Live data from Hacker News

Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu

121–130 of 163 posts

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#121

I come from a blue collar family and was one of the first to take a white collar job in 2007. I planned on making a long term commitment to my first employer, but spent 6 years fighting tooth and nail for more responsibility and money. Eventually I had enough and tried jumping into contracting (but ended up in consulting). At this point my career and pay went through the roof. I'm making (literally) twice as much mon…

This!

It reminds me of a great Clay Shirky essay:

http://www.shirky.com/weblog/2013/11/healthcare-gov-and-the-...

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#122
post #96
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I do. Rather that than fill in holiday forms, attend company meetings, have annual performance reviews etc etc.

Yeah, but you don't risk going to jail just because you're bad at bookkeeping.

Bookkeeping for small-time consulting isn't very difficult, even then if you mess it up, the IRS will just ask for the difference

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#123
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, those are your metrics. Your goals don't match those of the system. Ill defined terms like big losers don't really help. I don't think anyone would argue the system is perfect. I'd conclude that it's not nearly as bad as you seem to think it is. By being a part of the system, you're already better off than some 40% of the globe, by default.

taking your argument to its logical extreme, the goals of the system are met so long as the median and averages look favorable relative to other countries... an ultra wealthy 1% can offset the relative lack of wealth in the rest of the 99% and the median can still look good - I think this is the point you may have been missing above

> an ultra wealthy 1% can offset the relative lack of wealth in the rest of the 99%

Citizens of western nations (the US in particular, median income there puts you among the .3% globally) and the rest of the globe have a similar dynamic yet I have seen no westerners who proclaim the evils of income inequality attempt to resolve that disparity, in fact they seem set to increase their own income making the problem worse. Thus I don't take that argument on it's face as a serious one.

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#124
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe I'm not an entrpreneur if I don't actively think of that place that way. I mean I don't know the logistics of the supply of restaurants. Closest thing would be POS/menus for cooking those look realtively old or maybe it's one of those "does its job no need to fix". Haha the restaurant industry for me is like purgatory haha I look forward to the day that I work as a developer full time. Poverty is my never endin…

Just an idea, why have a POS system at all? Why have a waitstaff that take orders? Why not just give the orders to the cooks and eliminate mistakes made by servers? What about in-kitchen optimizations? What about reducing spoilage? The possible places to improve are limited mostly by your imagination. What complaints do the bossss have? What do the workers complain about most? Those are rhetorical questions, I don't…

Here's a tip: Try not to come up with ideas that are going to put large groups of people out of a job.

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#125
post #11

I've done mostly contract work because I liked the freedom when I was younger. Now I notice a lot of people my age have moved on to management or jobs "higher on the ladder" while I stress about the uncertainty of income when contracts end. I assume the lifestyle might suit people who are extraordinarily good networkers, but I feel mostly tired these days. My younger self didn't know about the fatigue the responsibil…

I worked contract for a while in NYC. The pay was great but the contract was abruptly terminated with just a few days notice about a year or so in. I landed on my feet but don't think I'd go contract again because as a single individual things can get pretty stressful, as you mentioned. It seems to work pretty nicely, however, if you have a partner that has a stable, full-time gig while you work contract. The full-ti…

Re: Having a partner with a "stable" coporate job.

I agree that this is helpful. When I was looking into going solo/freelancing in the legal field, I asked several solo lawyers how they provided health benefits for their families. All of them said that their spouse had a corporate job with good benefits.

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#126
post #11

I've done mostly contract work because I liked the freedom when I was younger. Now I notice a lot of people my age have moved on to management or jobs "higher on the ladder" while I stress about the uncertainty of income when contracts end. I assume the lifestyle might suit people who are extraordinarily good networkers, but I feel mostly tired these days. My younger self didn't know about the fatigue the responsibil…

I think you have captured technical contract work accurately.

In my experience the people I've met who only wanted to do contracting appreciated the clear specification of the work required, the lack of competition with other people in the office, and the simplicity of working when they wanted to and not working when they didn't want to. That contrasted with people who wanted to be full time because they were looking to evolve with the job or experience a wide array of roles. They were looking to "grow with the company" either in a technical leadership sort of way or a company leadership sort of way. The founder/entrepreneur is a sort of outlier in that they have some vision/idea of what they are trying to build and their world is wrapped around that rather than their career or monetary goals.

That is completely different than the rise of locally outsourced labor where a company hires a janitorial company who contracts out for janitors. At least in the Bay area you can pretty much contract out almost all of the non-technical stuff, from HR to building operation and security. I hadn't thought a whole lot about that until the Times article about janitorial staff as employees and as contractors. I cannot imagine (although I recognize it is possible) a contract janitor for ABC Janitorial being able to ask a line manager if there were programming tasks they could try at the company. Or to switch from janitorial to adminstrative assistant or security guard to sales. Sadly, I don't have access any more to the contract I signed when I hired a janitorial company for keeping the Blekko offices clean. Because now I am curious if there were in prohibitions in that contract that would have prevented me from hiring any of their contractors as employees.

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Trying to find references for this, I've found a New York Times article(1) that claims that upwards social mobility has not changed in 50 years. The article points to the research site(2), where they say: > Our work shows that children's prospects of earning more than their parents have fallen from 90% to 50% over the past half century. Is the second source referring to absolute mobility? (1) https://www.nytimes.com/…

I think perhaps he overstated the effect but this article will give you a bunch of information on social mobility in the US. http://www.politifact.com/florida/statements/2014/nov/06/jeb...

Amazing, thanks!

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#128
Any time you can earn more than you spend, and take advantage of compound interest (index funds, etc), you could eventually become rich, i.e. upward mobility.

In terms of jobs, it seems there are fewer guarantees and fewer formulas to follow (you used to be able to work somewhere for 30 years and count on a pension).

Upward mobility is still alive and well, but it's through self education and using the internet. Constantly improving is the only way to beat the game. Discipline, etc.

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel an odd magnetic sway towards the future envisioned in Neil Stephenson's "Snow Crash" where the gig-economy IS the economy.

What could be more alluring, living in a shipping container in one of the shanty slums most of Snow Crash's people live in or being one of the lucky few to live in a corporate enclave? I'm just glad we're going to have the opportunity to live in a cyber-punk dystopia!!!

I just started reading Snow Crash, really loving it.

Re: Is the Rise of Contract Workers Killing Upward Mobility?

#130
post #17
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a contractor in the UK I feel like I have better pay and prospects than 90% of staff members. Not 'promotion', but more respect for my expertise and more choice about my working practices. 'Promotion' is not something I've often observed happening in any of the software departments I've worked with of late. It does scare me when people say things like "40+ contractors still working as engineers", as if 40 is old.…

Is contracting in the US the same thing as contracting in the UK? The article doesn't seem to explain what a contractor is.

Well, for one, there's a difference between contracting as a professional, and contracting as a driver for Uber, etc.
Post reply on HN