Live data from Hacker News

Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

theguardian.com

11–20 of 86 posts

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#11

You guys should consider donating to the International Anti-Poaching Foundation[0][1] which fights these poachers. The founder, Damien Mander[2], is an Australian ex spec-ops sniper who is using his military experience to train the park rangers since they, unlike the poachers, tend to be poorly equipped and trained as well as understaffed. There is also the David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust[3][4] which takes care of ele…

Out of curiosity, are these organizations literally fighting poachers? I.e. we're saying that an elephant's life is more valuable than a human's? That's an interesting moral question.

Eh, play stupid games, win stupid prizes.

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How did the west acquire their elephants?

As families. Not condoning it, but these young elephants are pretty likely to die.

Ah. So if China were to capture entire families of elephants, you'd be ok with it?

I'm just trying to determine where the line is.

I went to a zoo a couple months ago. The elephants' tusks were cut, presumably so that the elephants wouldn't be able to impale each other. That was a bit too sad for me to want to go back to zoos anymore.

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#13

You guys should consider donating to the International Anti-Poaching Foundation[0][1] which fights these poachers. The founder, Damien Mander[2], is an Australian ex spec-ops sniper who is using his military experience to train the park rangers since they, unlike the poachers, tend to be poorly equipped and trained as well as understaffed. There is also the David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust[3][4] which takes care of ele…

Out of curiosity, are these organizations literally fighting poachers? I.e. we're saying that an elephant's life is more valuable than a human's? That's an interesting moral question.

Yes, they are. The countries that have a shoot on sight policy for poachers tend to have very low poaching rates.

> That's an interesting moral question.

It's not actually. The poaching groups are connected to the likes of Boko Haram http://www.nationalgeographic.com/tracking-ivory/article.htm.... So it's two birds with one stone really.

Also the poachers kill anti-poachers regularly

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/apr/25/two-wild...

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/aug/17/leading-...

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#14

You guys should consider donating to the International Anti-Poaching Foundation[0][1] which fights these poachers. The founder, Damien Mander[2], is an Australian ex spec-ops sniper who is using his military experience to train the park rangers since they, unlike the poachers, tend to be poorly equipped and trained as well as understaffed. There is also the David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust[3][4] which takes care of ele…

Out of curiosity, are these organizations literally fighting poachers? I.e. we're saying that an elephant's life is more valuable than a human's? That's an interesting moral question.

Is it so interesting? I'm sure they would apprehend poachers without violence if they had any reason to believe the poachers wouldn't fight for their freedom.

It's a bit like asking whether a human life is more valuable than a sack of money when a bank robber goes down shooting. Either law enforcement has teeth or there are no laws.

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#15

You guys should consider donating to the International Anti-Poaching Foundation[0][1] which fights these poachers. The founder, Damien Mander[2], is an Australian ex spec-ops sniper who is using his military experience to train the park rangers since they, unlike the poachers, tend to be poorly equipped and trained as well as understaffed. There is also the David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust[3][4] which takes care of ele…

Out of curiosity, are these organizations literally fighting poachers? I.e. we're saying that an elephant's life is more valuable than a human's? That's an interesting moral question.

Harmers are less valuable than victims, regardless of species. All consciousness should be respected.

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#16
I think they are just getting them where and while the getting is good, and the one being stomped by a boot wasn't about to get out of the cart or something.

If it's legal and is good money -- what are you going to do? Get it to be little money, or illegal and too much trouble. If reducing this phenomenon is your goal, that is.

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As families. Not condoning it, but these young elephants are pretty likely to die.

Ah. So if China were to capture entire families of elephants, you'd be ok with it? I'm just trying to determine where the line is. I went to a zoo a couple months ago. The elephants' tusks were cut, presumably so that the elephants wouldn't be able to impale each other. That was a bit too sad for me to want to go back to zoos anymore.

> The elephants' tusks were cut, presumably so that the elephants wouldn't be able to impale each other. That was a bit too sad for me to want to go back to zoos anymore.

Hint: the same is being done in mass animal production - pigs have their tails capped to prevent cannibalism from boredom, and chickens get "debeaked" (yeah it's an actual word). Male chicks actually get gassed or shredded alive (!) to death right after hatching because they're fairly useless for the meat production. Sows are often restricted in movement after giving birth so they cannot accidentally crush the piglets due to the litters being too large, and the conditions on transports to slaughterhouses... let's just say that's bordering on torture.

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As families. Not condoning it, but these young elephants are pretty likely to die.

Ah. So if China were to capture entire families of elephants, you'd be ok with it? I'm just trying to determine where the line is. I went to a zoo a couple months ago. The elephants' tusks were cut, presumably so that the elephants wouldn't be able to impale each other. That was a bit too sad for me to want to go back to zoos anymore.

> Ah. So if China were to capture entire families of elephants, you'd be ok with it?

Ok? No. It would be slightly less terrible though. And if the elephants had "ok" living conditions, not like cages where they can't move.

> I'm just trying to determine where the line is.

Like with most things, there isn't really one.

> I went to a zoo a couple months ago. The elephants' tusks were cut, presumably so that the elephants wouldn't be able to impale each other. That was a bit too sad for me to want to go back to zoos anymore.

I don't go to zoos and I wish they were closed.

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ah. So if China were to capture entire families of elephants, you'd be ok with it? I'm just trying to determine where the line is. I went to a zoo a couple months ago. The elephants' tusks were cut, presumably so that the elephants wouldn't be able to impale each other. That was a bit too sad for me to want to go back to zoos anymore.

> The elephants' tusks were cut, presumably so that the elephants wouldn't be able to impale each other. That was a bit too sad for me to want to go back to zoos anymore. Hint: the same is being done in mass animal production - pigs have their tails capped to prevent cannibalism from boredom, and chickens get "debeaked" (yeah it's an actual word). Male chicks actually get gassed or shredded alive (!) to death right a…

True. Also, it occurred to me just now that maybe the elephants' tusks were already cut before they arrived at the zoo, and the zoo was protecting them. So I don't know enough about it.

Re: Footage shows young elephants being captured for Chinese zoos

#20

You guys should consider donating to the International Anti-Poaching Foundation[0][1] which fights these poachers. The founder, Damien Mander[2], is an Australian ex spec-ops sniper who is using his military experience to train the park rangers since they, unlike the poachers, tend to be poorly equipped and trained as well as understaffed. There is also the David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust[3][4] which takes care of ele…

Out of curiosity, are these organizations literally fighting poachers? I.e. we're saying that an elephant's life is more valuable than a human's? That's an interesting moral question.

A few years ago I was on a trip in Tanzania, visiting Ngorongoro Crater. At one point, high up on the crater rim, the guide pulled the Land Rover to the side of the road to give a ride to a couple of uniformed "park rangers". They were dealing with "reports of poachers", and each was carrying an AK-47. It was unclear whether actual shooting was part of their remit; they were not talkative.
Post reply on HN