping version of Firefox when Chrome was first released absolutely did not have this feature. It was a regular pain in my ass. The ability to poof a tab out into a new window without reloading the contents was added to Firefox in the interim.

That's correct. Tear-off tabs were added to Firefox in version 3.5, which was released several months after Chrome 1.0.

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#69
post #59

"We need a way to organize browsing, to see all of our tabs at once, and focus on the task at hand. In short, we need a way to get back control of our online lives." Will power? Priorities? Reducing friction or eliminating annoyances is not always a good thing, and may not accomplish what you want. Worse, it may give you undesirable side-effects. For example, people complain about freeway traffic, how it takes too lo…

Too many tabs has never been an issue for me. Can anyone actually read more than one tab at once? If you're thinking of buying a DSLR, then focus on researching cameras. Close those tabs when you're done. Exercise restraint, guys. Tab grouping is the classic engineer's solution to a non-problem.

Open a new window, drag any existing tabs into that window. The solution already exists.

Re: Tab Candy: Mozilla Labs is making Firefox tabs sweet

#70

This whole effort is misguided. I can't fathom wanting to name a group of tabs. As it is I barely ever take the initiative to organize bookmarks, and those are permanent. People don't need a filing cabinet for something that should be ephemeral and self-limiting. When your desk gets buried under a skin of receipts, junk mail envelopes, and water-ringed Economists from last May, the only proper organizational tool is…

Sure, but the trashcan is the "proper organizational tool" only because a better solution doesn't exist yet, not because it solves the problem optimally. Isn't there some reason that copy of the Economist is sitting on your desk in the first place? Presumably you do want to read the interesting articles in it, and it'd be handy if the most interesting ones were somehow brought to you.

Now, Tab Candy doesn't do that, but I think it's at least a step in the right direction of trying to address the cases that are somewhere between "garbage collect the tab" and "immediately use the tab".

Post reply on HN