Live data from Hacker News

Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

motherboard.vice.com

11–20 of 137 posts

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#11
On the other hand, people often see themself as unselfish when in fact they are highly emotionally dependent on other people instead of being self-sufficient.

This path would lead directly to depression when you find out that the person you are emotionally dependent on isn't going to dedicate themself to making world look just to you.

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#12

On the other hand, people often see themself as unselfish when in fact they are highly emotionally dependent on other people instead of being self-sufficient. This path would lead directly to depression when you find out that the person you are emotionally dependent on isn't going to dedicate themself to making world look just to you.

Agreed. A lot of people who call themselves unselfish seem to just not be able to decide things on their own.

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#13

On the other hand, people often see themself as unselfish when in fact they are highly emotionally dependent on other people instead of being self-sufficient. This path would lead directly to depression when you find out that the person you are emotionally dependent on isn't going to dedicate themself to making world look just to you.

[deleted]

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#14

On the other hand, people often see themself as unselfish when in fact they are highly emotionally dependent on other people instead of being self-sufficient. This path would lead directly to depression when you find out that the person you are emotionally dependent on isn't going to dedicate themself to making world look just to you.

on the other hand you're a jerk

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#15

The point here seems to be that unselfish people are more empathetic to the plight of others. while I don't disagree I wonder if unselfishness leads people into situations where they work towards others benefit (people they perceive as being treated unfairly) at their own detriment also possibly leading to issues with depression. That's the point I presumed the article would make before I read it.

The article resonated with me. I find inequality very upsetting and can be prone to depression. I wouldn't say that the depression is caused by a lack of reciprocity in others. If anything I've found that almost everyone, even otherwise 'selfish' people, can be extremely generous if they view you as someone who does good by others. I'm also no fool if I know someone is trying to rip me off.

I do think the depression comes from thinking about someone's situation, thinking "wow, that would be really sad/stressful/aggravating" and then starting to feel those emotions myself quite strongly. I would also say this tendency in myself increased a lot after becoming a parent. Avoiding reading the news has helped considerably, although that's not a great solution.

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#16

On the other hand, people often see themself as unselfish when in fact they are highly emotionally dependent on other people instead of being self-sufficient. This path would lead directly to depression when you find out that the person you are emotionally dependent on isn't going to dedicate themself to making world look just to you.

I'd love to read more literature about this phenomenon. Do you have any?

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#17
Canary in the coal mine.

Depression may be a social illness because people with heighten empathy feel something is wrong with the system around them resulting in depression.

That seems a stronger argument then some macro economic argument about ill defined inequality.

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#18
post #12

On the other hand, people often see themself as unselfish when in fact they are highly emotionally dependent on other people instead of being self-sufficient. This path would lead directly to depression when you find out that the person you are emotionally dependent on isn't going to dedicate themself to making world look just to you.

Agreed. A lot of people who call themselves unselfish seem to just not be able to decide things on their own.

This seems to me less like an observable phenomenon and more an excuse to extend an argument that unselfish people are actually just selfish people, and therefore "selfish" people aren't real.

Sorry if I'm reading too much into it, but this reads like the preamble to at least 10 articles people have handed to me in defense of Ayn Rand.

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#19

On the other hand, people often see themself as unselfish when in fact they are highly emotionally dependent on other people instead of being self-sufficient. This path would lead directly to depression when you find out that the person you are emotionally dependent on isn't going to dedicate themself to making world look just to you.

The study is about people being unselfish, not about people seeing themself as unselfish.

Re: Unselfish People Are More Likely to Wind Up with Depression

#20
I can't tell where they flipped the directionality around for the headline, because the first line of the article is "People with depression are more likely to feel bad in response to perceived inequality" and the rest of the article sticks to that finding. It seems intuitive that people with depression are more likely to feel bad in response to X, for all X.
Post reply on HN